Best Dress Shoes Reviewed and Tested for Comfort

Whether you’re going out to a formal event, a nice dinner date, or simply need to dress up for your job, there are a great number of things that go into the process of creating the perfect outfit. Between your hair, shirt, pants, accessories, and more, so much more work and planning is required than simply throwing something together in the pinch of any eye. And, to some people’s surprise, one of the most important aspect of an outfit like this is the shoe that you wear.

This rule applies to both men and women, and we can’t stress enough how important a dress shoe is when you’re constructing just such an outfit. The reasoning behind this is due to a couple of reasons. First off, you need to ensure that your shoe compliments the rest of your outfit. A poor-looking shoe with an otherwise stellar outfit will stick out like a sore thumb, causing your whole look to collapse. Additionally, a good dress shoe needs to be comfortable. If you’re going to be doing an excess amount of standing and/or walking while wearing your dress shoes, ensuring that your feet stay healthy and comfortable is critically important. Looking great is one thing, but it won’t do you any good if your feet are in constant pain.

That’s a lot of things to keep in mind, and it isn’t helped by the fact that there are thousands upon thousands of various dress shoes out there. That’s where we come into play. We’ve scoured Amazon for the top 10 best choices available, and we’ll be talking about each shoe in detail in this list. The first 5 items will be dress shoes for men, whereas the last 5 will focus on dress shoes that are made for women. Without any further ado, here are the top 10 best dress shoes that you can buy.

Our Top Picks for Men
Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford
  • Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Comfort gel footbed
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Calvin Klein Men's Ballard Leather Boot
  • Calvin Klein Men's Ballard Leather Boot
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Genuine leather upper
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Bostonian Men's Bolton Dress Slip-On
  • Bostonian Men's Bolton Dress Slip-On
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Elasticized entry
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

Best Dress Shoes For Men

1. Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford

Read Reviews & Buy on
To kick off our list, we're going to be looking at the Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford. This particular shoe is constructed out of genuine leather, meaning it doesn't only look stunning, but it also extremely durable.
Expand to see more
The heel of the shoes measures in at just about 1-inch, and the sole is made out of a synthetic material. The outsole is non-marking, ensuring that it continues to look good throughout years of ownership, and the comfort gel footbed will help to keep your feet extremely comfortable throughout even the longest nights.

Focusing more on the actual look of the shoe, the Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford has a design that's home to a medallion toe and a five-eye lace-up. The overall look here is that of a traditionally-brogued wingtip oxford, and the final look is rather stunning. Additionally, there are three different colors to choose from - Cognac, Black, and Brown. All of these finishes look phenomenal, meaning that you can get a pair to match any outfit you decide to wear!

Depending on the size and color you select, the Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxfords will run a bit differently in price. While the cost may sound a bit high, what you're getting are a pair of shoes that are extremely well-made, durable, great-looking, and very comfortable on your feet.
Pros
  • Constructed out of genuine leather
  • Stunning look
  • Extremely durable
Cons
  • None

2. Dockers Men's Proposal Run Off Slip-On Loafer

Read Reviews & Buy on
Oxfords are one of the most popular types of dress shoes for men, but we're very aware that there are a lot of guys out there who simply aren't a fan of the way those type of shoes look.
Expand to see more
If you're just such a man, you might want to consider checking out the Dockers Men's Proposal Run Off Slip-On Loafer. As with the shoe above, this pair by Dockers is made out of genuine leather, and uses a synthetic sole on the bottom. The shaft measures in at around 2.5-inches from the arch, the heel comes in at 1.25-inches, and the platform at 0.5-inches.

When reading through the reviews of this shoe on Amazon, it's easy to see that the Proposal Run Off is an incredibly durable shoe. Even after multiple years of use, owners have reported that their pair continue to look great with minimal signs of wear and tear. Additionally, Dockers' All Motion Comfort technology should help to ensure that you feet don't get fatigued or worn out while wearing these.

One thing worth noting is that these shoes appear to run a bit small in the size department. Judging from many reviews, ordering a full size down from what you usually get could prove to be the ticket, due to the stretchy nature of the shoe.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Incredibly durable shoe
  • Stylish
Cons
  • Not as durable

3. Dockers Men's Gordon Cap-Toe Oxford

Read Reviews & Buy on
Although we already looked at an oxford-style shoe on our list, the overall design for this particular one is a bit different than the one made by Nunn Bush. While it still features all of the major aspects that you would expect from an oxford, there are no fancy patterns or anything to found on this shoe.
Expand to see more
It's much more subdued and laid-back, with the only noticeable design cue being the nice leather stitching that goes around the entire body. It's simple, sure, but it's also very elegant.

The top and inside of the shoe is made out of leather, yet a rubber construction is used for the sole of the shoe. Additionally, this shoe features a cap-toe design, and a padded collar/insole. All of these items come together to create a shoe that not only has the looks, but also has your back when it comes to ensuring your feet stay nice and comfy throughout the day.

Perhaps one of the best aspects of this shoe is the price. While many dress shoes can cost quite a bit, the Dockers Men's Gordon Cap-Toe Oxfords actually have a reasonable price point. And, despite its lower price tag, you're still getting an incredibly built shoe. If you're looking for style and comfort while on a bit of a budget, this just might be the perfect choice for you.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Nice leather stitching
  • Very comfortable
Cons
  • Fragile contruction

4. Bostonian Men's Bolton Dress Slip-On

Read Reviews & Buy on
There's no doubt that a dress shoe needs to have great looks, but as we mentioned in the intro to this list, superb comfort is equally important - if not more so to some people.
Expand to see more
If you understand the importance of a dress shoe needing to look good, but also want to make sure you get the most comfortable shoe possible, what are your options? While there are certainly no shortage of choices out there, one of your best bets is going to be with the Bostonian Men's Bolton Dress Slip-On.

The shoe is made out of genuine leather, and the sole is made up of a synthetic material. The shaft measures in at around around 2.53-inches from the arch of the shoe, and the entry features an elasticized goring for added convenience whether you're putting the shoe on or taking it off. Combine this with double-needle stitching along the entire top of the shoe, and we're already looking at a pretty nice package.

We're just getting started though, as this shoe excels when it comes to comfort features. First off, the padded collar around the entry of the shoe adds a nice bit of comfort to the top part of your foot. Also included here though is a roomy space inside the shoe for your toes, a nicely cushioned footbed, and a traction sole. Top this off with shock-absorbing technology, and you're looking at one of the most comfortable dress shoes that you're going to find!
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • The sole is made up of a synthetic material
  • Comfortable
Cons
  • None

5. Calvin Klein Men's Ballard Leather Chukka Boot

Read Reviews & Buy on
For the final men's dress shoe on our list, we're going to be taking a look at something a bit different. This shoe by Calvin Klein features the form factor of a chukka boot silhouette, in addition to a plain toe design.
Expand to see more
The boot is made out of real leather, and the shaft measures in at 4-inches from the arch. All of this in addition to the lace-up front and blind eyelets make for a shoe/boot that really stands out from everything else so far on this list.

As great-looking as these shoes are, there is one thing that needs to be mentioned. The shoes are very narrow by design, so those with wider feet will probably have a hard time finding the right fit for them. Calvin Klein intended these shoes be narrow, so it isn't really a design flaw, it's simply the nature of how the shoes were built. Narrow or average-sized feet should be perfectly mine, but you might want to set your sites elsewhere if your feet are particularly wide.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Comfortable
  • Stylish
Cons
  • Not suitable for wide feet

Best Fashion Sneakers For Women

Our Top Picks for Women
LifeStride Women's Seamless Pump
  • LifeStride Women's Seamless Pump
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Bonnibel Wonda-2 Women's Peep Toe
  • Bonnibel Wonda-2 Women's Peep Toe
  • 4 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Ellie Shoes Women's 254 Lucille Pump
  • Ellie Shoes Women's 254 Lucille Pump
  • 4 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

1. LifeStride Women's Seamless Dress Pump

Read Reviews & Buy on
And, finally, the last women's dress shoe on our list follows the theme of paying a little bit more money for a shoe that has a whole lot more to offer. The name of said shoe is the LifeStride Women's Seamless Dress Pump, and boy is it a looker.
Expand to see more
Before we get into any of the features that this shoe has to offer, the sheer look of this thing is already an eye-catcher. We're dealing with a heel design that measure 2.5-inches off of the ground, and the 15 different color choices help to ensure that there's something here for everyone. The overall look of this thing combines a nice combination of simplicity and style into one, great-looking package.

As for some of the features the LifeStride Women's Seamless Dress Pump has to offer, we're looking at a flexible sole, traction outsole, and LifeStride's exclusive Soft System technology. These features all come together to create a shoe that feels great on your foot, is extremely comfortable even during the longest of days, and wills stay snug and secure on any surface you happen to be walking on.
Pros
  • 15 different color choices
  • Flexible sole
  • Traction outsole
Cons
  • Not suitable for wide feet

2. Bonnibel Wonda-2 Women's Peep Toe Low Heel Glitter Slip On Dress Pumps

Read Reviews & Buy on
What if you're in the market for something a bit flashy? Retro designs are one thing, but there's something to be said for a nice dress shoe that's a bit of the more vibrant side of things in regards to its design.
Expand to see more
This next pair of shoes are made up out of a synthetic material. While we would have preferred to see leather, you might be a bit forgiving of the synthetic material after we mention the price. Before that though, there are other things we need to talk about.

For starters, height of the heel on this shoe is abut 2.5-inches off of the ground. The form factor used here is that of a slip-on with no straps to speak of, the the glitter pattern all along the front of the shoe looks quite fantastic. One point worth noting is how the shoes are sized. Bonnibel recommends themselves that the shoes run a bit large, and it appears that ordering a size smaller than you normally do should do the trick when it comes to finding the perfect fit.

And, as for the price, these dress shoes by Bonnibel are incredibly affordable. Depending on the color and size you end up choosing, these come with a fairly low price tag attached. Although we don't have the same premium materials that we've seen in other dress shoes on this list, there's no doubt that that's an incredibly low price point for a shoe of this caliber. If you're on a tight budget but still want a dress shoe that will help you feet stand out from the crowd, look no further than this one right here.
Pros
  • Glitter pattern 
  • Comfortable
  • Sturdy
Cons
  • All sizes are larger

3. Ellie Shoes Women's 254 Lucille Dress Pump

Read Reviews & Buy on
Now that we've looked at the 5 best men's dress shoes out there, it's time to focus on the ladies. A nice dress shoe for a woman's outfit is just as important to that of a man's, if not more so.
Expand to see more
And, just like with men's dress shoes, the same rules apply here. Dress shoes for women need to not only look great, but also need to keep your feet comfortable while being worn. The first shoe on our list that hits both of these notes perfectly is the Ellie Shoes Women's 254 Lucille Dress Pump.

The overall look of the shoes are quite nice. They're technically heels, and feature materials of both leather and satin. The sculpted heel, round toe, and t-strap design work nicely with these materials to deliver a heel that is simplistic and gorgeous at the same time - no small feat by an stretch of the imagination. The design language here is very similar to something you would find a flapper wearing in the 1920's, and we're okay with admitting that we're big fans of the classic, throwback design.

Along with the great looks, a large majority of the reviews on Amazon report that the shoes are also incredibly comfortable to wear. The rubber sole on the bottom is most likely one of the biggest contributing factors to this, as it helps to ensure you have a solid grip on any and all types of surfaces. One thing worth mentioning though is the sizing of the shoe. It appears that the Lucille Dress Pumps tend to run a little small, but ordering about a half size up from what you normally get should provide for a perfect fit.
Pros
  • Stylish design
  • Comfortable
  • Great price value
Cons
  • Ordering a half a size smaller

4. Aerosoles Women's Arivederci Dress Pump

Read Reviews & Buy on
Being able to score a solid pair of dress shoes for an incredibly low price is an insanely rewarding feeling, no doubt about it at all. And, if you really need to keep a close eye on your budget, these previous two options might be lifesavers for you.
Expand to see more
For this next shoe, however, we're going to kick things up a notch. While there's nothing inherently wrong or bad with the last two shoes we reviewed, it's no secret that spending a bit more money will score you with a much higher-end dress shoe. The next shoe on our list is more expensive than our last options, but the higher price you pay is very well justified when you consider everything that comes included.

The shoe in question is the Aerosoles Women's Arivederci Dress Pump, and boy does this shoe have a lot that it's packing in. Right off the bat, the shoe is made up out of real, genuine leather. The sole of the shoe is made out of a synthetic material, and the heel of this particular pump measures in at around 2-inches. That's all fine and dandy, but it's also stuff we've seen on many of the other shoes on our list. So, what exactly does the Arivederci have to make it stand out?

One of these standout features comes in the form of the double-padded Memory Foam that's found in the insole of the shoe. The Memory Foam technology is able to form to the exact shape of your foot, and in turn provides some of the best comfort you'll find in a shoe of any kind. Additional, the heel rest technology helps to distribute your body weight throughout the entire heel, helping to keep any and all stress off of the balls of your feet. To top these off, other features include Aerosoles' Diamond Flex Sole technology for a sturdy grip when walking, diamond pattern sole, and a microfiber sock liner in the insole.

All of these features come together to form a shoe that is able to provide unparalleled comfort in a pretty striking overall package. The Arivederci Dress Pumps can be found on amazon for a pretty decent price, as far as dress shoes go
Pros
  • Double-padded Memory Foam 
  • Diamond pattern sole
  • Microfiber sock liner in the insole
Cons
  • Expensive

5. Ollio Women's Shoe Classic Lace Up Dress Low Flat Heel Oxford

Read Reviews & Buy on
What if you're in the market for something a bit flashy? Retro designs are one thing, but there's something to be said for a nice dress shoe that's a bit of the more vibrant side of things in regards to its design.
Expand to see more
This next pair of shoes are made up out of a synthetic material. While we would have preferred to see leather, you might be a bit forgiving of the synthetic material after we mention the price. Before that though, there are other things we need to talk about.

For starters, height of the heel on this shoe is abut 2.5-inches off of the ground. The form factor used here is that of a slip-on with no straps to speak of, the the glitter pattern all along the front of the shoe looks quite fantastic. One point worth noting is how the shoes are sized. Bonnibel recommends themselves that the shoes run a bit large, and it appears that ordering a size smaller than you normally do should do the trick when it comes to finding the perfect fit.

And, as for the price, these dress shoes by Bonnibel are incredibly affordable. Depending on the color and size you end up choosing, these come with a fairly low price tag attached. Although we don't have the same premium materials that we've seen in other dress shoes on this list, there's no doubt that that's an incredibly low price point for a shoe of this caliber. If you're on a tight budget but still want a dress shoe that will help you feet stand out from the crowd, look no further than this one right here.
Pros
  • Stylish
  • Comfortable
  • Inexpensive
Cons
  • Not made of leather