Best Oxfords Shoes Reviewed and Tested for Comfort

The type of shoe that you wear can say a lot about you. Who you are, your taste in appearance, what you do for a living, and so much more can all be determined by shoe that you wear. While a shoe isn’t necessarily the one defining factor of your attire, it is certainly one of the most important aspects when it comes to your wardrobe.

Shoes can send a message, and if you want to send a message of class, elegance, professionalism, and uniqueness, few shoes do a better job than that of an Oxford. This particular style is characterized by their distinctive look, more specifically in regards to their closed lacing system, exposed ankle, and low-heeled design cues.

Today’s Oxfords shoes are available for both men and women, and today we will be reviewing the top 10 currently available – the first 5 being the top choices of oxfords shoes for men, and the last 5 focusing on the best ones for women. We have a lot of ground to cover, so let’s get started.

Our Top Picks
Dream Paris Lexington
  • Dream Paris Lexington
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • TPR Rubber Sole
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Giorgio Brutini Vick
  • Giorgio Brutini Vick
  • 4 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Flexible sole
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review
Nunn Bush Nelson
  • Nunn Bush Nelson
  • 4 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Comfort gel footbed
  • Price: See Here
Check on Amazon!
Jump to Full Review

 

1. Dream Paris Lexington Women's New Casual Nubuck Upper Cut-Out Lace Ups

Read Reviews & Buy on
We've already seen a shoe that combines an Oxford and a heel, but what about a shoe that combines one with a flat? Thanks to Dream Paris Lexington, that combination has come to life with the Women's New Casual Nubuck Upper Cut-Out Lace Ups.
Expand to see more
The overall look here is a bit more reminiscent to that of a flat than anything else upon first glance. The shoe is a bit closer to the ground than most, and the overall shape of the shoe just feels more like flat than anything else. However, the familiar style stills shines through loud and proud with the closed lace setup and the exposed ankle when worn. The material that is used here is that of a synthetic leather, so while it does keep the overall cost down, it doesn't have the same premium nature that you only get with real, genuine leather. However, the shoe certainly makes up for that with the wide variety of color options that are available. There are 15 options to choose from here, and some of them change not only the color, but the overall design pattern found on the shoe. This makes hunting through the colors extremely fun, and there's a great deal of choice between colors that are more laid back, and those that are more flashy and in your face. Combine this with a lightly padded insole for extra comfort, and you're looking at a pretty solid shoe.

Just wait till we mention the price though! The Dream Paris Lexington Women's New Casual Nubuck Upper Cut-Out Lace Up Flats can be yours for a very affordable price. Being able to snag these shoes for so little is absolutely crazy, and although they aren't the most classic-looking choices out there, it's still hard to believe you can get something in the family for such an affordable price point.
Pros
  • 15 options to choose from
  • Stylish
  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
Cons
  • None

2. Giorgio Brutini Men's Vick 65905

Read Reviews & Buy on
All of the choices on our list so far have either been made out of genuine leather, or a faux leather of some type. Oxfords have traditionally featured a leather design in some shape or form, and while that may be the classic look, it's a very real fact that not everyone is fan of leather.
Expand to see more
Whether it's because of the look, feel, or smell, there's a whole number of reasons as to why you'd prefer to have an absence of leather on your shoe. Unfortunately, it can sometimes be quite difficult to locate an Oxford that abandons any trace of leather with its construction. Thankfully, we've done a bit of searching and found the Giorgio Btutini Men's Vick 65905 Oxford.

Rather than featuring a leather design, the Giorgio Brutini features a design that is made out of fabric. The appearance of fabric on an Oxford is quite different than that of leather, but it's a look that we think looks quite nice. The other defining features are still alive and wel, but the fabric creates an entirely different vibe than that of the leather. Some might say it looks less professional, and while we could agree with them, we also don't think that that is necessarily a bad thing. The fabric construction feels a bit more casual, but the Oxford shape and form factor still looks quite dapper. The combination creates for a design that utilizes elements that are both casual and professional, with the final outcome being quite unique and good-looking.

In regards to comfort features, this is an area where the Giorgio Brutini Men's Vick 65905 Oxford finds itself lacking. While there is a synthetic insole that has the ability to flex, that's about it. There's no shock absorbing technology, no odor-resistant lining, etc. A lot of reviewers on Amazon have also noted this, saying that while the shoes are perfectly fine for wearing around the office, they aren't something you'd want to wear on a lengthy walk.

While these aren't the most affordable option on our list, they're also far from the most expensive as well. But, at the end of the day, it's one of the best-looking options you'll find that doesn't utilize leather as its main material. It's unique, different, and something we think that a lot of people out there will be very taken with.
Pros
  • Casual look
  • Stylish
  • Comfortable
Cons
  • Faux leather

3. Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtips

Read Reviews & Buy on
Like we mentioned at the very beginning of this article, these are shoes that are often associated with a higher price tag than things like clogs, sneakers, slippers, etc. They're a high-end dress shoe that produce a sense of fashion and success.
Expand to see more
We've seen what something on a budget will get you, but what if money isn't necessarily an object for you? While the previous ones that we just looked at are an excellent pair of shoes for the price, what if you're curious as to what spending double the price will get you in an Oxford? The first high-end Oxford on our list is from Nunn Bush.

The Nunn Bush Men's Nelson is made out of genuine leather, something that you simply will not find in cheaper, more affordable options. The sole is made out of a synthetic material, and the heel measures in at just around 1 inch. Combine this with a non-marking outsole and a design that features a medallion toe and five-eye lace-up system, and we're looking at a shoe that's already shaping up to be rather impressive. However, so far we've only really been talking about the overall appearance of these. It's reassuring to know that this thing has the looks of a high-end shoe, but what about the actual feeling when wearing it? Is it a comfortable, stable shoe to wear on the day-to-day?

In short, yes! This particular Oxfords shoes model has quite a bit going for it in the functionality department, so let's take a closer look to see exactly what we're dealing with. First of all, this Oxford utilizes a comfort gel footbed that provides your feet with an exceptionally good feeling when worn. Having good looks on the outside is one thing, but that won't mean anything if you're uncomfortable. Thankfully with the Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxfords, that won't be a problem at all. Additionally, the rubber heel on the bottom ensures that you have excellent grip and stability when walking around, making these very safe shoes. The only real downside we were able to find when looking through reviews on Amazon is that some owners have reported that the leather takes quite a bit of time to break in. All leather is expected to be stiff at first, but it appears that it takes a little longer than usual for the leather on the shoes to soften up. However, that's a very minute issue that will go away after just a bout a week of wear.

Now, let's talk price. These are certainly high-end Oxfords, so you'd expect a high-end price to accompany them. It is also undoubtedly a better shoe in nearly every category. And while the price may seem like a large pill to swallow, it's still a bit cheaper than a lot of the really high-end choices out there. So while you are paying more here, you're still getting a pretty good deal when you consider everything that the Nunn Bush Men's Nelson Wingtip Oxford has to offer.
Pros
  • Made out of genuine leather
  • Utilizes a comfort gel footbed
  • Comfortable
Cons
  • High priced

4. Wanted Shoes Women's Babe

Read Reviews & Buy on
The look of this style is quite distinctive. We've seen today that all have the same general look and appearance, and along with this, they often come in very few color selections. This isn't really a downside as that's simply how these types of shoes are generally made, but it might be a downside to you if you like having your shoes be as colorful and bright as your personality.
Expand to see more
What if you could somehow combine the traditional appearance with the colors of something much more fun and vibrant? With the Wanted Shoes Women's Babe, that is very possible.

In regards to the overall look of the shoe, this is first and foremost a classic design. The material used to make the shoe is that of a synthetic leather, so you aren't going to be finding genuine leather here. However, the implementation of the faux leather with the Wanted Shoes Women's Babe looks quite nice and doesn't look fake by any means. While the actual feel will differ slightly from real, genuine leather, you won't have a hard time at all fooling people that this is the real deal. The heel of this shoe measures at just about 1-inch, and the medallion toe adds a nice design flare that we've seen on some of the others on our list so far. However, the real star of the show here is just how many color options the Wanted Shoes Women's Babe Shoe comes in. There are 24 different color selections to be exact, and they range from options that have the traditional tan design, to ones that feature a variety of various shade of pink in one single shoe. While seeing so much color on one of these is definitely an interesting sight, it's one that actually looks quite stunning. No matter what your taste is when it comes to fashion, there's bound to be a color option here that you will fall in love with. Not all of them are stunningly gorgeous, but there's enough here to fit everyone's personality and personal preference.

One thing we need to mention is that, according to a number of reviews on Amazon, these shoes have a very pungent smell out of the box that tends to linger around for a few days. We've determined that the smell is reminiscent to that of a new car, and is most likely associated with the synthetic leather that is being used here. This is something that faces any shoe that utilizes synthetic leather, but we still wanted to point it out as a number of uses complained about this. However, if that doesn't halter your purchasing decision, the Wanted Shoes Women's Babe comes in at a very reasonable price. These shoes are definitely one of the more affordable options that you will find. The price does make sense when you consider the use of synthetic leather and the lack of any real support features, but the classic design and wide array of color options make the Wanted Shoes Women's Babe a worthy contender on our list.
Pros
  • Premium look
  • Comfortable
  • Stylish
Cons
  • Faux leather

5. Women Leather Shoes E208

Read Reviews & Buy on
When we talk about Oxfords, it can be easy to only think of shoes that are for men. For so long Oxfords were only made for men's feet, but that is no longer the case. Oxfords that are made and designed for women are very real things, and although they might be the most popular women's shoe out there, it's still just as classy and fancy on a woman's feet as it is on a man's.
Expand to see more
However, since women's versions aren't quite as popular as those made for men, it can sometimes be a bit of a challenge to locate high quality options for women. However, we've made that issue disappear for you. We scoured Amazon for the five best Oxfords shoes choices available for women, and we came back with some rather compelling options - the first of which is this selection by Oyangs.

As the name suggests, this one boasts the classic leather construction for its design. However, the leather doesn't just stop at the top of the shoe. While it is certainly prevalent there, it also continues all the way down through the lining and even to the insole. Lovers of leather will be right at home here, and the abundance of the leather used really does remind us of the old, classic in its purest and finest form. Additionally, these shoes are packing in a very flexible and lightweight PU outsole for great stability and grip, along with a comfortable insole that promises to not only keep your feet from aching, but from getting mucky and sweaty as well. Reading through the reviews on Amazon, the majority of folks who own the shoes are extremely pleased with just how comfortable these actually are. This is especially good news if you're looking for a shoe to not only look fantastic, but to keep your feet happy and healthy as well.

That's a price tag that easily falls in line with some of the higher-end options we've reviewed so far, but the shoe certainly earns that higher price tag. Along with the classic look and genuine leather construction, the extreme comfort that these shoes bring along really do make their price very justified.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Classic look
  • Very comfortable
Cons
  • High priced

6. Refresh BH50 Women Leatherette Lace Up Chunky Heel Bootie

Read Reviews & Buy on
All of the Oxfords shoes on this list so far have feature the traditional look. While each and every shoe has had its own unique design twist with patterns, materials, or color choices, they've all retained that same general fit and finish of what we've come to expect from a classic shoe.
Expand to see more
However, what if we could somehow combine the look of an Oxford with the form factor of a heel? It may sound like a wild pipe dream, but we're happy to report that it is actually a very real thing. The Refresh BH50 Women Leatherette Lace Up Chunky Heel Bootie takes the best parts of an this style, a heel, and even a bootie, and crams them all together in one Frankenstine of a shoe. Is the final outcome any good though? It certainly is!

This is, without a doubt, one of the most unique shoes on this list. This overall design is very rarely tampered with or changed, so that's why something like the Refresh BH50 Women Leatherette Lace Up Oxford Chunky Heel Bootie is so refreshing and exciting. The material used here is, as the name suggests, leatherette. The heel measures in at around 2.75-inches, but despite being higher off the ground than traditional Oxfords, it still has the distinctive closed lace system and exposed ankle like any other version out there.

Along with it's unique design, the shoe also has quite a bit going for it in regards to its safety features. For starters, the synthetic non-skid sole will help to ensure that you are stable and sturdy on your feet wherever you go with these shoes. Although you won't be running or anything due to their resemblance of a heel, you can skill rest assured that you'll have a solid grip on the ground when walking around on any surface out there. Additionally, we find that the shoe packs in a footbed with warm cushioning and a padded insole. This helps keep the Refresh BH50 not only to look great, but also to keep your feet warm, happy, and healthy at the same time - something we can't say about every option we've reviewed so far today.

Right on the list page for the shoe, Refresh notes that the BH50 does run quite a bit smaller than other shoes. Refresh encourages that you consider ordering your shoe an entire size larger than you normally do, and it's really great to see that they're aware of what people have said about their shoe. The actual cost makes them one of the most affordable options on our list. While such a low price tag might give off the wrong impression that these are nothing but cheap junk, reviews on Amazon are overwhelming positive.
Pros
  • Unique design and pattern
  • Stable
  • Solid grip
Cons
  • Sizes run a bit smaller than other shoes

7. Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tips

Read Reviews & Buy on
This style is all about class and professionalism, there's no doubt about that at all. Their elegant shoes that are meant to be worn at elegant occasions, and because of that, spending more money on a pair is often necessary if you want to get an Oxford of the utmost quality.
Expand to see more
When we talk about quality, we mean in regards to both the outer look, and how the shoe feels when worn. The general look of an Oxford is quite distinct, but only the best of the best Oxfords utilizes extra design elements and implement certain features that make wearing the shoes much more enjoyable than their competitors. If you're looking to get the absolute most that you can out of your next pair of Oxfords and aren't against spending a little bit more, the Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tip Oxford is jam-packed with excellent choices in both design and functionality.

Let's start with the design. Along with the traditional look and feel, there are a few things going for the Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tips that you wont' find anywhere else - one of those things being the perforated brogue trim. The trim here makes the shoe stand out unlike any of the more affordable options on our list, and while some may say that its a bit too much for their own personal taste, we think it looks quite stunning. And, to add to the overall look, the Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tip Oxford comes in six different color options to choose from. All of the selections are quite neutral, meaning that you shouldn't have a hard time at all pairing any of the different colors with the outfit of your choice.

While the Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tip Oxford may have a lot going for it in the looks department, it has even more to offer when looking at its functionality features. The first of those features we're going to take a look at is the lightweight EVA-foam sole. The special EVA-foam makes the sole of the shoe incredibly soft and comfortable, which in turn means that you won't have to worry about aching feet while looking your sharpest. Another excellent feature found here is the Adidas adiPRENE sock-absorbing heel. The shock absorbent technology here keeps any abrasive impacts off of your actual feet, keeping them safe and secure inside your shoe. And, as if that wasn't enough, there's even Dewix moisture-wicking and odor-resistant lining all throughout the entirety of the shoe. So, even when you wear these Oxfords on the hottest of days, the inside of the shoe will stay cool and dry, preventing your feet from getting hot and moist.

It's easy to see that the Rockport Men's Style Purpose Wing Tips are packing quite a punch, but just how much does that punch actually cost? There's no doubt at all that that's a pretty steep price to pay, but if you are looking to get the best of the best for your next pair, you really can't go wrong here if you have the budget for them.
Pros
  • Traditional look and feel
  • Perforated brogue trim
  • Comfortable
Cons
  • High priced

8. Kenneth Cole Unlisted Men's In Good Part

Read Reviews & Buy on
The past two shoes on our list have had very similar looks. While some may see their designs as elegant and beautiful, others may see them as overly busy. Each and every person has their own unique preference when it comes to shoes, and that unique preference is even more relevant when talking about a shoe like an Oxford.
Expand to see more
If you're hunting, but are shopping around for something with a design that's not quite as flashy and a little more subdued, the Kenneth Cole Unlisted Men's In Good Part could be the shoe for you.

One of the highlights of this particular shoe is that it is made out of real leather. However, the finish here is quite a bit different than the last two shoes on our list. The leather is certainly genuine, but the overall look is a bit more rugged and natural than the overly finished ones that we've seen on the last couple of shoes. It almost looks like fabric in its overall appearance, but we think it looks fantastic when paired with its Dark Grey color.

If you're worried about stability when wearing these shoes, you can leave your fears at the door. The entire bottom of this shoe is made out of a rubber material, meaning that you should have excellent grip no matter where you are. However, comfort is a bit of a different story. Some reviewers on Amazon have said that these shoes are quite comfortable, while others have said the exact opposite. What we recommend is trying the shoes on first as they are, but if you find that they don't provide as much support as you may like, you can certainly add in an orthopedic insert to get the exact feel and comfort that you're looking for.

The price of this shoe is actually quite reasonable when considering the materials used to make it. These come at more than a fair price to pay for an Oxford as good-looking as this that's made out of real leather! The design is subdued yet elegant at the same time, the genuine leather resembles that of a high-end alternative, the rubber sole will prevent you from falling, and the price will keep your wallet happy. Overall, this is an incredibly solid choice.
Pros
  • Made of genuine leather
  • Excellent grip
  • Good price
Cons
  • May not be as comfortable

9. Caterpillar Women's Reegan

Read Reviews & Buy on
Alright, so we've looked at the offerings that are quite different and experimental so far. Between vibrant color options and designs that incorporate a heel/bootie, it's quite impressive to see just how exciting the shoe industry can sometimes be.
Expand to see more
And while that may be great for some, not everyone wants a shoe that is trying to be unique and standoffish - especially when dealing with Oxfords. These are shoes that are often at their best when left alone in their traditional sate. Rather than focusing on how to make the shoe unique and different, some of the best Oxfords are ones where the focus was put on how to make a really, really good classic Oxford. For those of you who are looking for a shoe that not only features a classic design, but also one that comes with zero compromises, you won't want to look any further than the Caterpillar Women's Reegan.

Just what makes this one so great? Let's start with the design and build quality. The Reegan is made out of genuine leather, so right off the bat it's obvious we're dealing with a shoe that's incredibly high-end. The heel has a measurement of 0.75-inches, and the platform measure in right around 0.25-inches. Additionally, the bottom of the sole is constructed out of leather, so you can walk easy knowing that you'll have a solid grip on any surface your shoes come into contact with. When looking through reviews on Amazon, a lot of people reported that, unlike some others out there with real leather, the leather used here already feels as if it was broken in. It's quite soft out of the box, and doesn't have that stiff feel like many other shoes with genuine leather. We strike this up as a pro, but if you're a fan of the stiff leather feel with a new shoe, this could be a bit of a turn off for you.

The Caterpillar Women's Reegan also stays true to the classic design by only offering a handful of neutral colors. You have your choice between Latte, Bridal Rose, and Shell. While only a few colors are offered here, all of them look quite fantastic in their own right. However, all of these premium materials and features do come at a bit of a high cost. The Caterpillar Women's Reegan shoes come at a higher price depending on the size and color you end up choosing. That may seem like a lot of money for a shoe that doesn't try to do anything special or unique, but what you're getting here is one that's really good at looking classy, and nothing more. The materials used here are incredibly premium, and if you're looking for something that stays true to the classic design, uses only the best materials, and feels great while wearing them, this could be the perfect choice for you.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Bottom of the sole is constructed out of leather
  • Solid grip on any surface
Cons
  • Soft leather

10. Bruno Homme Moda Italy Prince Men's Classic Modern Wingtip Lace Dress Shoe

Read Reviews & Buy on
When we talk about Oxfords shoes throughout this list, we'll see that they don't always come very cheap. Oxfords are relatively high-end shoes, and because of that, they generally resemble a high-end price. However, generally doesn't mean always.
Expand to see more
There are certainly some cases in which you can snag a pair of fancy shoes for not a lot of money on Amazon, and just such a shoe comes in the form of the Bruno Homme Moda Italy Prince Men's Classic Modern Oxford Wingtip Lace Dress Shoe. However, before we dive into the actual price of the shoe, we should first take a look and see just what it has to offer.

For starters, we've got everything you would come to expect from a classic Oxford design - closed off laces, an exposed ankle, and a low-cut heel. The material that is used is that of a faux leather, but even though it isn't genuine, it still looks and feels like the real deal, so much so that other people more than likely won't be able to tell the difference whatsoever. The heel of the shoe is wooden to add a bit of stability to the shoe as a whole, and the height of the heel measures in at around 1 inch. In regards to the footbed, this particular Oxford does feature some light cushioning to keep your feet nice and comfy throughout the day while wearing these.

When perusing through the reviews on Amazon, there are a number of people who do have an issue with the sole of the shoe. More specifically, there is little-to-no grip to found anywhere on the sole. Since there's no grip, these reviewers have said that these Oxfords can be quite slippery at times when walking. The heel has a bit of grip to it to even this out, but if you take a step without the the heel first making contact with the ground, you might notice a bit of slippage.

While the lack of a solid grip on the sole is a bit of a disappointment, the price certainly isn't. We mentioned earlier that one of the biggest selling factors for this shoe came in the form of its price. It's quite rare that you can find a pair of Oxfords for such a low price, and while the Bruno Homme Moda Italy Prince Men's Classic Modern Oxford Wingtip Lace Dress Shoe does come with a couple of trade-offs, they are more than made up for with the extremely low price point. If you're looking for a solid pair on a budget, these are going to be your best bet.
Pros
  • Classic Oxford design
  • Closed off laces
  • An exposed ankle
  • A low-cut heel
Cons
  • Not made of genuine leather