Best Formal Shoes Reviewed
When going to a significant event or fancy affair, a regular shoe just won’t cut it. You will need a pair of formal shoes to match the event's style. Besides being different in looks, formal shoes will often be made with more luxurious materials. In addition to style, you will want your formal footwear to be comfortable. While comfort may not be the first thing that comes to mind when someone thinks of pumps or Oxford shoes, it is essential to consider that you may be spending prolonged periods wearing them and that doing damage to the health of your feet is not worth looking good.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 17 hrs of research
- ECCO Helsinki
- Stacy Adams Dwight
- Thursday Boot Company President
- Clarks Tilden Oxford
- Florsheim Midtown
- Rockport Total Motion
- Frye Jones
- Vince Camuto Carrelen
- Cole Haan Tucker Venetian
- Calvin Klein Brodie
- Criteria Used for Evaluation
- Frequently Asked Questions
10 Best Formal Shoes
1. ECCO Helsinki
ECCO is well known for making supportive and comfortably styled shoes, but now you can enjoy ECCO for formal or dress occasions as well. The Helsinki slip-on shoe has a soft square toe and bicycle stitching, making this a great pick for business or pleasure. It features all of the brand’s technology when it comes to keeping your foot healthy and protected, and is easy to wear - you won’t have to bother with laces, just slip the Helsinki on, and you’ll be out the door in no time.Read more
The Helsinki is comprised of a leather upper, with classic stitching along the side panels and toe. The distressed leather finish gives a sophisticated elevation to the rugged make of the shoe, demonstrating elegance and function.
Believe it or not, the Helsinki from ECCO could even be used for a gentle hike or walk. The functionally built toe box allows for the feet to spread in comfort when walking, without restriction or pain. Built to last, the polyurethane soles can take a beating from dancing, hiking, or racing for a cab at the end of your evening. With their patented Comfort Fibre System, the ECCO allows for a cushion of air to circulate through the shoe, cutting down on odor and heat while providing a cushioned sole.
Cost and Value
If looking for something you won’t need to replace for a while, this shoe is for you. The ECCO Helsinki may be a slip on formal shoe, but the brand prides itself on the construction of durable, lasting footwear. A bit on the expensive side for our list, but still the average price of most formal shoes, you can rest assured to invest in a pair of these for the long haul!
2. Stacy Adams Dwight
Memory Foam Insole
Will Need Breaking In
For more of a modest shoe that can easily go from formal to casual, the Stacy Adams Dwight might be the right choice for you. It has a very simple stitching detail on the upper, making it both stand out from the simplest of derby shoes, and also elegant enough to be worn with a fancy suit. The Stacy Adams Dwight features a perforated trim and blind-eyelet lacing and is made with leather both outside and in. The outsole is made out of rubber which is a more durable, easy to maintain and flexible option, while the memory foam insole and a low stacked heel make this lace-up the shoe a pleasure to wear.Read more
The memory foam insole is an excellent feature in this shoe because it molds to the shape of your foot, providing you maximum softness and comfort to your feet. Being on your feet long in formal shoes can open the door for sweat and odor build up. The perforated trim allows for more air to get into your shoe to keep your feet cool and dry.
Stacy Adams has been in the business of constructing stylish shoes since 1875. Founded in Brockton, Mass, the company has been part of American culture throughout the years, styling shoes for speakeasy parties, Frank Sinatra concerts, and now the hustle and bustle of the 20th century.
Cost and Value
Coming in under the average cost of a formal shoe, and from a brand name, this is a great buy. With sophisticated styling, classic bits of broguing, this shoe is a current classic to be added to your collection of formal wear. It even comes in a variety of colors, all of which will look dapper with any outfit you choose.
3. Thursday Boot Company President
Requires Breaking In
The Thursday Boot Company is no stranger to creating a classy boot, made for longevity and function, but also a classic formal styling, reflected in the President. It’s the perfect choice for cold and rainy weather as it will protect you from the elements while still providing a look that’s elegant and classy. Made of leather, a studded sole, and speed hook eyelets, it’s well worth the investment as it’s sure to last you a lifetime.Read more
Well made shoes can sometimes be hard to find, but the President delivers on all accounts for a boot. The rubber studded sole gives added grip, and weather resistant treatment lets you step out without worrying about wet feet or ruined leather. An added bonus is that the boot is resolvable, should you wear them down as your new favorite boot!
An EVA strip and cork footbed give additional cushioning to each step, allowing you to stay out for the duration of the evening in comfort. As an ankle boot, lacing up gives added structure and stability to your foot and ankle, and flat wax laces keep you tied up for the evening.
Cost and Value
The President comes in on the more expensive side of a formal shoe, but compared to other models of boots, is around an average price. Considering the styling and durability of the President, it’s still a great buy if you’re looking for a long-term formal shoe investment.
4. Clarks Tilden Oxford
Limited Color Options
The Clarks Tilden Oxford is another classic formal shoe, but big on comfort. For those new to wearing this kind of shoe, Clarks is well known for designing functional comfort in footwear. With a built-in insole and TPR sole, the Tilden will easily become your go-to shoe for work, fancy dinners and even casual occasions when a leather lace-up is not out of place.Read more
Clarks has been designing stylish comfortable shoes since 1825. Throughout the years, they’ve employed innovative cushioning, 3D printing technology, and pride their brand on comfort through biomechanical assessments of the foot. Their oxford style shoe is no exception to this, boasting cushioned Ortholite insoles to keep your feet comfortable and dry.
Typical of an oxford style of shoe, Clarks has given their best selling model a rich leather look, with a cap toe to finish. Detail can be found in the stitching along the panels of the uppers and around the toe. With a great classical design, it’s a staple in anyone’s closet.
Cost and Value
The Clarks Tilden Oxford comes in at a moderate cost, but average when compared to other Oxford style shoes. However, knowing that you’re buying a shoe built for comfort may sway you to wear these out for that weekend wedding, to work, or even for just a night on the town.
5. Florsheim Midtown
Genuine Leather Upper
Non-Slip Rubber Outsole
Moisture Wicking Lining
Florsheim footwear is an excellent choice for formal occasions, no matter which of their models you opt for. Nonetheless, one of our favorites is the Midtown, a range of shoes that come in as many variations as you can wish for. Whether you prefer a simple, plain toe Oxford, a cap toe, wingtip or even bike toe, it’s available. Even more, it even comes in a boot, chukka, and slip-on version. This means that the Midtown is one of the most versatile pairs of shoes currently available for purchase, and the best part is that it hits the sweet spot in terms of quality to price ratio.Read more
Easy To Size
The Midtown is a pair of shoes that will fit almost anyone, seeing that it combines smart sizing with a genuine leather upper. It comes in medium, wide and extra wide, which is great news for those who need a bit more space in their shoes, while the upper is a natural material that breathes, flexes and adapts to the foot, especially once it’s broken in. To ensure your shoe retains its suppleness, make sure to take good care of it with a quality leather conditioner in the appropriate color.
There’s more to the fit of a pair of shoes than just the shape of the upper. How it will feel on your feet is highly dependent on the materials used in the sole as well, and this is where the Midtown shines. With a non-slip rubber outsole, it’ll keep you safe no matter the weather conditions, and the midsole features a good amount of OrthoLite cushioning that will absorb shock from standing and walking.
Cost and Value
With a price that’s average, and even low when compared to footwear of similar quality, the Florsheim Midtown is a definite top choice. It’s got everything going for it - looks, versatility, size options as well as technological innovation. It’s available in several colors and toe options, so you can easily find the perfect pair (or pairs) for you.
6. Rockport Total Motion
Genuine Leather Upper
truTECH® Heel and Forefoot Cushioning
PU Midsole Plate & Outsole
Medium & Wide WIdths Available
Heel May Slip
When it comes to options for women, it is usually very hard to find something that looks appropriate, but that is not a pair of feet-killing high heels that will leave you in pain after just a couple of hours. If you need something elegant to wear to a wedding, a business meeting, or just a night out, you will want something that both looks good and shows off your leg, without doing any actual damage to your health. The Rockport Total Motion pointed toe pump is one of the rare shoes that can do that. With a 3 inch heel, a variety of upper material and design options, and a good number of comfort technologies, it’s the perfect choice for fancy occasions.Read more
The Total Motion comes in a number of options when it comes to color and upper material. Whether you prefer to go with a classic black, in suede, leather or patent leather, or wish for something a bit more fashion forward such as leopard print canvas or studs, this heel by Rockport can give it to you. No matter which version you go with, you’re sure to be satisfied with the fit, looks, and ease of maintenance.
As any other pair of Rockport shoes, the Total Motion features many innovations that are meant to make it your go-to pair of footwear. From the truTECH® cushioning in the forefoot and heel which allow for excellent levels of shock absorption, to the high retention foam footbed that molds to your feet and provides great levels of lasting support, and even to the safety-oriented outsole that is stable and slip resistant. These shoes have got it all.
Cost and Value
Fancy high heels can be crazy expensive, and if they’re cheap, it’s probably for a reason. However, the Rockport Total Motion surprises when it comes to price, which is not only affordable, it’s the cheapest out of all the items on this list! This is quite an achievement, considering that this is a genuine leather shoe, made with excellent cushioning and comfort features. That’s why you simply can’t go wrong with this pair of heels - you may even be tempted to purchase several pairs.
7. Frye Jones
Leather Upper, Lining & Outsole
Goodyear Welt Construction
Heel Pull Tab
Gets Better With Time
Limited Color Options
Founded in 1863, Frye is a brand known for their high-quality footwear that’s made with the most carefully selected leathers. The Jones is a pair of Chelsea boots that’ll work wonderfully both for casual and formal wear, thanks to its simple yet elegant design. You can get it in two color options, brown and black, and if you take care of it, it will last you a lifetime. The leather used is from premium tanneries in France and Holland, and it will develop a beautiful patina over time that simply cannot be recreated.Read more
In addition to the leather upper that will only get better with wear, the Jones features a leather lining and a leather outsole. This means that this is a high-end pair of boots, made to comfort and mold to your feet, and to serve you for years to come. You’ll find that these boots require a bit more love - you will need to condition the upper, let them dry thoroughly between wears, and have them resoled when the outsole wears out, but you’ll find yourself reaching for them time and time again.
Goodyear Welt Construction
The best footwear is constructed using the Goodyear welt method, which not only gives a great level of durability but also ensures that your shoes can stand up to more aggressive wear and that they can be easily resoled should the need arise. Do note, however, that due to having a leather outsole, the Jones shouldn’t be worn in wet weather, as this can damage the shoe.
Cost and Value
The Frye Jones is the most expensive pair of footwear on this list, costing a small fortune. This means that it may not be an option for most people, but those looking for something extremely high quality, that will work both with a suit and jeans, should consider getting these boots. They’ll serve you well, and for years, and they’re sure to turn some heads in the process.
8. Vince Camuto Carrelen
Slightly High Heel
When summer rolls by and you simply can’t imagine being stuck in a pair of leather pumps, the Vince Camuto Carrelen becomes the perfect option for formal occasions. A sophisticated heeled sandal with a cute bow embellishment, this is a pair of shoes that can work for any formal occasion. It is available in a number of colors that range from serious black suede to crazy and fun banana split, which means that it can be the perfect foundation for an elegant outfit or a statement piece that’ll make you stand out in any crowd.Read more
A high heel can do wonders for your appearance. It makes the posture more feminine and elongates the line of the legs, showing off all the right muscles and curves. What differentiates the Carrelen from a simple pair of strappy sandals, however, is the fact that it’s got a heel with a good amount of volume, making it more stable and easier to walk on. With this type of heel, you’re less likely to get fatigued too quickly, and it will even work for walking on uneven or soft surfaces such as grass and cobblestone.
You can never have enough safety features, especially if you are wearing a high heel. The Carrelen features a thin, stylish ankle strap that’ll give added support to your ankle, and that’ll keep the shoe from slipping off your feet. With a buckle closure, it can easily be adjusted to fit anyone, which makes it both a fashionable and practical feature.
Cost and Value
Costing less than what you’d expect from a pair of designer heels, the Vince Camuto Carrelen is a great investment if you need something with timeless style. It’s an elegant pair of sandals that won’t feel out of place even at the fanciest of occasions, and it can easily be paired with almost any outfit - from long formal gowns to ripped boyfriend jeans, meaning that these won’t just be another pair of shoes you buy, then only wear once a year.
9. Cole Haan Tucker Venetian
Another well-loved brand name in fashion, Cole Haan, delivers a loafer styled driving shoe that combines style and comfort in a sleek soft leather look. With a moc-stitched toe and wax leather look, this combination of sporty and elegant is going to be the perfect choice for summer formal wear or boat attire. What’s best about the Tucker Venetian is definitely its flexibility - allowing you to step in style and comfort, without having to endure a stiff pair of shoes for hours on end.Read more
This Venetian style loafer proudly gives an aristocratic feel to comfort. Vintage inspired leather designing mixes with comfortable sporty construction, giving flexibility to this slip-on shoe. A textured Vibram rubber sole allows for traction, perfect for boat attire or an afternoon on the docks. Plus, it’ll keep you safe on the dance floor too!
Cole Haan is known for its artisan quality of styling, bringing back a love for the 1920s generation gentleman. Since 1928, they’ve been bringing timeless formalwear to the masses, and their sporty Loafer is a classic for anyone’s footwear collection. Crafted with soft leather, moc-toe, and contrast stitching, it’s clear the classic details of a formal shoe were kept in this sportier option loafer.
Cost and Value
For a designer brand shoe, this hits the average mark on the price list. When comparing to other non-designer brand name shoes it may appear more expensive. However, the simple sporty design mixed with a formal sophistication makes this a good buy, especially as it can easily be dressed up or down.
10. Calvin Klein Brodie
Lacks Arch Support
If you’re looking for something simple yet elegant, the Calvin Klein Brodie is a good option to consider. A leather shoe with a classic design, it’s a great choice for both business and casual wear. Plus, you can choose from some uppers, from patent leather to burnished calf leather, to epi leather, as well as some color choices so that you can pair these either with charcoal, black, gray or navy suit. The footbed is padded for comfort, making the Brodie a great option for all-day wear.Read more
Nothing is as elegant as a beautifully cared for leather shoe, and the Calvin Klein Brodie can do just that. Available in a number of leather types and colors, it’s an incredibly versatile shoe that will work with anything, from a suit, to a pair of chinos, and even with dressed up jeans. The lace-up closure allows for some fit customization, and the reinforced eyelets prevent wear and tear from lacing.
The padded footbed feature in the Calvin Klein Brodie helps to give you a softer feel on your feet that will make standing and walking more comfortable, even when they’ve been on your feet for hours. Expect to be out all evening without skipping a step in these shoes, but with a box toe, be sure to size correctly to suit your foot width.
Cost and Value
For a Designer brand name, The Calvin Klein Brodie is quite reasonably priced, coming in at just under average cost for a formal shoe. But if you’re looking to impress with Designer shoes, CK’s Brodie will not disappoint. The unique leather texture gives an added value to the shoe, different than other similar styles available on the market.
Criteria Used for Evaluation
When pairing dress shoes, it is very important that you are aware of the basic rules. A pair of black dress shoes will go with almost any outfit and will look good both on dressy and more casual occasions. Shades of brown, however, should never be paired with a black suit, and won’t work for black tie events. But other than these simple rules, you can easily make your own, building your style so that it shows off your tastes. Today, most shoes come in a variety of colors, and some can even be customized. Fashion forward options can include various embellishments and details that will bring attention to your footwear, without making it inappropriate for an occasion.
If you are looking for ways to let your personality sow in your footwear, you can consider some of the following options. However, note that a classic pair of shoes will be more versatile and appropriate on a variety of occasions than a statement one.
Color Contrasting – instead of selecting a shoe with a solid, single color, a shoe that has a bold contrast of color or hue steps up the eye-grabbing attention your style deserves. Pair a dark black with a tan or rust color leather in your shoe and pair with light gray slacks. White pants or dresses act as a blank canvas, and your accessories act as your palette to paint. Add a bright color shoe, or play with the shoe texture, mixing a cotton attire with a shiny patent leather.
Stitching – contrast stitching usually has a different color than the shoe itself. This creates a visually appealing detail, subtle yet distinct.
Rhinestones – who doesn’t love a little glitter and sparkle? Rhinestones added to adorn strappy shoes give an elevated air to your style and can dress up the most commonplace clothing. Depending on your unique style, you can have a simple design of sparkle, lining the shoe, or go all out with a fully encrusted shoe. In either case, you can always pair with jeans or leggings for a night out in comfort!
Hidden Eyelets – sometimes a sleek look requires simplicity, and hidden eyelets accomplish this by removing the usual grommet that is seen on the tongue of the shoe for lacing up. Instead, a small hole is all that is seen on the outside, creating a clean, sharp look. Many times, the grommet can be found on the inside of the tongue on the back of the lace hole.
Cut Out Design – cut out designs are usually done with machinery that utilizes a laser to cut a pattern or design into the shoe. With no limit to the number of designs imaginable, this can dress up any bootie to the next level of style.
Brogueing – found mostly in formal men’s footwear, brogueing is the decorative perforations seen along the edges of the uppers, toe caps, wingtips, or other areas of the shoe. It gives an added element of sophistication and flair to a regular oxford style shoe. This kind of shoe is meant to be seen, so pair with ankle length slacks. Anything too long will cover the detail.
Wingtip – wingtips are a decorative design of construction where the toe has backward curving sides extending to a point which looks similar to the shape of a wing. Pair these with ankle length slacks or pants so as not to hide the decor!
Toe Box Design – from pointed to round to square, or tapered toe boxes, this can add some sophistication to your style. A pointed toe shoe will pair well with long slacks, skirts, or dresses while a rounder or tapered toe can go great with just about every kind of clothing.
Combine your favorite shoe style with options for high fashion statements, and you’ll be turning heads at distinguished events. The best part is that once you find that great combination of shoe that suits your individuality, you can always tone it down by pairing with something more casual such as jeans, leggings, shorts, or casual skirts and dresses. There’s no going wrong by investing in a formal pair of shoes!
Most formal shoes should have decent construction, that will let them survive wear and tear. Fashion continues to blur the boundaries between what looks casual versus something formal, and many times different shoes can be paired with both. Those shoes should be constructed keeping in mind the fact the wearer will be using them for more than just one evening. You can always check for a decently constructed shoe by the following tips.
Knowing good leather when you see it is an art in itself. Full grain leather has the least amount of flaws or blemishes with color that is consistent. Top leather is also of great quality but may require some sanding or buffing to correct marks and flaws. Less desirable are belly or bonded leathers which tend to be wrinkled and hold less shape over time, or have been pieced together from other scraps.
How To Spot Good Leather:
How a formal shoe is crafted can clue you into how durable the shoe will be. Goodyear welt construction is the best shoe assembly for a formal shoe but can come at a premium. Usually, a thin strip of rubber, leather, or plastic is stitched around the shoe perimeter. The insole, adhered to a gemming, along with the sole and uppers to creating a stiffness to the shoe that prevents wear and tear, and brings weatherproofing to the shoe. This kind of constructed shoe can also be resoled quite easily.
How To Spot Good Shoe Craftsmanship:
Attention To Detail:
Take time to inspect the shoe for small details that clue you into the craftsmanship of the shoe.
You wouldn’t buy a pair of shoes you can’t wear for an hour, would you? Well made formal shoes need to be just as comfortable as they are stylish. A bad fit can be much more serious than just having sore feet at the end of the day, and can lead to serious foot health issues over a longer period. Always make sure that you are purchasing shoes in the correct size and width for your foot shape, and stay away from models which have features that don’t agree with your anatomy – your health is not worth sacrificing for being able to wear the latest style.
Today, there is an abundance of available technologies which brands can use when constructing their footwear. From supportive and shock absorbing midsoles to memory foam insoles that adapt to your foot shape, and even to elastic materials in the upper that can conform to the shape of your foot. Moisture-wicking properties are no longer only reserved for athletic footwear, and you’ll find plenty of formal lace-ups with odor control and antimicrobial treatments.
In addition to the above, well-known brands and designers usually, make a quality shoe. Doing a little bit of research here can help you find what a well constructed formal shoe would look like, and help you make an educated selection if dealing with less-popular or known brand names. Check designers such as Cole Haan, Calvin Klein, Jimmy Choo and Givenchy.
Now, not all quality constructed shoes need be designer shoes. There are a number of boutique designers and shoe cobblers that will construct a well made formal shoe. If you’re looking to purchase a brand that you’ve not heard of yet, just be sure to check any reviews, or ask your local shoe cobbler for their opinion. With so many options available in terms of purchasing these days, you’re sure to find a formal shoe that’s well made, and can suit your budget!
Expert Interviews & Opinions
Many dressier formal shoes can also be work for business attire, or sometimes give a posh look to a casual outfit. Try out for yourself mixing and matching your new oxfords or heels with something slightly casual, like jeans, for a new look you may just love!
While most formal footwear come in basic blacks, browns, and neutral tones, adding a pop of color from your footwear to your ensemble is a fun way of making formal, well, fun!
Go for shades of red or a bright white to pair with blacks and browns, or opt for greens and blues to really make a statement!
Frequently Asked Questions
Polishing a leather shoe is relatively simple. Here’s a step by step process that you can follow to keep your shoes looking clean and shiny for a long time. All you need is a cloth that’s soft, a shoe polish, and a brush. See more about polishing and cleaning here.
Brush whatever debris is on the shoe with either the brush or a soft wet cloth.
After you’ve gotten all that you can get off with the brush, give your shoes a chance to dry for a while.
Apply the shoe polish you have on to the shoe with a dry cloth. You can rub it on with a small circular motion. Shoe experts caution using only a little bit of polish.
Take your brush again, and rub off any leftover polish on the shoe.
Lastly, buff the shoe with a dry cloth for a nice shiny look to your formal footwear.
They can last for a couple of years if you take good proper care of them. One thing you can do is regularly polish your formal footwear, particularly if it’s leather. You can also put in shoe trees in your shoe to help have a longer lifespan. They’re designed to soak up the foot sweat that might be left behind in the shoe and maintain the shape of the shoe. With all kinds of footwear, it’s generally recommended not to wear them every single day. You should rotate between shoes instead so there’s time given for drying of any moisture in them and maintaining the shape.
Formal shoes have the reputation of being tight on the feet, but they should not feel restrictive or painful. They should give your toes room to stretch and move around inside of the shoe. The sides and heel of the shoe should feel snug, but not too tight on you. Fit experts recommend trying on the shoes in the evening when your feet are more swollen so you can get a true sense of the whether shoes will be too tight on you or not.
It can take anywhere from a couple of days to a couple of weeks depending on the type of material and the construction of the footwear. It’s suggested, in order to avoid too much discomfort, you should wear them a little at a time frequently throughout the day, increasing the amount of time until you can wear them comfortably for up to an hour.
- 11 Best Men's Dress Shoes You Need To O, ,
- Best Dress Shoes For Men This Spring That Are Stylish And Comfortable, ,
- The Ultimate Men’s Dress Shoe Guide, ,
- The 27 Best Dress Shoes For Men?, ,
- Top Men's Formal Shoes, ,
- 4 Things to look for in a good pair of men's shoes, ,
- The best men's dress shoes for under $200, ,