to top 10 table

Best Black Booties Reviewed for Appearance

last updated Mar 15, 2019

Over the past few years, booties have roared into mainstream popularity – and it isn’t hard to see why. It is almost impossible to walk down the street without seeing at least a few people rocking them, so why feel left out? With this list, we hope to outline the variations available with black booties so that you can decide which features will work best for you. Whether you like buckles, bangles, and laces, or you prefer a simple, sleek look – or maybe something right down the middle – there is sure to be a model here that is perfect for you. In addition to appearance, we took into consideration other features like comfort (of course), durability, stability, and more.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 19 hrs of research

icon
Forever Buckle Strap
94.8/100 our score
Comfort
92
Heel
95
Traction
97
Versatility
94
Style
96
Forever Buckle Strap
Why is it better?

Strong Synthetic Material

Roomy Toes

Three Buckles

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Forever Buckle Strap
Test Winner: Forever Buckle Strap
Researched Sources
14
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1289
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
19
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Comfort Heel Traction Versatility Style By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
#1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
Comfort
92%
Heel
95%
Traction
97%
Versatility
94%
Style
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$19.99
#2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Comfort
94%
Heel
93%
Traction
91%
Versatility
94%
Style
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$55.65
#3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Comfort
92%
Heel
91%
Traction
89%
Versatility
90%
Style
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$39.95
#4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Comfort
90%
Heel
91%
Traction
89%
Versatility
89%
Style
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$99.00
#5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.4
Comfort
89%
Heel
90%
Traction
87%
Versatility
88%
Style
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$18.59
#6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Comfort
85%
Heel
88%
Traction
86%
Versatility
89%
Style
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$26.00
#7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.2
Comfort
85%
Heel
86%
Traction
84%
Versatility
87%
Style
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$26.75
#8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.6
Comfort
83%
Heel
85%
Traction
82%
Versatility
85%
Style
83%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$40.45
#9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.6
Comfort
84%
Heel
82%
Traction
80%
Versatility
81%
Style
81%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$109.95
#10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.4
Comfort
81%
Heel
82%
Traction
78%
Versatility
80%
Style
81%
Price Comparison Last Updated (25.03.19)
$21.00
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Forever Buckle Strap
  • Dr. Scholls Dakota
  • Marco Republic Galaxy Wedge
  • Lucky Brand Bremma
  • Forever Camille-86
  • Breckelles Heather-34
  • Soda Mug
  • Rampage Tarragon
  • Lucky Brand Basel
  • ZooShoo Western
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Black Booties

1. Forever Buckle Strap

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.8
Forever Buckle Strap
Comfort
92
Heel
95
Traction
97
Versatility
94
Style
96
best offer for today
$19.99
Pros:

Strong Synthetic Material

Roomy Toes

Three Buckles

Cons:

Wearing On Sole Under Toes

Less Arch Support

The Forever Buckle Strap Block Heel Ankle Booties are not for the meek. These stunning shoes are a beefed-up model with a high heel and three buckles across the foot. The separate tongue on this model opens the shoe up, making it both breathable and unique. Less formal and more fun, these boots are a fun option for shoppers looking to mix things up.

Read more

Three buckles
This model has three buckles stacked from the top of the foot to the middle of the ankle. These help to add security and stability while also adding unique style.

Roomy toes
This model has a sharp angle and tall heel but somehow retains enough room in the toe for all-day comfort – a rarity for similar boots.

Cost and Value
The Forever Buckle Strap Block Heel Ankle Booties are a killer statement at a bargain price. Even though you will be rocking them like a model, the boots themselves actually come with a very reasonable price tag. Great shoes to add to your closet for special occasions or when you’re just feeling yourself, this model is a strong value whichever way you look at it.

2. Dr. Scholls Dakota

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.8
Dr. Scholls Dakota
Comfort
94
Heel
93
Traction
91
Versatility
94
Style
92
best offer for today
$55.65
Pros:

Padded Insole

Secure Fit

Wide Foot Friendly

Ankle Support

Cons:

Sizing Runs Small

High Arch

Another wedge option, this model is extremely comfortable without sacrificing style. Composed of man-made materials and built with a padded insole, the Dr. Scholl's Dakota Booties are a quality purchase. The laces make these shoes easy to get on and off and helps secure the boot to your foot with a more secure fit.

Read more

Padded in-sole
This model has an additionally padded insole that provides extra comfort on the foot – specifically the arch. Booties can make the foot ache after a long day, but this model has additional padding to ease that pain.

Fits wide feet
Many boot options are narrow and do not support wearers with wider feet. This model is designed to fit any size foot with flexible material and laces to secure the body to the wearer’s foot.

Cost and Value
The Dr. Scholl's Dakota Booties are priced right around the market average. However, the comfort level of these boots is far above average with wearers reporting that they can wear them all day pain-free. Because of that, this model is a very strong value.

3. Marco Republic Galaxy Wedge

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Marco Republic Galaxy Wedge
Comfort
92
Heel
91
Traction
89
Versatility
90
Style
92
best offer for today
$39.95
Pros:

Vegan-Friendly

Great Value

Highly Stable For High Heels

Roomy Toe Box

Cons:

Limited Traction

Separation of Rubber Sole

A beautiful and simple model, the Marco Republic Galaxy Wedge Boots are a great addition to any wardrobe and come in at number one on our list. With a tall wedge, this bootie has a more solid body than most of the shoes on this list. Vegan-friendly, this model will appeal to a broader audience than most others as well.

Read more

Vegan Friendly
This model is built without using any animal products, making it a great choice for shoppers who are ethically aware when shopping for clothes. The faux suede upper is almost indistinguishable in quality from animal products.

Added Stability
The wedge style and wide body of this shoe make it a more stable option – perfect for those who are a little less steady in heels.

Cost and Value
With the faux suede and simple design, this model is an extremely economical option. Priced at the low end of the spectrum, you can be confident that you are getting a great value.

4. Lucky Brand Bremma

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Lucky Brand Bremma
Comfort
90
Heel
91
Traction
89
Versatility
89
Style
90
best offer for today
$99.00
Pros:

Memory Foam Insole

Smooth Internal Lining

High Traction Outsole

Secure Zippers

Cons:

Stiff Sole

Sizing Runs Small

The Lucky Brand Breema Bootie is traditionally designed, with zippers for easy entry, this model is a perfect representation of the classic black bootie. This shoe was designed with an emphasis on comfort and has internal features that are next to none.

Read more

Smooth lining
The inside of this model is lined with a smooth material, making it not only easy to get in and out of but soft and comfortable throughout the day.

Cushioned in sole
In addition to the smooth lining, the insole of this model has extra cushioning, making it both supportive on the bottom of the foot and secure around the top.

Cost and Value
Since this model is a signature shoe, it does sit at a price point that is slightly above average. However, the care and attention to detail inside the shoe give it a comfort level that is hard to match. Because this model will feel so great, you can be confident knowing you won’t regret this purchase, but be happy every time you slip your foot inside these ultra comfy boots.

5. Forever Camille-86

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.4
Forever Camille-86
Comfort
89
Heel
90
Traction
87
Versatility
88
Style
88
best offer for today
$18.59
Pros:

Cushioned Insole

High-Quality Synthetic Material

Unique Style

Roomy Toes

Cons:

Separation At Sole

Chipping Of Heel

Forever Camille has produced a statement set of shoes with their Comfort Lace Up Ankle Booties. Invoking an almost military style, this model has black laces up the front to help secure the shoe to your foot while the tall heel gives them a little more attitude. Finished off with a padded insole, this shoe is sexy, yet comfortable.

Read more

Cushioned in-sole
With such a tall heel, additional comfort in the insole is a necessity. This model is securely padded to keep the pressure off of the foot and ensure all-day comfort.

Front laces
Not many bootie models have laces all the way up the front of the shoe, but this narrow model has strong, black laces that help secure the boot to the foot more than other models.

Cost and Value
The Forever Camille-86 Comfort Lace Up Ankle Booties are priced very reasonably. With the additional comfort in the sole and the striking design, these shoes will come with the look of a celeb but a price tag we can all be happy with.

6. Breckelles Heather-34

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Breckelles Heather-34
Comfort
85
Heel
88
Traction
86
Versatility
89
Style
86
best offer for today
$26.00
Pros:

Made In USA

Highly Stable

High-Quality Materials

Cons:

Not For Wide Feet

Fabric Separates Inside Shoe

Breckelles Heather-34 Ankle Booties are a subtle twist on the classic bootie. A simple, black body is similar to other models on this list, but the unique feature comes with this model’s height. While most boots end at the ankle, this model is slightly taller, offering more stability and a slightly different, more Western appearance.

Read more

Chunky Heel
The chunky heel on this model makes it a more stable option for those who feel a little off balance when rocking heels. The average height and tapered heel make it a safe, yet sexy option.

Made in the USA
As an added bonus, this model is made in the USA – meaning you know your purchase is going to American workers and stimulating the economy.

Cost and Value
Intelligently made in the USA, this model is a little pricier than some of its competitors, but it offers features that they can’t match. Since it is a domestic product, you can be sure the quality is high and that they will comfortably last you for a long time. The Breckelles Heather-34 Ankle Booties are a strong value for the price.

7. Soda Mug

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.2
Soda Mug
Comfort
85
Heel
86
Traction
84
Versatility
87
Style
84
best offer for today
$26.75
Pros:

Western Style Fit

Pair With Anything

Durable Construction

Slight Heel For Height

Cons:

Verify Brand Prior To Purchase

These are vegan black booties in a simple, western style. They are sleek and comfortable and easily pair with most of the outfits in your wardrobe. With such a simple and sleek yet versatile boot available to you, you’ll fall in love with the bootie style.

Read more

Durable build
This bootie is meant to last as a part of your go-to wardrobe. They are effortless to slip off and on without damaging the heel. They feature a sturdy rubber outsole as well which provide both comfort and long wear.

Pair with anything
Whether you’re in the mood for jeans and a sweater for the early fall weather, a pair of capris and a light summer top, or your slacks and blouse for work, these simple little boots will pair well with almost anything, making them a great value.

Cost and Value
Priced near the bottom of the range, these shoes will be worn so often that they represent true value for the dollar. The fit is great, for an inexpensive bootie. You will also appreciate their comfort and versatility.

8. Rampage Tarragon

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
83.6
Rampage Tarragon
Comfort
83
Heel
85
Traction
82
Versatility
85
Style
83
best offer for today
$40.45
Pros:

Low Heel

Great For Wide Feet

Dual Zipper

Non Slip Sole

Cons:

Lose Shape

The Rampage Tarragon Ankle Bootie is the classic zip-up bootie model. A simple, black, low heeled body makes this a safe and reliable option. The heel pull tab and zipper along the outside of the body makes this shoe very easy to get on and off, and the dual zippers also add a subtle flair to the otherwise straightforward style.

Read more

Great for wide feet
The zippers along the side of this model run all the way from the ankle opening to the sole, ideal for fitting wider feet comfortably.

Low Heel
The heel of this model only measures 1.25 inches, making this model a great option for shoppers who are afraid of heels that still want to rock the booties.

Cost and Value
The Rampage Tarragon Ankle Bootie is a versatile option made from high-quality materials. As a result, its price sits slightly higher than the average. But fear not, the overall quality of this model makes it a strong value, as it will last for a long time without showing wear.

9. Lucky Brand Basel

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
81.6
Lucky Brand Basel
Comfort
84
Heel
82
Traction
80
Versatility
81
Style
81
best offer for today
$109.95
Pros:

Rubber Sole

Pull-Tab

Dual Zippers

Cons:

Not Good in Rain

Peeling at Heel

Another model with double zippers, the Lucky Brand Basel Boot is a versatile and classy option that possesses a subtle style. A narrow body and tall ankle amplify this model, giving it a more formal air. But the stacked heel also makes it stable, making this shoe an extremely reliable option for any closet.

Read more

Stacked block heel
The stacked block heel on this show makes it very stable, ideal for professionals who are often on their feet. A relatively low heel adds to the long-term comfort of this bootie.

Dual zippers
The zippers along either side of the ankle make this model very easy to put on and take off.

Cost and Value
The Lucky Brand boots carry a slightly higher price tag, but the brand is respected and well known to create quality footwear. This particular model is priced slightly above the market average, but knowing the quality that comes along with it, you can be sure you are purchasing a great value for the price.

10. ZooShoo Western

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
80.4
ZooShoo Western
Comfort
81
Heel
82
Traction
78
Versatility
80
Style
81
best offer for today
$21.00
Pros:

Eco-Friendly

Cushioned Insole

Western Flair

Can Be Paired With Jeans Or Formal Dress

Cons:

Separation At Sole

Slippery

By perfectly combining Western style with modern class, this model is an extremely versatile and appealing bootie option. The body is composed of a simple, black, eco-friendly material and sits slightly lower on the ankle than average. A sharp angle that tapers to a narrow toe invokes the classic Western style without sacrificing formality.

Read more

Eco friendly material
For environmentally conscious shoppers, this model is a great option. Composed of materials that are both friendly animals and the environment, you can be confident you won’t be making a negative environmental impact with this purchase.

Versatile
The sleek and simple design of this shoe makes it ready to pair with almost any outfit. From formal work clothes to jeans, you will be comfortable knowing you look great in any situation.

Cost and Value
The simplicity of this model helps keep the price low. Quality, man-made materials give this shoe extra durability and the low arch also wears down more slowly than other models. Overall, the Western Ankle Boot Low Heel Closed Toe Casual Bootie is a very strong value for the price.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Comfort

Booties are versatile in their uses: you can rock them on the dance floor on Saturday night and turn around and wear them in the office on Monday. Either way, you are going to be on your feet a lot and need some shoes that will keep your feet feeling fresh and comfortable all day. The shoes on this list all possess advanced comfort features that put them (pardon the shameless pun) a step above the competition.

Some of the comfort features seen throughout our list include:

Extra padding in the sole – Any shoe with heels can be particularly hard on the heels. Because boots are so versatile, you will find yourself wearing them on multiple occasions and for long periods of time – enough to make anybody’s feet ache. Many of the shoes on this list address that area with additional padding along the insole that alleviates the pressure along both the arch of the foot and the heel.

Internal lining – An internal lining provides an extra layer of support and comfort all around the foot, but it also helps the shoe fit more securely around the unique shape of your foot. An increasingly popular feature, a bootie with internal lining will have you feeling like you’re walking on clouds – no matter how long you are on your feet.

Heel

This list is for shoppers of all kinds, so don’t be afraid to browse if you are hesitant around heels. While boots aren’t typically as wobbly as other high heels, we still made sure to select models that are fine for any wardrobe, be you an Olympic athlete or someone with two left feet.

When it comes to stability, there are certain points on the shoe that can really affect you. Things to watch for are:

Heel Width: This one is a no-brainer, but a shoe with a more narrow heel and sole will be less stable than a wider heel. If you aren’t so comfortable in heels, focus on finding a wider option or a wedge – they won’t make you look like you’re walking on ice all day.

Heel Height: The obvious follow up to heel width, you also want to be conscious of the height of the heel on your next bootie purchase. There are many options out there for heel height with everything from small wedges to 4-5 inch heels – so choose what feels most comfortable for you.

Traction

This is one of the major flaws of cheap booties and if you aren’t careful, you could end up with a shoe that will slide out from under you like it was greased. In compiling this list, we purposefully searched for boots with solid traction that will have you strutting your stuff confidently.

Versatility

The beauty of booties is that they are just so darn versatile. Almost any outfit can be paired with them and look great. We made sure that every pair on our list has the versatility to work with multiple outfits so you won’t be boxed out of wearing them as much as you possibly can (assuming the outfit calls for black shoes, of course).

Booties are not limited to just one type of look, and you can find many different types, ranging from completely flat to significantly heeled. If you are looking to change up your style, or are after a certain look then it’s good to take note of the different bootie styles available.

Style

Last, but certainly not least, we need to look at style. All of the models on our list just had to look good. The last thing we want to do is send you out the door with shopping bags full of booties that don’t look good. At the end of the day, shoes are a fashion statement, and these shoes look good.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
#1
Comfort
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#2
Heel
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#3
Traction
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#4
Versatility
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
#5
Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Pairing Booties

Booties are one of the most fun styles of footwear around, from their cage like wrap around the foot, to embellishments of zippers, fringe, or studs.
Pairing black booties is a simple basic, as the color can go with anything under the sun. The structure, or embellishment is what to pay attention to. Structured booties that have clean lines go great with other structured apparel like pencil skirts, while studded or embellished booties an be used as accent pieces for a punk or posh look.

Monochrome Style

Basic black from head to toe can certainly be a darker kind of statement, but add your booties to the base of some well coordinated pieces, and you've got a look to go anywhere.
Baggy black knit sweaters with jeans and studded booties is a great look for casual, concert-going, or evening's out on the town. A basic little black dress paired with patterned fishnet stockings and black booties makes for a fun goth kind of style, good for out on the town in the evenings!

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Is there a difference between ankle boots and booties?
a:

Though often confused, there actually is a difference between ankle boots and booties. Ankle boots are typically designed to end between one and four inches from your heel, while booties are designed to end at the heel itself.

q: Are booties safe in the snow and ice?
a:

If you’re set on wearing a shoe with a heel or lift on it in bad weather, booties are probably your best option. Typically designed with a thicker heel and a wider base, these shoes will give you more grip and stability in the snow and ice than other high-heeled shoes will.

q: Can booties be work with a formal outfit?
a:

This question is a bit trickier, simply because there are so many options available out there. Black is definitely a more formal color option, but you will need to keep in mind other features of the shoe as well such as the material, the attachments, etc. But technically, the right pair of boots could be the perfect foundation for a formal outfit.

q: Are booties comfortable?
a:

Like with any shoe, it varies from model to model, but they are generally viewed as a very comfortable shoe option. Many professionals who spend all day on their feet – like teachers – report that boots are a great option to look stylish and stay comfortable throughout the day.

q: Can booties provide ankle support?
a:

Not typically because they are designed to end at the ankle. Also, depending on the prominence and size of your ankle, you may find that they rub against your ankle, causing discomfort and pain. If you have very prominent or large ankle, you might want to consider an ankle boot instead.