Best Black Shoes Reviewed & Rated for Appearance
A great pair of high-quality black shoes is an essential item in any versatile closet. Basic black is always in fashion and is always a classic wardrobe staple. Everyone needs at least one pair of basic black shoes to complement their apparel. They are chic and often go with a wide variety of clothing and accessories as black is a neutral color that can be paired with many other colors.
Stop for a moment and think about your favorite outfits and the shoes you may consider wearing. Even if your initial thoughts did not include this color, it is likely that a pair of black footwear would complete several of the outfits that came to mind. Depending on the occasion, you may need black dress shoes or a pair of plain black sandals. Fortunately, they can be found in every size, shape, and style.
In a Hurry? The test winner after 105 hrs of research
Available in four widths
Provide great support
Rubber outsole to prevent slipping
- Easy Spirit Traveltime Clog
- Skechers Go Walk 4
- Asics Gel-Kayano 24
- Crocs Classic Clog
- New Balance MX608v4
- Converse Chuck Taylor
- Puma Suede Classic
- Kaitlyn Pan Pointed Toe
- Nike Air Monarch IV
- Dream Pairs Oxford Wingtip
- Criteria Used for Evaluation
- Other Factors to Consider
- Frequently Asked Questions
Top 10 Picks
1. Easy Spirit Traveltime Clog
Available in four widths
Provide great support
Rubber outsole to prevent slipping
Run a bit wide
The Easy Spirit Traveltime Clog is a great choice for those interested in a shoe that provides great arch support and durability. This clog is designed for walking and standing for long periods of time. The shoe is available in several colors and widths for a wide range of options. The Traveltime Clog is so comfortable that you will want to wear them everywhere you go.Read more
Padded, Removable Insole
The padded and removable insole is a great feature because the insole can be washed. The padding absorbs shock and provides a cushioned step.
Durable Rubber Outsole
The Easy Spirit Traveltime Clog is designed with a durable rubber outsole for added grip and traction which makes this shoe a great choice for those who are concerned about slipping.
Cost and Value
The Traveltime Clog is a great value due to the durability and comfort of the shoe. The design is a classic style that lasts from season to season. Available in black, this clog is sure to be a good fit for almost any budget. For a casual black shoe, look no further than this affordable option.
2. Skechers Go Walk 4
Promote a natural stride
A bit narrow through toe box
The Skechers Performance Go Walk 4 are unique shoes engineered with advanced technology that provide sensory feedback to the brain. Other elements of the shoe are created with proprietary elements as well that promote a natural stride which prevents back and foot pain. The slip-on style offers a quick option for sliding into a comfortable shoes.Read more
One of the most important features of the Skechers Performance Go Walk 4 are the Goimpulse sensors that move together and independently to provide sensory feedback to the brain which helps to promote a natural stride.
This proprietary design consists of an injection-molded compound that allows memory retention to help absorb impact. The memory retention also creates a custom fit that molds to the foot.
Cost and Value
The proprietary components of the Skechers Performance Go Walk 4 are of great value when it comes to the quality and value of these shoes. The advanced technology is something you would expect of high end expensive shoes. However, these shoes offer a quality alternative at an affordable price.
3. Asics Gel-Kayano 24
Impact Guidance System enhances natural foot function
Gel cushion system absorbs shock
Memory foam molds to heel for a better fit
Breathable mesh upper keeps foot dry and comfortable
Narrow toe box
The Asics Gel-Kayano 24 tennis shoes are a great choice that can be used for activities including running and cross training. Carefully engineered, the Asics Gel-Kayano meet the needs of those in the market for black shoes.Read more
Gel cushioning system
The rearfoot and forefoot gel cushioning systems are designed to absorb the impact when you land on the balls of your feet as well as when your heel hits the ground.
Personalized heel fit
The Gel-Kayano 24 features memory foam around the collar that mold to your heel to create a custom fit which reduces heel slippage and improves the fit of the shoe.
Cost and Value
In comparison to the Nike Free RN Flyknit, the Gel-Kayano 24 offers both a gel cushioning system as well as a memory foam custom fit collar. The design and structure of the Gel-Kayano 24 are elements that put these shoes at the top of the list for comfort and value.
4. Crocs Classic Clog
Ventilation system that allows air and water to pass through
Removable back strap
Only available in whole sizes
The Classic Clog from Crocs is a staple for many wardrobes as it is a multi-purpose shoe that can be worn in many casual settings. From a day at the lake to a day at the park, the Classic Clog is a great fit because it is waterproof and sturdy. With such versatility, many people find they want to buy a Croc in every color.Read more
The Crocs Classic Clog is a highly versatile shoe that is good for water sports, hikers, and others in the market for a functional shoe.
This shoe is designed with multiple ports in the side of the shoe to allow air and water to flow through. This design is perfect for those who may enjoy an active lifestyle.
Cost and Value
This iconic shoe is a great value because of its functionality. For casual shoes, the Crocs Classic Clog is a budget-friendly option. Whether you need a shoe for the park, or a shoe that is comfortable for walking, this classic shoe is a perfect solution. Black Crocs Classic Clogs are widely available and can be found at a low price point.
5. New Balance MX608v4
Looking for a blackout style sneaker to keep you training hard in and outside the gym? New Balance’s MX608v4 give a solid athletic sneaker a mean clean look with total black coloring from uppers to sole and logo. With internal shank to help provide support and stability, traction sole with a 10mm drop, and Abzorb heel technology, you’ll be sure to crush old personal bests and step up to the next goal.Read more
Not only does the MX608v4 have a thick rubber sole to help absorb impact, it’s also incorporated an EVA injection molded midsole and footbed for cushioned comfort. The Abzorb heel is a proprietary technology with foam-based polymer that helps absorb shock, especially in the heel, and help prevent pain. Leather uppers help keep this shoe flexible but durable for long wear.
The New Balance MX608v4 although an athletic sneaker, can be worn with many casual style outfits as well as giving solid performance in the gym or for outdoor athletics. It’s blackout style from sole to logo to uppers keeps it looking sleek and clean, and in the gym, they give a little bit of aggressive prowess to your workout. Careful on the court though, as these soles tend to leave scuff marks on the floor!
Cost and Value
For a sneaker, the New Balance MX608b4 is quite reasonably priced, and is versatile enough for wear during your workouts or for casual times. Great paired with jeans, shorts, or athletic wear, it’s sleek look gives a little attitude to your attire. Solid cushion and thick sole help keep these comfortable for all day wear, and are great for professionals such as nurses or doctors who may be on their feet all day as well.
6. Converse Chuck Taylor
Four grommets for laces
Narrow toe box
Laces are too short
The Converse Chuck Taylor is a classic shoe that has withstood the test of time. This iconic shoe is a gender neutral option for those looking for a casual black shoe that is good for walking or for accessorizing a cute outfit. Gentlemen may prefer to wear these with jeans or shorts. Ladies will find that the Chuck Taylor’s are a nice addition to shorts, skirts, jeans, and casual dresses.Read more
Unlined with a Cushioned Insole
While the Converse Chuck Taylor may be worn with or without socks, the unlined and cushioned insole means socks are not necessary unless you will be doing a lot of walking.
The Converse Chuck Taylor shoe is a classic style that features a rubber toe box, contrast sidewall trim, and side air vent holes to improve breathability.
Cost and Value
The Converse Chuck Taylor is an iconic style that has been around for years and will continue to be a popular choice for casual shoes for years to come.
7. Puma Suede Classic
- Padded Collar
- Special Rubber Outsole
- Comfortable Suede Upper
- Perforations for Breathability
- Reasonable Price
- Narrow Toe Box
The PUMA Classic Suede is the most popular of all PUMA shoes with good reason. This classic shoe is loaded with comfort and street style. A special rubber outsole makes sure your feet are firmly on the ground while a padded collar adds extra cushion. Built-in perforations provide extra breathability and allow air to flow freely around your toes and feet, while a trendy suede upper keeps you looking on-pointe.Read more
PUMAs' Classic Suede is the most popular and well-known of all PUMA shoes making these a long-standing pair of footwear that never seem to go out of style. Look effortlessly cool in these all-black consumer favorites.
A lightweight and breathable shoe, the PUMA Classic Suede will keep your feet feeling great. A padded collar adds additional cushion while built-in perforations allow your feet to breath. The Classic's super comfy suede upper and special, maximum grip rubber outsole, will have you coming back for more.
Cost & Value
These PUMA's are relatively budget-friendly considering the infamous branding behind them. PUMA's are ultra-comfortable and offer an effortlessly stylish wear that is worth every penny.
8. Kaitlyn Pan Pointed Toe
Can Be Slippery
Not for Wet Weather
Talk about a pair of shoes that embody femme fatale at it’s best!!! The Kaitlyn Pan Pointed Toe heel combines several hot trends of 2018 all into one stylish pair of killer pumps. With strappy ankle closure and 4 inch heel, it accentuates the foot and calves for more formal occasions. However, when combined with studded straps and pointed toe design, this pair puts noir back into the evening hours! A show stopper for any evening!Read more
For 2018, strappy style flats and pumps are in, as well as those with some kind of studded or jeweled accents. With a cage like strap to hold the foot in place, studded with metal pyramid shaped studs, it brings an edgy feel to elegance. The 4 inch heel gives just enough height to accentuate the calves and legs without feeling uncomfortable of off balance.
Black Point Toe
Another trendy still in style for 2018 are pointed toe shoes, as well as square toed shoes. The Kaitlyn Pan Pointed Toe has a tapered point to the toe box which makes it perfect for wearing with dresses and skirts, but also long trousers or jeans. And, to make an even bolder statement with these studded beauties, you can pair with a bright solid color such as yellow or orange to keep some sophisticated rocker to your style.
Cost and Value
Slightly more expensive than some on our list, but for a quality pair of amazingly designed heels, the Kaitlyn Pan Pointe Toe heel is a strappy fun pair to add to your collection. Black color option will pair great with bright colors or prints, and the studded accents give a little urban edge to your attire. Perfect for statement makers looking for a night out on the town!
9. Nike Air Monarch IV
Moderate arch support
True to size
Non-marking, solid rubber outsole
Potentially loud on slick floors
The highly rated Nike Air Monarch IV tennis shoe is available in an all black lace-up style for athletic training or casual wear. These tennis shoes are a reliable shoe in a classic style that lasts from year to year. These shoes are an excellent, stylish option that fit your feet and budget well.Read more
All Leather Upper
The Nike Air Monarch IV consists of an all leather upper for added protection and durability. The stylish look of the all leather upper add to the overall aesthetic appeal of these tennis shoes.
Non-Marking, Solid Rubber Outsole
Many athletic facilities require shoes with non-marking outsoles to protect gym floors. The Nike Air Monarch IV shoes do not leave marks behind and offer slip protection with a solid rubber outsole.
Cost and Value
Comfort and performance-wise, the Nike Air Monarch IV are one of the best black shoes in this price range for the value. These shoes are durable and can withstand both casual wear as well as athletic training.
10. Dream Pairs Oxford Wingtip
For a formal pair of oxford style shoes, Dream Pairs Oxford Wingtip gives the basic classic oxford an upgrade. Wingtip toe gives an added sophistication and décor to the basic black look, and brogueing adds some design element as well as function to keep you cooler. A more formal style of dress shoe, it’s best suited to business functions or formal occasions and gatherings, even weddings! A perfect option for a bit of classic style with individual flair.Read more
Most oxford style footwear consists of a closed lace system which pulls the vamps together leaving little gap. It gives a very formal look to the shoe, keeping clean and classy in the forefront of design. The Oxford Wingtip ups this classic styling with patters of perforations called brogues, that not only add some design flair, but function to help cool the foot as well. Wingtip toes make this pair fancy for dancing, or wherever you want to make an impression.
Faux leather constructs the uppers, giving the shoe a sleek somewhat shiny look and appeal. A wooden heel gives a confident height, and hidden eyelets typical of oxford style footwear keep the uppers looking clean and sleek. And, as a little added bonus, the soles of these shoes have a brogue pattern etched into the bottom so you can step in style leaving your mark!
Cost and Value
For a formal pair of oxford shoes, Dream Pairs Oxford Wingtip is an extremely budget friendly buy. With its decorative styling from wingtips to brogues, sleek clean look, and formal style black shoe, it’s best suited for formal or business attire. You’ll be sure to make an impact at the next fancy affair in this pair of black shoes!
Criteria Used for Evaluation
The footbed or insole is the part of the shoe where the foot rests on. Insoles are often made with specific structural elements and unique layers that offer better fit, support, and comfort. The materials used to construct the footbed include;
EVA (ethylene vinyl acetate): EVA is a man-made foam material that absorbs shock and adds extra comfort. EVA can be compression molded to fit desired shapes and sizes and can be crafted from both recycled materials or mixed with other materials, including cork.
Naturally Occurring Materials: Natural materials often used for footbeds include; latex, rubber bamboo, rope, cork, and leather. These materials offer a lot of benefits like comfort, breathability, and durability, but some wearers avoid them because they are not vegan materials.
The outsole is the part of the shoe that makes contact with the ground and protects your feet from hazards. The outsole is also the part of the shoe that will prevent slips, guard against water, and allow you to walk on specific types of terrain.
One of the most popular choices for outsoles is, Vibram®. Vibram outsoles are long-lasting and can be found in all different styles of shoes, in-particular, hiking shoes. Vibram outsoles offer excellent grip and prevent any accidental slips or falls and are a registered trademark of Vibram S.P.A.
The upper is the whole part of the shoe that covers your foot. The upper may be stitched or molded with the sole to make one whole unit. Upper units are made from a variety of materials, both natural and synthetics. Leather is a popular choice for the uppers’ material because it is breathable and help maintain a consistent temperature. Synthetic materials cost less than animal skins and are widely used in all types of shoes today. Synthetics provide waterproofing and durability which makes them a good consideration.
The heel can mean either is the back area of a shoe, or the solid part that holds the heel cup The most common heights for a shoes’ heel to be are:
There are also an array of unique heel structures and styles, including:
Stacked Heel: A heel consisting of horizontal lines, giving the appearance that the heel is made up of stacked layers of leather.
Negative Heel: A favorite choice for comfortable footwear, this is a type of footbed with a lowered heel area that is designed to encourage more natural foot placement.
Sculpted Heel: A type of high heel that’s made from high-impact plastic and is molded in one piece.
Wedge Heel: A chunky heel that extends from the back of the shoe to the ball of the shoe.
Breathability and airflow are a principal consideration when selecting a pair of shoes. Black shoes, in particular, need to have adequate ventilation because dark colors have a tendency to trap heat and make for a warmer wear than a shoe of lighter color.
The materials used to construct a shoe can make a big difference in how well feet can breathe. Certain materials are better for airflow than others, materials like:
Controlling moisture and eliminating sweaty feet will make for a comfortable wear and will help prevent odors from occurring. When selecting a pair of black shoes it is a good idea to look for ones with either built-in air ventilation holes or moisture wicking properties. Moisture wicking is a process that pulls moisture away from the foot and wicks it towards the outer surface where it can evaporate easier.
If you have your heart set on a pair of shoes that don’t wick moisture you can try one of these long-standing tricks to help eliminate moisture and sweat; sprinkle talcum(baby) powder in your shoe, or use a deodorizing powder from the store and dust it in your shoes.
Dress shoes are worn for formal or smart casual gatherings and could be described as the opposite of an athletic shoe. Dress shoes are the typical attire for dancing, on special occasions, and for attending a more formal party.
Traditionally, dress shoes, particularly men’s, will be made entirely from leather which exudes elegance and style. Though rubber can commonly be used to form the outsole which would offer a more durable and less slippery shoe but can also detract from the shoe’s prestige. Black is the perfect shade of dress shoes because it matches with practically every color and offers an air of professionalism.
Casual and athletic shoes always look good in black. Dark colored footwear gives an illusion that the wearers feet are smaller than they actually are and black tends to match with any outfit.
For athletic shoes, black is a popular choice, in part because it tends to conceal dirt and mud better than light colored shoes and this is often a problem athlete’s face.
Summer shoes don’t have to be light colored to look good while keeping you cool and comfortable. People have a tendency to perceive black shoes as being too warm to wear in the summer but that’s just not true.
If you are planning to wear dark footwear in warm weather opt for a pair that is made of light and breathable materials such as canvas, and mesh.
While style is often a matter of personal taste, we've checked thousands of online reviews to see what people are saying about each of the products on our list. Some things, such as sleek design, seamless construction and overall weight and shape of the shoe, were common likes or dislikes among buyers of each product.
To evaluate style, we considered everything from the design, color, shape, weight, lines and overall construction of the shoe in question. While no one wants to wear an uncomfortable shoe, they also don’t want a comfortable shoe to be ugly on the eyes. We’ve selected all of those on our top 10 to be not only stylish, but also comfortable, true-to-size, supportive and durable.
The higher the score on the “style” metric, the more fashionable we and the community of buyers we surveyed deemed the product to be.
Finding a perfectly-fitting pair of shoes can be like finding the holy grail; there are so many brands, styles, models and makes of shoes that it seems like it’s next to impossible, especially when you are shopping online! Fear not, as we’ve ranked each product on our list for their fit and trueness-to-size to help guide you in finding the perfect match for you.
To come up with a score for fit of a shoe, we considered several factors, like the ones mentioned above, in addition to real customer reviews, to help boil down everything into one simple score. For example, Nike tends to make shoes that are true-to-size, meaning that you can buy a pair of 11s one year, and another pair of 11s next year in a different model, and they will usually still fit (unless your feet grown or shrank). A brand like Nike will most likely have a high score when it comes to fit, but the other variables in play, such as make, model and purpose, will also affect the overall score.
Consider that a running shoe, with its thicker midsole and synthetic sole, might fit differently than a flat shoe, with its thinner midsole and hypothetical leather sole. Each of these shoes, even if they are both from Nike, may have similar scores for trueness-to-size, but a size 11 in one might not be the same as an 11 in the other. What’s a reader to do in this case? You must also consider the purpose and type of shoe it is. Knowing what kind of shoe you are buying, and for what purpose, will help you make a better decision. A running shoe might run smaller than a flat because it has thicker materials, so read customer reviews as well to arrive at the best decision for fit, in addition to just our overall score.
Expert Interviews & Opinions
Basic black footwear should be a staple in anyone's collection of footwear. Aside from the type of shoe you get, black goes with anything and everything, making it the most versatile color of footwear to have.
While other colors of shoes can be a bit easy to manage caring for, black can fade over time if not properly stored. Keep your black shoes away from direct sunlight to prevent color fading, and when washing, hand wash with soap and water if textile or canvas, and let them air dry.
Leathers or suedes can use a shoe protectant to ward off weather related spills or damage, and leather polish or conditioner will help them to keep their color along with supple texture.
Other Factors to Consider
When you are shopping for the perfect pair of black footwear, there are countless options. However, with the multitude of choices of styles and brands, it is important to select a pair that will not only meet your fashion needs but will also be a good investment in terms of price and quality. If you can only have one pair of shoes, you cannot go wrong with a simple but high-quality pair of black shoes.
Black footwear is a great addition to all wardrobes. Always fashionable, black shoes offer an opportunity to find the perfect fit for any type of shoe and are always popular because they compliment almost every outfit. There are countless styles available to shoppers of all ages and for all lifestyles. Since they can go with a variety of outfits, whether it is a business meeting or day at the park, you can choose shoes that look professional when you need to impress or throw on a pair of comfortable sandals when you are ready to relax.
The shoes that made the Top 10 Black Shoe list offer a wide variety of options made from premium materials. Although these shoes are of high quality, the prices are reasonable if you find yourself on a tight budget. Whether you are looking for a casual everyday pair or tennis shoes for athletic training, this list offers great options for every occasion. Every pair you find here offers the ultimate in comfort and value. Take a moment to consider which pair suits your needs best, and then go ahead and step out in style!
Frequently Asked Questions
Black is a versatile shade that can be easily paired with any color and still look good. When it comes to dress shoes, both men and women seek out black colored footwear because it is perceived as being more professional looking, as well as for the extreme versatility in terms of matching shoes to an outfit.
This really depends on the style of shoe and the materials that it’s made from. Below you will find care instructions for different materials;
Suede: To remove dirt gently brush debris and dirt from your shoe, or if you have scuffs try using a more force which will bring life back to aged suede while removing stubborn scuffs.
Leather: Dust leather with a soft brush and follow with a soft cloth and some toothpaste to shine and remove scuffs. Be sure to rub gently as to prevent any further scuffing or scratches. If you find that you have a few oil or grease marks you can dust baking soda over the stain and leave it on overnight, by the morning the mark will be gone but the black color will not have faded.
Canvas or Mesh: Dilute a tiny bit of laundry soap with water and use a toothbrush to scrub away any stains or marks. If you are in a hurry to dry your shoes afterward, use an old newspaper to absorb any excess moisture.
While black shoes have a tendency to be warmer than those of a lighter color, they can still be a good choice to wear while playing sports in warm weather. Black shoes are good for sports because they hide dirt and mud better than light colored shoes and as long as they are made from a breathable and lightweight material, there is no reason why your feet should be any warmer than if you were wearing a light colored shoe.
If your socks are visible while you are wearing your shoes than it is not the best idea to wear a white sock. Contrasting white and black with make your white socks stand out all the more and will draw unwanted attention to that area of your body. There are lots of black socks available in all different heights and materials that will pair much better with black shoes.
There are, however, darker colored socks that can be worn well with black footwear. Dress socks, for example, come in different patterns like stripes and checkers that look professional with a black shoe.
- BLACKED OUT: 15 BEST ALL BLACK SNEAKERS FOR MEN, Article, Jan 18, 2018 ,
- 10 Best Black Shoes For Men, Article, Jan 02, 2018 ,
- Black Running Shoes You’ll Want to Wear On the Run and Beyond, Article, Feb 20, 2018 ,
- What Is Abzorb®?, ,
- Vogue's Ultimate Shoe Guide Spring/Summer 2018, ,
- 12 Shoe Trends You'll Want to Wear All Spring Long, ,
- The Spring 2018 Shoe Trends That Fashion's 'It' Girls Are Wearing, ,