to top 10 table

Best Fishing Boots & Hip Waders Reviewed

last updated Dec 03, 2018

While you’re looking forward to the weekend, heading off to work in the fishery industry or planning your next fishing excursion, wherever it will be, knowing that you have the best boots for your particular needs will be the best preparation you could make. Are you in cold waters or warm waters? Are the waters spring-fed from the mountains, in which case they will often be freezing? All of these conditions will impact your comfort and determine what you wear, and you should consider this before choosing your preferred boot.

Researched Sources
14
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1100
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
18
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Sorting Options
Weight Water Resistance Durability Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
Weight
94%
Water Resistance
98%
Durability
90%
Value
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$106.59
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Weight
91%
Water Resistance
95%
Durability
92%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$119.00
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
Weight
90%
Water Resistance
92%
Durability
95%
Value
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$93.30
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Weight
89%
Water Resistance
94%
Durability
88%
Value
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$18.61
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.3
Weight
89%
Water Resistance
90%
Durability
91%
Value
87%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$47.29
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.3
Weight
87%
Water Resistance
87%
Durability
90%
Value
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$29.99
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.3
Weight
88%
Water Resistance
89%
Durability
90%
Value
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$29.75
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.3
Weight
86%
Water Resistance
87%
Durability
88%
Value
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$91.12
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.3
Weight
83%
Water Resistance
87%
Durability
86%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$22.94
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
Weight
83%
Water Resistance
87%
Durability
85%
Value
81%
Price Comparison Last Updated (10.12.18)
$92.77
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Allen Company Blue River
  • MuckBoots Edgewater
  • MuckBoots Scrub
  • Magid Servus
  • Kamik Hunter
  • ALEADER Water Shoe
  • Honeywell Servus
  • XTRATUF Legacy
  • Custom Leathercraft F23011
  • Caddis Chest Wader
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Fishing Boots

1. Allen Company Blue River

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.5
Allen Company Blue River
Weight
94
Water Resistance
98
Durability
90
Value
92
best offer for today
$106.59
Pros:
  • Completely Waterproof
  • Light & Roomy Construction
  • Durable & Longlasting 
  • Easy To Get On & Off
  • Good Length For Most Users
Cons:
  • Buckles Are Not High Quality
  • Soles Too Pliable For Some

These waders have great features for the fishing enthusiast. Rated as extremely comfortable by many users, these boots are perfect for warm weather use. They also have numerous pockets and gravel guards are attached. There is also an included belt. The Allen Company River Breathable Waterproof Wader boots are very quick and easy to put on and also to remove.

Read more

Lightweight and waterproof
For use in warmer temperatures, these non-insulated shoes are highly rated by professional users as well as recreational users for being non-bulky and completely waterproof in extreme conditions.

Roomy fit
The fit works well for most users, taking the boot comfortably up over the hip and usable with heavy socks if desired. They can also accommodate a heavy pair of work pants.

Cost and Value
These boots are priced very low compared to the other fishing boots mentioned in this comparison review. They offer excellent value for a very low price. Some users report being surprised at the level of quality for this price point.

2. MuckBoots Edgewater

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
MuckBoots Edgewater
Weight
91
Water Resistance
95
Durability
92
Value
90
best offer for today
$119.00
Pros:
  • Quick-Dry Neoprene
  • Grippy Rubber Soles
  • Pull On Ease
  • Achilles Support Panel
  • Waterproof Bottom
Cons:
  • Sizing Issues

This is a boot that is waterproof to above ankle height and quick dry neoprene in the shaft. Not for getting out into the middle of the stream but great for shoreline fishing. It is also great for getting to those secret fishing spots that are a little further back into rougher terrain. MuckBoots are built to be durable and hard-working, and the Edgewater is no different.

Read more

Pull on ease
These boots pull on easily over a thick pair of socks. The neoprene is flexible and stretches well enough to get your foot into the boot easily. The lower part of the boot also features a reinforced panel for Achilles support.

Grippy, rubber sole
Fishing is a slippery business, and we’re not just talking about the fish. The shoreline, streambeds and lake bottoms can all post slip and fall hazards to the unwary. These boots feature a grippy outsole that can cope with those conditions. And if you get in a little too deep, the neoprene shaft will dry quickly as well.

Cost and Value
These boots are priced in the mid-range of the list and represent a very good value given that they are a versatile, comfortable boot that can take a lot of beating and keep coming back for more. Whether you’re fishing from the shoreline or working in wet conditions, these boots will keep up.

3. MuckBoots Scrub

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.5
MuckBoots Scrub
Weight
90
Water Resistance
92
Durability
95
Value
89
best offer for today
$93.30
Pros:

Mid Calf

Protection

Insulated

Price

Unisex Fit

Cons:

Sizing May Vary

MuckBoots is no stranger to keeping folks warm and dry with their footwear, made for messy or wet conditions, and packed full of insulation. This 8-inch boot is perfect for shallow wading and comes about mid-calf height. A flexible shell gives ample room for maneuvering, and a comfort stretch nylon shaft gives a snug fit. Perfect for creeks and shallow riverbeds!

Read more

Outer Shell
Constructed from both rubber and textile, the Scrub will help insulate and keep you warm in cooler water temperatures but maintains enough flexibility so you can maneuver as needed for the catch. Not only does rubber help insulate you, but being reinforced, it helps add protection to your foot for scrambling across stones and pebbles, without fear of seriously banging your toes.

Breathable
Within the Scrub boot is a breathable AirMesh lining, made to help wick away moisture from your feet and help keep you dry, even when water is rushing around you. This will help keep the boot smelling fresh and cut down on bacteria harboring inside the shoe. A comfort stretch nylon shaft helps keep you fit in place and makes these easy to get on and off.

Cost and Value
Moderately priced compared to those found on our list, the MuckBoots Scrub is a great boot for those looking to fish in shallow water such as creeks, river bed edges, or ponds. It's well insulated and protective, and definitely worth the investment. Available in neutral to brighter colors, this boot also has a unisex fit, so be sure to size accordingly!

4. Magid Servus

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.5
Magid Servus
Weight
89
Water Resistance
94
Durability
88
Value
91
best offer for today
$18.61
Pros:
  • Steel-Toed
  • Seamless Construction
  • Degradation Resistant
  • Flexible Shaft
  • Lightweight Cushioning
  • Cleated Outsole
Cons:
  • Not Especially Durable

What is more protective than a steel-toed waterproof boot? The Magid Servus is a seamless, 100% waterproof, flexible boot that is used for a variety of purposes including fishing, hunting, agriculture, and animal husbandry, all while protecting the toe of your foot from the hazards of hard work and rocks in streams. The outsole is well cleated for additional protection as well.

Read more

Degradation resistant
Along with being waterproof, this boot is resistant to a number of chemicals including agricultural chemicals, fertilizers, and animal waste. It is seamless, and the sole is also rated for electrical hazards for additional protection. These boots will take whatever fishing can throw at them and then some.

Slip-resistant
The sole on this boot features a number of deep angle cleats that help you keep your footing on slippery surfaces – great for fishing and other slippery hazards you may encounter. The boot will help prevent a fall but remember that no boot is completely slip-proof so you’ll still need to watch what you’re stepping in.

Cost and Value
These boots are incredibly inexpensive. For the value, you get a great boot for fishing or other wet work that will resist degradation while protecting your feet from slips, falls and things being dropped on them. They are also good for work – the versatility increases the value you get for an extraordinarily low price.

5. Kamik Hunter

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.3
Kamik Hunter
Weight
89
Water Resistance
90
Durability
91
Value
87
best offer for today
$47.29
Pros:

Insulated

Traction

One Year Warranty

Thermal Guard

Cons:

Price

Sizing Can Vary

It’s not every day you come across a budget-friendly pair of waterproof 13-inch boots to add to your gear of angling, but the Kamik Hunter is perfect for all levels of fishing participants. This knee-high boot is rated for -40F temperatures, and has a solid waterproof upper. For over 100 years, Kamik has made boots for northern sport and outdoor enthusiasts alike, so you’re sure to stay insulated, dry, and warm. Best of all, they recycle their rubber, and the boot has a one year warranty!

Read more

Insulated Protection
Rated for temperatures down to -40F, the Hunter also has an 8mm removable Thermal Guard liner, so if you find yourself a bit too warm, you can adjust the insulation. This liner is a two-layer system, that helps to keep moisture clear but retain body heat. A waterproof nylon collar is adjustable at the opening of the boot with drawstring ties, so you can secure your foot and keep out the water.

Traction
The Hunter has a rugged EXPLORER outsole, that will allow you firm traction on slippery ground or ice. As a bonus, the rubbers used in constructing Kamik’s boots are recycled, giving sustainability for those anglers concerned with environmental effects. Ideal for cooler rivers, ice, or streams, this boot will keep you firmly planted on all sorts of surfaces!

Cost and Value
One of the more budget-friendly boot options on our list, it’s a great addition to the newer fisher or expert angler alike. For those who ice fish, this boot is a solid option to consider not only for its insulation but lugged outsole as well. Anyone finding themselves in cooler water or temperature will love the Kamik Hunter!

6. ALEADER Water Shoe

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.3
ALEADER Water Shoe
Weight
87
Water Resistance
87
Durability
90
Value
89
best offer for today
$29.99
Pros:

Slip On

Mesh

Water Shoe

Price

Cons:

For Beginners Or Casual Fishers

Protection

The first water shoe to make an appearance on our list is the ALEADER Water Shoe, designed for the novice or warm water fisher. For some, a simple shoe such as this will suffice, especially for shoreline fishing, or warmer creeks. This Water Shoe not only allows open breathability with its construction design, but it has supportive features as well as incredible traction for a water shoe. And, if you’re just starting into fishing as a hobby, it could be a great starter shoe option for you as its quite easy on the wallet.

Read more

Construction
Uppers are made from a durable mesh, allowing breathability. This, of course, doesn’t make the shoe waterproof, but if your intentions are for shore surfing or to fish in warmer waters, it’s a solid option for consideration. Mesh allows these to dry quickly, and allows them to be washable should they start to pick up dirt or odors. A heel and tongue loop help you to slip these on quickly, so you won’t need to fuss with anything but the bait.

Support and Cushioning
A ComfortDry sockliner resides inside the shoe for cushioning, but helps to dry out the shoe after use, and promotes better shoe environment throughout the lifespan. Solyte midsoles give a lightweight bouncy feel, so with each step energy is returned to you, reducing foot fatigue. Water Grain outsoles give exceptional traction control but allow water drainage as well.

Cost and Value
If you’re just starting out into fishing, or intend to shoreline fish, or cast in warmer waters, this shoe is a perfect, budget-friendly option to do so. Investing in more expensive boots is ideal for those who peruse angling as a hobby, but a simple water shoe such as ALEADER’s Water Shoe, can help the beginner decide if this hobby is a passion, and requires more investment.

7. Honeywell Servus

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.3
Honeywell Servus
Weight
88
Water Resistance
89
Durability
90
Value
86
best offer for today
$29.75
Pros:
  • Slip-Resistant
  • Very Durable
  • Lighter In Weight
  • Safety Features
  • Customizable Height
Cons:
  • Sizes Run Large

The Honeywell Servus Shrimp Boots are made specifically for harsh weather on land or at sea. These are made to resist animal waste that would be encountered on shrimp boats and is useful for other applications as well, including shoreline, off the dock and onboard fishing. With a tough sole, upper and shaft, these boots can take a beating.

Read more

Contoured insole
The Honeywell Servus comes with a contoured insole for cushioning and support to your foot. Whether you work on a fishing boat or fish as a relaxing hobby, you will enjoy a great deal of comfort in this boot. It also features a steel shank for stability and to reduce leg and foot fatigue.

Soft & Flexible
The boot is made of injection-molded PVC which will stay flexible and comfortable in colder environments. The construction also makes the boots lightweight. Add in arch and heel support and you have a boot you can work in all day long.

Cost and Value
The boots are very inexpensive given their quality, comfort, durability and safety features. For just a little more than our least expensive boot, you get a boot that will last, be easy on your feet is also slip-resistant and safe for work or play on the slick deck of a boat.

8. XTRATUF Legacy

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.3
XTRATUF Legacy
Weight
86
Water Resistance
87
Durability
88
Value
84
best offer for today
$91.12
Pros:
  • Latex Neoprene
  • Flexible & Strong
  • Slip-Resistant
  • Non-Marking
  • Moisture-Wicking
Cons:
  • Sizes Run Narrow

These are a very tough waterproof boot that is great for the female angler. Made to be worn with thick socks, they also feature a durable, slip-resistant sole. Great for any wet conditions, these are especially comfortable when standing in the stream waiting for that record-breaking trout to grab your fly. This year you’ll get him, for sure.

Read more

Resistant & Waterproof
Waterproofing is important for fishing. If only they would appear on dry land… These boots are also resistant to ozone, acid, and chemicals. They are made from a triple-dipped latex neoprene for lightweight and pliability along with great resistance.

Protective construction
The boots are built on a female-specific last. The heel counter prevents a narrower heel from moving around in the boot ensuring a more secure fit. They are also built with toe and heel guards that protect the boot (and your feet) from abrasion. They are slip-resistant as well.

Cost and Value
These fishing boots are priced in the mid-range relative to the rest of the list. They are a versatile boot made especially for the security of a woman’s foot. Resistant to almost everything, you can use them for activities other than fishing as well, where a comfortable, waterproof boot is necessary.

9. Custom Leathercraft F23011

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.3
Custom Leathercraft F23011
Weight
83
Water Resistance
87
Durability
86
Value
85
best offer for today
$22.94
Pros:
  • EVA Formed Sole
  • Cleated Outsole
  • Over The Sock Sizing
  • Durable PVC
  • Scalloped top line
Cons:
  • No Ankle Support

These durable PVC boots will be an angler’s best friend. With good traction, good comfort and waterproofing, these are ideal for fishing wherever, whenever. They also come at a very reasonable price for the hobbyist or the industrial fisherman.

Read more

Cleated sole
Wet surfaces are slippery surfaces and fishing is full of those. These boots are designed for improved traction in wet conditions – whether it’s fishing or just working in the rain. The sole is made of the same PVC as the rest of the boot, making it very durable as well.

Over the sock sizing
Over the sock, sizing means that the boots fit a little large so you can wear thick woolen, warm socks under them. They will also accommodate a pant leg-in wear and feature a scalloped shaft that will flex and not irritate your calves.

Cost and Value
These boots are priced at the low end of the range and represent a very good value given their durability, traction, and comfort. The EVA foot form makes the boot feel more like a sneaker inside. The boot will also last quite a bit longer than many ‘wet’ boots on the market.

10. Caddis Chest Wader

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
84
Caddis Chest Wader
Weight
83
Water Resistance
87
Durability
85
Value
81
best offer for today
$92.77
Pros:

Chest Wader

Double Knees

Gravel Guards

Pockets

Cons:

Price

Color Options

For the female angler, the Caddis Chest Wader is a brilliantly designed wader, with softer pastel coloring, but capable to fit men or women equally well. Packed full of pockets, adjustability, guards and water resistance, it’s sure to keep you dry when you’ve got to get deeper into the water for your catch. Double taped feet are glued shut so no water creeps into your feet, so you can be confident stepping out for your cast.

Read more

Construction
With a breathable outer shell consisting of polyester to help keep you warm, but also CaddisDry technology which helps keep water out while allowing perspiration to escape, the Caddis Chest Wader will have you comfortable in any kind of weather. The stockingfoot design is double taped and glued for added water protection, and quality stitching help bolster the integrity of the foot. Adjustable deluxe suspenders make this wader able to fit any height, so you can get the best fit possible.

Features
Not only is the Caddis Chest Wader packed full of waterproof insulation, but it also has attached and breathable gravel guards to prevent any silt from creeping in where it should be. Double knees help to give flexibility and durability, and a new Quad pocket allows for storage of everything you may need instead of a vest. For all your fly fishing needs, this wader certainly has you covered.

Cost and Value
When compared to other chest wader models and brand, its similarly priced, but when you consider the one year manufacturer’s warranty, stylish look, and feature packed design, it’s a smart purchase. If you’re new or a veteran for fly fishing, the Caddis Chest Wader is a great option to consider for your next new pair!

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Weight

If you have read reviews from fishing boot purchasers online, you will often see that someone will say that they had too much tightness in the ankle, or that the boots they bought were either too small or too large. Keep in mind that different manufacturers use different lasts, or 3-dimensional molds made of wood or plastic to construct their boots. The overall fit of your shoe is determined by the last, which has the following dimensions: Forefoot width, heel width, and instep height. Of course, you can always send them back for another size, but if you’re about to leave on a big fishing trip the next day, that may not be an option. So what do you do?

The sizing could vary accordingly. You can easily check the reviews to see if the boots you have chosen has a few customers who write that they should have ordered one size up. Then you will know the tendency of that particular brand in terms of sizing.

Remember as well that many fishing boots use a sock on sizing, which means they are meant to fit larger to accommodate thick socks underneath.

Some fishing boots and hip waders are much lighter than others. Although it may seem like a few extra ounces would not make a difference, if you are standing in the water for hours and days at a time, it’s something to consider, depending on the temperature of the water you want to fish in. If the temperature is cold, then you will have to choose for a heavier boot or wader to stay warm.

Unless you are angling in very cold water, you always have the option to choose for PVC construction soles over rubber soles, which are somewhat heavier and will increase energy expenditure.

So be sure to check the weight on the shoes you are considering, and compare. A few hours or even a day of wearing an extra few ounces could make a big difference in your day out in the water.

Water Resistance

It’s so important to make sure that the boot or wader you choose keeps you dry, which means it has to be 100% waterproof and doesn’t fail when you are out enjoying angling for the day.

To have your socks and pants taking on water will really spoil your day out, as well as being dangerous if you are in a colder-water environment of sub-zero, for example. When you’re out angling you’re often far away from having an easy change of clothing at hand. Suffering from hypothermia because your boots are not 100% waterproof is not an option anyone wants to consider. However, sometimes having a simple water shoe can suffice if the water is warm enough, so long as the sole has a firm grip or tread. Who doesn’t love the feel of warm water on a hot day?

Durability

If you’re trudging through water or standing while waiting patiently for a fish, a boot that can last as long as you can is truly necessary. This list features certain qualities of footwear that ensure your boots will still look and feel like new after long time use.

To protect the stitching and construction, rubber guards are a feature that shouldn’t be overlooked when searching for a shoe intended to use with sports gear. Small features such as this set long-term wear boots apart from their short-living counterparts.

Value

Let’s be honest for a minute, if you are in the market for a pair of fishing boots, you already know that you are going to be paying top dollar for a great pair. The reality is, they are not the cheapest boots on the market. With that being said, since this buying guide was focused on reviewing an assortment of footwear, we did take into consideration the differences in the price tags.

Reason being, if there is a quality boot that offers the same features as a more expensive boot, we want to ensure that we share that with you. So, as we performed our research and picked out products, we carefully noted how much the product was and compared its value to others from the brand. Using this tool, we can say that these 10 footwear choices are the absolute best from the brand in style, value, and in price.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
1
Weight
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
2
Water Resistance
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
3
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
4
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Beginner Fishing Tips

If you're newer to the love of fishing, but have been on a few trips and found you have a passion for the sport, it's time to invest in some quality gear to help you enjoy afternoons at the lake or river.
Depending on your environment and climate, chest waders are an excellent investment that allow you to head out into the water without getting wet, to reach some of the more isolated spots for fishing.
If your budget is limited, taller boots are a great option when combined with waterproof pants!

Caring For Waders

If you've invested in a pair of waders, it's a good idea to care for that well spent money! Always clean off your waders after you fishing trip, removing any dirt or mud, so they stay clean, but don't degrade over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Is rubber or PVC construction best for a fishing boot or hip wader?
a:

Depending on where you are angling, you may prefer a lightweight boot. In this case, you should probably choose a PVC boot, unless the water where you are fishing is on the extremely cold side, where a rubber boot may serve your purposes better.
A PVC boot is around 25% lighter than a rubber boot, and if you’re standing all day in a rushing stream or river, this will have an effect on your stamina.

q: How much traction does felt provide v.s. cleated soles?
a:

The level of traction is dependent on many factors in the environment. Of course, sometimes the decision to choose between felt and cleated soles is already made for you. In some states, it is illegal to have cleated soles (so that the water environment is not too changed by human traffic moving about on the bottom of the river or stream) so in this case, you will have to choose for felt soles.
Actually, both types of soles provide excellent traction, but one has less impact on the natural environment and is therefore preferable. So it’s important to find out your local rules, or the rules of the area you plan to visit and make sure you have either interchangeable soles or that you purchase the right sole for the area.

q: Will wading boots be safe on slippery rocks, both above and under the surface?
a:

Many users report that their shoes “stick like Velcro” to moss-covered rocks that are covered by flowing water. If you know your environment, and where you plan to use the boots or waders, have a look at the comments of the users online to see how the traction compares from one boot to another. It’s usually best to cast from thigh-high water and not go much deeper.
It’s also really important that the fit is perfect and supports your feet properly so that you can maintain your balance under all conditions. You want to avoid any possibility of injury by being well prepared for your fishing activities.

q: What is the main consideration when choosing a lighter boot over a heavier one?
a:

A lighter boot or wader will feel more weightless on your feet, and if the conditions are not extremely cold or sub-zero, these may be preferred. A lighter boot will not have as much insulation, but the lighter weight will make it easier for you to stand in the water and move about for hours at a time.
Of course, in colder conditions, you will have to choose for a heavier boot. The good news is that Thinsulate insulation is available in many boots and waders, and does not add much weight to the boot.