10 Best Oxford Shoes Reviewed & Tested

The world is a complicated place, especially when it comes to fashion and versatility. We want our shoes to be able to stand the test of time. We want them to be comfortable.

Best-Oxford-Shoes-oxfords on table

We want them to stand with any outfit, from a suit to a casual ensemble of skinny jeans and a plain white tee. Oxfords can do all of those things. With their classic style and practical build, it’s no wonder why they’ve been around as long as they have.

Featured Reccomendations

Last Updated: August 21, 2017
By Emily Walker:

The update was for the FAQs about Oxford shoes and criteria for buying Oxford shoes. Important things to look for when shopping for Oxford shoes include the toe style, type of leather, and soles. 

Bruno Homme Moda
  • Bruno Homme Moda
  • 5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Raised Wooden Heel
  • Price: See Here
Dadawen Fashion
  • Dadawen Fashion
  • 4.4 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Slip Resistant
  • Price: See Here
Forever GD61
  • Forever GD61
  • 4.5 out of 5
    Our rating
  • Non-Skid Sole
  • Price: See Here

Oxfords are the perfect middle ground when heels or dress shoes are just too much, but sneakers just aren’t enough. They can dress an outfit down, or dress it up depending on what you need. All you have to do is find exactly what shoe fits the bill to be your closet staple.

 

10 Best Oxford Shoes

 

1. Bruno Homme Moda

If you’re looking for a stock picture, classic oxford shoe, this is pretty much it. It’s versatile and not too eye-grabbing. It’s also available in a variety of colors and is reasonably priced. By the looks of it, it’s the perfect starter oxford.
Expand to see more
Style Selection
This shoe is available in various shades of brown and black, so you can pick which is best for your wardrobe.

Cushioned Footbed
In addition to the style and value, it also won’t leave your feet aching due to the cushioning on the inside.

Cost and Value
This is a shoe that definitely won’t break the bank, but looks high quality and stylish. It’s a great value with the color and style selection.
Pros
  • Good value
  • Classic and versatile
  • Cushioning
  • Style selection
Cons
  • Leans more towards a dressed-up aesthetic

2. Dadawen Leather Fashion

These oxfords definitely lean more towards the casual side, but could still be dressed up easily. They have a more suede leather look, and are also available in multiple different colors. They were built for comfort and function, but still look great.
Expand to see more
Comfort
It’s proof enough just by looking at the reviews that they are a comfortable shoe and are made to be breathable.

Style
This is a shoe, that while looking great in a casual ensemble, could also look fantastic worn to a wedding or dinner party. It really all depends on the outfit.

Cost and Value
These are another pair that won’t break the bank. And with their quality, you’re definitely getting your money’s worth.
Pros
  • Rubber sole is good for longevity
  • Versatile
  • Comfortable
  • Breathable
  • Cost effective
Cons
  • Might lean more business casual

3. Wanted Shoes Babe

While still remaining true to the oxford style, these shoes are open to a sense of play. Go with a neutral hue, and you get a regular true-to-form oxford. Go with one of the louder colors available, and you have the perfect fashion shoe. Again, it can be dressed up or down and has the potential to assist in any look.
Expand to see more
Color Selection
If you want a tan or black shoe, this shoe is here for you. If you want a metallic silver or baby pink, this shoe is also here for you.

Little Lift
While these shoes sport a slightly thicker heel than most, it’s not enough to cause discomfort. It is enough, however, to give you a boost in your height.

Cost and Value
The price of these shoes depends slightly on the color and size, but is still a bargain regardless. Enough to snag a few different colors!
Pros
  • Color selection
  • Slightly lifted heel
  • Comfortable
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Run slightly small

4. Bed Stu Lita

4. Bed Stu Lita
This brushed leather shoe is both comfortable and stylish. They radiate quality and are built to last and to walk in. They, again, can go with just about anything. They’re very well made and come in a few neutral colors.
Expand to see more
Comfort
If you do a lot of walking, not to worry. These shoes have your back. They’re not going to fall apart on you or have your feet aching.

Quality
These shoes, no doubt, are built to last a while. They’re made of genuine leather and are definitely worth the money.

Cost and Value
These shoes are on the pricy side, but for a good reason. If you’re ready to commit to a simple, yet stylish pair, these should definitely be in the running.
Pros
  • Quality
  • Good to walk in
  • Worth the money
  • Genuine leather
Cons
  • Slightly pricey

5. Blivener Pointed Toe

5. Blivener Pointed Toe
This shoe is a cool, sleek-looking take on the oxford that is modern and interesting. It can work for business, casual, and everything in between while remaining unique to its own style. It’s another one on the affordable side while remaining comfortable, high quality, and size accurate.
Expand to see more
Unique Style
There is no doubt that this shoe has a very fashionable look to it, yet it’s not trendy to the point of going out of style in two months’ time.

Fit and Comfort
This shoe is comfortable and cushioned, which is good if you’re expecting to live and walk in them. It also is true to size.

Cost and Value
This shoe is very affordable yet still remaining high quality. It’s one of the lowest prices on this list.
Pros
  • Affordable
  • Unique looking
  • Versatile
  • Size accurate
  • Comfortable
Cons
  • Only comes in two similar colors

6. U-lite Perforated Lace-up

6. U-lite Perforated Lace-up
This shoe is comfortable, sensible, and genuine leather. It’s another on the pricier side, but it is also very high quality. It comes in a few different combinations of neutral and fun, loud colors. These shoes are likely to work in a business or casual setting and stay very true to the Oxford template.
Expand to see more
Comfort
These shoes are comfortable and true to size. The leather isn’t too stiff, they don’t tend to pinch anywhere and they are good to walk in.

Quality
These shoes are shoes built to last. They’re genuine leather and are very well made and worth the money.

Cost and Value
They are on the more expensive side, but if you’re looking for a comfortable shoe to last you a while, they’ve well worth it.
Pros
  • Genuine leather
  • Comfortable
  • Fun colors available
  • Quality
Cons
  • On the expensive side

7. Forever GD61 Lace Up

7. Forever GD61 Lace Up
This shoe is yet another affordable, fashionable shoe. It is stylish and comes in a variety of colors. This shoe could easily be dressed up or down and is perfect as a comfortable, versatile shoe that won’t break the bank. It’s a great start if you want to experiment with an oxford in your wardrobe!
Expand to see more
Style
These shoes are a very basic oxford that can work with just about everything. They come in a few different solid colors that are easy to pair with just about anything.

Comfort
This shoe is a comfortable shoe for walking and living, and won’t leave your feet pinching by the end of the day.

Cost and Value
These are some of the most affordable shoes on this list, which makes them perfect as starters or if you’re pinching pennies at the moment, but they won’t fall apart on you.
Pros
  • Versatile
  • Comfort
  • Low cost
  • Basic style
Cons
  • Might not last quite as long as a more expensive shoes

8. Ououvalley Suede K01

8. Ououvalley Suede K01
While these shoes lean slightly more towards the casual side, they are still versatile and great quality. They are built for comfort and are great for walking. They are high quality even with their low price and are available in a range of colors so they can fit into pretty much any ensemble.
Expand to see more
Comfort
This shoe is one that is comfortable and good for walking, and can be worn all day without irritation.

Fit
These shoes are very size accurate and tend to fit very well. There is also a sizing chart offered in the description for optimal size accuracy.

Cost and Value
This shoe is lower in cost even though it is high quality, making this pair a bargain. They’re also very versatile, so you’re sure to get your money’s worth.
Pros
  • Comfort
  • Fit
  • Versatile
  • Low cost
Cons
  • Suede is more difficult to clean than standard leather

9. Allen Edmonds Carlyle

9. Allen Edmonds Carlyle
Definitely ranking at the most expensive on this list, this shoe is a versatile, long lasting oxford that is sure to work with any ensemble from the office to a casual day off. They’re comfortable, durable, high quality, and made of genuine leather. If you’re truly ready to commit to a shoe, this may very well be the right one for you, because these are bound to last.
Expand to see more
Quality
These shoes sit pretty at the top of the line. They’re built to last years, and look good while doing it.

Versatility
This shoe is basic and simple. It is available in a variety of neutral colors, and can work with casual or business attire easily, so you can truly get your money’s worth

Cost and Value
These shoes are expensive, and are probably best for somebody searching for a high quality commitment pair of shoes that they’ll use regularly and keep for years.
Pros
  • Quality
  • Comfortable
  • Versatile
  • Long-lasting
Cons
  • Expensive

10. Rocket Dog Lander

10. Rocket Dog Lander
This shoe is slightly chunkier than most oxfords, which makes for a stylish aesthetic with lots of outfits. These are built for comfort as well as aesthetics. They are available in both black and white and have a very similar look to that of the Dr. martins Oxford, but are not nearly as expensive.
Expand to see more
Style
These shoes have a very unique look to them, and can make a statement if you want them to. However, their basic colors could also let them simply enhance an already fantastic outfit.

Comfort
These shoes are sturdy and good for walking. They are comfortable to wear, especially after being broken in.

Cost and Value
These shoes are high quality, from a well-respected brand, and are surprisingly inexpensive relative to what you might expect. They’re definitely a bargain.
Pros
  • Comfortable
  • Unique Style
  • Renowned Known brand
  • Inexpensive
Cons
  • Only available in two colors

In a world full of dress shoes, sneakers, and all other kinds of shoes, the oxford serves as a go-between. They can probably fit perfectly in almost anyone’s closet. They can be casual, business casual, or board-room business. It can even be formal and dressy. They can work with a suit and tie, floral dress, or jeans and a tee shirt. For those days when heels or dress shoes that pinch seem like a nightmare, or for those days when you want an extra pop in your step that your sneakers just aren’t serving, the oxford has got you covered. They’re made for comfort, style, and best of all, they give you free reign to build just about any ensemble around them, no matter who you are. If that doesn’t sound like a fashion adventure, I don’t know what does.

 

Criteria Used to Evaluate the Best Oxford Shoes

 

Types of Leather

Top-Grain-Leather-Best-Hunting-Boots-Reviewed

The type of leather in your dress shoe depends on how active you’re going to be. If you’re buying a shoe to wear to several events or every day to work, you’re going to want one that doesn’t crease easily. You want durable leather that looks smooth and can stand up to a long day of meetings or spinning bridesmaids around the dance floor.

Different types of leather include;

  • Pebble grain leather – embossed with a raised pattern.
  • Top grain leather – smooth in appearance, second most durable
  • Full grain leather – durable, doesn’t allow moisture in.
  • Patent leather – shiny, creases easily

The Sole

Best-Oxford-Shoes-crepe sole

The sole of the shoe is another factor that depends on what you’re wearing the shoe for. Almost always, you want a durable sole with a good grip. It’s hard to find a balance between a thick sole that protects your foot and one that’s breathable and allow your feet to get air.

Types of soles include;

  • Double leather – durable, protects well
  • Rubber sole – has a good grip, not as breathable
  • Crepe sole – a lighter sole with a rubber texture
  • Single leather – makes for a sleek shoe, isn’t as protective

A double leather sole on a shoe is going to be more durable and protect the foot better. If your shoe has a rubber sole you will have more grip but the shoe isn’t able to breathe as well. A crepe sole is a lighter sole and made from rubber with a texture. A single leather sole makes for a sleek shoe, but don’t  protect as well as some of the other ones.

Toe Styles

Best-Oxford-Shoes-pointed toes

A toe style on an Oxford can change the look of your entire ensemble. You don’t want anything that’s too pointed as some of the styles are because it doesn’t look great on everyone. It’s important to get
a style that fits your personality and your foot.

Types of toe styles include;

  • Wingtip – a pointed toe cap
  • Cap toe – an extra piece of leather on the toe
  • Plain toe – clean and simple

The Shoe’s Construction

Best Oxford Shoes-construction

The way the shoe is made is a great way to tell if it’s a quality shoe and to choose the best style for yourself. The Blake Stich connects the upper directly to the sole. This means you get a lighter shoe. It will be more flexible, but will also wear out quicker. A Goodyear Welt is a strip of leather stitched to the insole and the upper and goes around to the outsole which helps the shoe mold to your foot, shoes with this type of construction will last longer.

 

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What makes a shoe an Oxford?

A: An Oxford shoe has a low heel, a closed lace system, and exposes the ankle. There are several types of Oxford shoes. There’s the Cap Toe which has an extra piece of leather over the front of the shoe. The Plain Toe which is the cleanest of all the Oxfords and a simple choice.  The Wingtip Oxford has a pointed cap on the toe. Kilties have a fringe of leather coming from the top of the shoe. The top of a Wholecut Oxford is cut from one piece of leather.

There are Brogues which have perforations in the shoe to allow water to drain from the shoe. These can be Semi Brogues or Full Brogues defined by how many perforations there are. The Quarter Brogue has even less decorative holes and Longwing Brogues have perforations over the whole shoe.

Q: How Should an Oxford Shoe Fit?

A: Since this is a leather shoe you’ll need it to fit perfectly. They don’t have much give so if they don’t fit when you try them on, they are not going to fit. You don’t want your toes to press up to the front of the shoe, this is not a good fit. The same is true if it presses into your heel, you want it to fit but not leave an indention on the back of your foot. You want them to be comfortable when it comes to the width, if they are squeezing you, then they’re too small.

Q: How Do I Clean Oxford Shoes?

A: To clean your Oxford Shoes, you’ll need a mild soap, a shoe brush, some clean cloths, shoe polish a leather conditioner and laundry detergent. Put an old towel down so the polish you use doesn’t get everywhere.

Take the laces out and wash them with the laundry detergent. Brush the shoes to remove any dirt and then soap them up. Use one cloth to wipe the soap off and then condition the leather. Let the shoes air dry, but not in the sun. When they are dry polish them and they’ll look great!

Q: How Do I Lace Oxford Shoes?

A: The eyelets where you’ll put the laces are located on the quarters of the shoe. With the closed system, the top is over this and the eyelets are underneath the top part of the shoe, this is called the vamp and covers the toe and instep. You lace the shoe across instead of like you would do a tennis shoe in a cross lace. Make sure the laces are thin so your shoe looks sleek and that they are the right length for your shoe.

Q: What Type of Oxfords Should I Buy?

A: If you want to make sure you have a match for any formal attire you’ll want to get two pairs of Oxfords. You’ll want to get a brown pair and a pair of solid black ones.

Q: What Should I Wear With Oxford Shoes?

A: You can wear what you like with Oxfords depending on what fits your personal style. Traditionally Oxfords are a formal shoe, but some people like to wear them casually. You should make sure your pants just hit the top of the shoe so they can be seen. Colorful socks are always a good choice to finish your look.

 

Make sure to check out our guide on how to clean your Oxford shoes.

We also have a complete guide on how to repair damaged shoes.