Best Shoes After Foot Surgery Reviewed & Rated
Any kind of surgery can sets us all back a few steps. Our bodies need to rebuild, rest, and work our way back into our pre-surgery shape. We can usually get back to our normal day-to-day routine in a short period of time with a little care and caution to the area of the operation. The foot, however, is our lifeline to mobility and needs special attention post-surgery if you need to be on the move, as we all do.
- Darco Med-Surg
- Square toe design
- Zoned outsole
- Darco Slimline
- Rocker sole
- Removable EVA sole
- Darco Body Armor
- Shock absorption
- Unique bungee closure
So I have compiled a list of the 10 Best Shoes After Foot Surgery to help you make a wise choice if this unfortunate situation ever happens to you.
10 Best Shoes After Foot Surgery
1. Darco MedSurg
The square toe design protects the front part of the foot as a bumper to further damage and also provides the space you would need if K-wires were part of your foot surgery. They have designed MetaShank ™ protection which gives more rigid control under the metatarsals. This is a huge bonus if it was your tender tootsies that were injured.
Foot surgeries have, like most surgeries many different stages of healing. Darco’s entry into this list has a fit that is consumate to all stages of recovery. While your foot is fully dressed post surgery, the expandable forefoot closure relieve any buckle pressure on the dressings yet also adjust to the extent that even without bandages you have a very fitting comfortable shoe.
Cost and value
This section should be switched around as the value you get for the cost is very respectable. Price point can be high for something you may only use for a short time, but the quality is there reflecting each dollar you spend. You may not be in it for long but you will appreciate the money spent.
- Flexible fit
- Metashank™ technology
- Ease of use
2. ProCare Squared Toe
The architecture of this shoe is its best trait. It provides maximum immobilization and protection of the forefoot and toes. This asures progression for postoperative rehabilitation. The rigid sole know throughout the industry as a “rocker sole” allowing a firm transition from heel to toe.
This shoe has a lot of coverage ensuring your foot is well supported and protected. The high ankle strapping secures your foot allowing less travel and keeping it in the correct position. The reinforced heel area also helps prevent skin breakage in critical areas.
Cost and Value
This shoe is in the lower tier price wise and seems to provide a lot of features. Buyers have been left with the feeling of a decent bang for their buck and happy with it. Quality is there as is the technology to back it.
- Very decent price
- Reinforced heel
- Firm support
3. Vive Post Op Shoe
This is a multi use shoe ready for most types of foot injuries. It is stiff yet effective in its design allowing features to be enjoyed by several types of injuries. The extra-strong velcro straps are adjustable to even be able to fit around a minimalist casting allows you to alleviate pressure at several different points in the shoe.
The Rocker sole of the Vive shoe is made of hypoallergenic foam ensures no soreness around the forefoot and heel areas often associated with foot recovery. This foam also is a leader in combating foot odor and germ infestation while your foot spends 80% of the time in this shoe.
Cost and Value
A mid-range priced shoe seems to be one of the favorites. Some have voiced that they used the shoe past the allotted time as it was a very good shoe for the money.
- Subtle fit
- Sizing variables
4. Alegria Alli Professional
Let’s be honest, style has been prevalent to date in this list, however it has certainly not been the focus. Alegria is a shoe that most would never notice on your foot other than admising a nice pair of regular shoes. Don’t be fooled however, there are some great parts to this shoe that will keep you on the road to recovery.
From a generous toe box to adjustable velcro fastenings, this shoe is truly designed with your foot in mind. After your bigger, boxier shoe has served its purpose, this shoe is a perfect transition to the next shoe. Add to that a structured outer sole and you have a very nice looking, very functional recovery shoe.
Cost and value
Essentially, you are getting a 2-in-1 shoe here. Given it is at the highest price point, I would expect as much. For over double the price of most other recovery shoes, it stands to reason that you would be getting 2 stages of shoe in your shoebox.
- Low key
5. Darco Slimline
This boot is designed for use immediately post surgery. The overall larger design allows for larger dressings, compression wear, fiberglass casts and other lighter weight casts. This will allow you to be mobile from day one.
The Slimline features a familiar square toed design that is there to protect the toes and forefoot. You will also find the industry standard rocker sole for that firm controlled step. It also has the luxury of a removable EVA sole that provides 10mm of cushioning for a smooth step.
Forefoot to ankle support
This boot is designed to hold your casted foot in place. The strapless forefoot closure system can be adjusted to accommodate the cast or bandages and can also be switched from a left to right closure to suit your needs. The centre strap made from wide elastic secures the neck of the ankle to set the casted foot in place securely
- Full support
- Budget boot
- Key features
- Quite conspicuous
6. Aircast Short Pneumatic
The most evident feature is right in the name. The Aircast. Built right in, you will find a small hand bulb air pump allows the aircast to be filled to the amount you need to provide you the comfort and support needed.
A generous full boot insole provides a tremendous amount of comfort the full length of the boot. There is a substantial strap at the top of the boot and forefoot of the boot. It allows for the foot an easy entry as well as full support to dissuade movement.
Cost and value
This is a pricier shoe to buy. I believe technology of the air pump is the reason for the price. All in all a good value for the elevated price but it has its return on investment for sure.
- Rigged support
- Universal fit
- Multi adjustable
7. Advantage Mesh Top
A basic design is best made for soft tissue or post trauma injuries but also used by the geriatric client.
A basic shoe that is breathable thanks to a mesh upper and softened material guaranteeing comfort above all. Two small velcro straps are the only adjustable areas on this shoe. This dual side closures accommodates bulkier yet not too abundant dressings.
As do many of these shoes, the Ossur has a semi-rigid sole to assist with the natural walking gait. Along with the sole is a reinforced heel counter and padded heel ensuring stability and support while reducing slippage.
Cost and value
Priced as a midpoint shoe, there seems to be nominal value for all you get. There are other shoes in this range that offer more, yet customers seem happy with what they pay.
- Fits well
The Mabis DMI was created to fit around a lightly casted or abundantly bandaged lower leg.
Lightweight and durable are the first things you will notice about this shoe. It makes use of three very strong adjustable velcro strappings that keep it all secure. They placed it in the midfoot to ease entering with your delicate foot and then lastly around the achilles to secure the foot once you are comfortable.
Add to that a very pronounced rocker sole, the design of this shoe bodes well for any post op foot.
This shoes design reflects keeping your foot clean and dry during its recovery. Enhanced sole depth and high sides, your cast or bandaged foot will remain clean and dry.
Cost and value
A mid priced shoe, this model has specific usage. If you are in need of a shoe like this for its specific use, it is moderately priced and very cost effective.
- Rocker suport
- Foot Coverage
- Looks bulky
9. Health Design Classic
Basic but functional. Duel straps position the foot well for with the overlapping material of the shoe. Not much room for movement once you are strapped in. A higher heel marker allows for a normal flow of design yet still settling the heal in place. It is all about securing the foot.
Sole and rigidity
The Classic provides a moderate rigidity for an even step. With a slightly thicker sole, it provides the comfort while in recovery. These two things combined provide all you need for a basic shoe.
Cost and value
At the lower end of the spectrum, you are essentially getting a lower value shoe for a lower price. The company history is rich, but their shoes are not.
10. Darco Body Armor
Built tough for your protection and endurance of your casted or bandaged foot. The new design has sturdier low profile buttons, better locking system and better bungee system. On top of that, the EVA unibody design assures you have the best shock absorption going.
Starting with the toe box, the rounded covered toe is essentially polar opposite to many other designs. This protection (if your toes can accommodate) would be superfluous to any other model.
With the rubberized sides and bungy buttons, there is like an armadillo shell protecting your foot.
Cost and value
Another mid-range shoe, this is less about cost and value and more about whether you need this specific shoe for your needs or not. Like others, it appears to be best suited for heavy bandaged or casted feet or shortly after their removal. If you are in need, this shoe seems to hit all the marks.
- Thick rubber protection
- Guarded toe box
- Needs specific
Foot surgeries are common among both active and inactive people given that we are on our feet everyday. Be it a stress fracture from worn out shoes and lots of miles or a pulled ligament from going over your ankle at the mall, your foot has quite a few ligaments, 26 bones and a few isolated muscles that can either break, tear or detach. Healing is harder and takes longer if you do not help it along the way. The best way to take care of the two feet you have is by investing in protective, supportive and therapeutic post operative shoes.
Criteria Used to Evaluate the Best Shoes after Foot Surgery
Foot surgeries can vary from the minor removal of a bunion to the more invasive achilles tear or plantar fasciitis repair. So depending on what surgery you had, the purpose of the shoe reviewed is paramount. You would not get an AirCast boot when you are trying gently to ease your foot into a walking motion. Nor would you get a Slimline Cast boot when immobility is key to your rehabilitation. The designed purpose of your post surgery shoe is the foundation of your checklist of “must haves” when considering this type of shoe.
To Rock or Not to Rock
One of the key factors to most foot surgeries is returning your foot to its natural rocking motion while walking forward. The “rocker sole” which seems to be the basis for many of the designs was designed to roll the foot forward for you instead of working those many muscles and tendons in your foot. You will note that most post-operative shoes have a varying degree of “rocker” to them. Once again, the specific surgery you have undergone may dictate the degree of “rocking” you would require.
You may notice that Nine West or Luboutin do not have lines in this facet of the shoe world. Function over fashion is the name of the game in the post surgery shoe market. The construction material used for each shoe should serve a purpose. If it is a soft, subtle feel you need for your foot, you will find it. If “weather resistant” or “easy cleanup” is what you have in your sights, it is out there. Oddly enough, you will also find shoes that DO concentrate on the fashionable side, albeit ever so slightly.
Movin’ n’ Groovin’
Support in a post surgical shoe is an often overlooked feature in this type of shoe as most concern themselves with the “rocker” feature. Both are key as many of this industries customers are sporting this footwear immediately following a casted foot. Once the cast is off, a well bandaged foot will need a continued level of support in order of for the muscles to gently get back into form. High sided, wide velcro strapped shoes provide the support needed to restore your foot gingerly and gradually to the shape it was well before that first ache or pain.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where do I start?
A: Best bet for a perfect shoe for YOU is to speak to your doctor or even perhaps your post surgical care specialist. They will advise you what the key features you will want for your particular case. You can never ask too many questions!
Q: Most of these types of shoes look weird…like they have warped in shape. What gives?
A: There is some serious engineering behind the funny look of these shoes. The weeble-wobble bottom you find on these shoes alleviate the foot from having to bend in order to have a normal walking form. This rocker feature you see is key to protecting the small muscles under foot during the healing process making walking more natural and easy for you.
Q: How accurate is the fit on these shoes? Should I go bigger or smaller?
A: Many of these shoes are designed to fit a full cast, heavily bandaged cast or simply a socked foot. Depending on your needs and given the velcro adjustments on most of these models, bigger would be better. You need room… just not a ton of it.
Q: Are these shoes ambidextrous?
A: It would be fair to say that 95% of the shoes offered in this range would be good for either left or right feet. Best to read the description carefully or fully investigate their ability to fit either foot.