to top 10 table

Best Shoes After Foot Surgery Reviewed & Rated

last updated Nov 12, 2018

Any kind of surgery can set us all back a few steps. Our bodies need to rebuild, rest, and work our way back into our pre-surgery shape. We can, usually, get back to our normal day-to-day routine in a short period of time with a little care and caution to the area of the operation. The foot, however, is our lifeline to mobility and needs special attention post-surgery if you need to be on the move, as we all do.

So, we have compiled a list of the 10 best shoes after foot surgery to help you make a wise choice if this unfortunate situation ever happens to you.

Researched Sources
15
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1100
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
12
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Mackenzie Jervis:

The recent update reflects the best of 2018’s shoes after foot surgery of all types, shapes, sizes, colors, with new information as to how to choose the best shoes after foot surgery and our criteria for evaluation. Also, included are some of the most frequently asked questions about shoes after foot surgery.

Sorting Options
Use Materials Support Durability Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.6
Use
97%
Materials
94%
Support
95%
Durability
95%
Value
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$51.80
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.6
Use
95%
Materials
93%
Support
96%
Durability
94%
Value
90%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$20.83
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Use
94%
Materials
90%
Support
91%
Durability
92%
Value
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$20.43
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Use
89%
Materials
92%
Support
93%
Durability
90%
Value
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$17.99
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Use
93%
Materials
90%
Support
88%
Durability
91%
Value
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$10.59
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.4
Use
89%
Materials
91%
Support
90%
Durability
89%
Value
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$11.95
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Use
87%
Materials
89%
Support
92%
Durability
91%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$55.99
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.6
Use
87%
Materials
89%
Support
90%
Durability
89%
Value
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$14.99
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Use
86%
Materials
89%
Support
90%
Durability
85%
Value
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
$10.00
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Use
83%
Materials
89%
Support
88%
Durability
85%
Value
84%
Price Comparison Last Updated (21.11.18)
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Health Design Classic
  • FLA C3
  • Darco Slimline
  • Vive Walking Boots
  • ProCare Squared Toe
  • Darco Med-Surg
  • Aircast Short Pneumatic
  • MARS Wellness Premium
  • Darco Softie
  • Medline Semi-Rigid
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Shoes After Foot Surgery

1. Health Design Classic

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.6
Health Design Classic
Use
97
Materials
94
Support
95
Durability
95
Value
92
best offer for today
$51.80
Pros:

Affordable

Effective

Comfortable

Great For Large Feet

Adjustable Straps

Cons:

Sizing

This is another nice addition to the post-operative shoe market. No frills; just hit all the marks of the mandatory requirements for post-operative shoes. A rich history of providing quality shoes, Health Design does its name proud with this model, regardless of its simplicity. After all, after a surgery, sometimes simple is better.

Read more

Design
Basic but functional, the dual straps position the foot nicely with the overlapping material of the shoe; not much room for movement once you are strapped in. A higher heel marker allows for a normal flow of design; yet, still settling the heel in place. At the end of the day, it is all about securing the foot.

Sole and Rigidity
The Classic provides a moderate rigidity for an even step. With a slightly thicker sole, it provides the comfort while in recovery. These two things combined provide all you need for a post-op shoe.

Cost and Value
At the lower end of the spectrum, you are essentially getting a great value shoe for a lower price. This shoe is wonderful for those with larger feet; especially, when in need of a decent post-op shoe after surgery.

2. FLA C3

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
93.6
FLA C3
Use
95
Materials
93
Support
96
Durability
94
Value
90
best offer for today
$20.83
Pros:

Adjustable Straps

Foam Inner

Antimicrobial Protection

Moisture-Wicking Inner

Accommodates Bulky Dressing/Cast

Cons:

Not Sold In Pairs

This post-op shoe is great for allowing you the room you need to accommodate bulky dressings or a cast. It has a moisture-wicking liner which helps to remove sweat away and into the antimicrobial inner. In this, the shoe works well to help maintain a healthy foot environment; a critical attribute when pondering the delicacy of the body after a surgery.

Read more

Adjustable Straps
These straps are adjustable, so as to accommodate bulky dressing or a cast. They are Velcro; and as such, are made to relieve the nuances of messing around with laces. More importantly, they make life much easier after surgery.

Foam Inner
The inner is made of foam and, thus, brings comfort along with it. Additionally, the inner has antimicrobial protection to help maintain a healthy foot environment.

Cost and Value
This shoe is budget-friendly when considering other shoes on this list. It is well built and a great post-op shoe. Keep in mind, however, this price only reflects one shoe, as they are not sold in pairs.

3. Darco Slimline

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Darco Slimline
Use
94
Materials
90
Support
91
Durability
92
Value
93
best offer for today
$20.43
Pros:

Full Support

Left/Right Foot Compatible

Velcro Closure

Bulky Bandage-Friendly

EVA Sole

Cons:

A Little Heavy

Designed more for surgeries that involve heavy bandaging or different levels of casting, this boot will protect your foot well. Higher on the calf to provide all-around stability, this is a shoe ready to give you ample comfort and support, as this can be important; depending on the location of your foot surgery.

Read more

Early Stages
This boot is designed for use immediately post-surgery. The overall larger design allows for larger dressings, compression wear, fiberglass casts and other lightweight casts. This will allow you to be mobile from day one.

Forefoot-to-Ankle Support
This boot is designed to hold your casted foot in place. The strapless forefoot closure system can be adjusted to accommodate the cast or bandages and can, also, be switched from a left to right closure to suit your needs. The center strap made from wide elastic secures the neck of the ankle to set the casted foot in place securely.

Cost and Value
This shoe falls into the midrange of cost association when compared to other post-op shoes on this list. It is an ideal choice for someone who needs something a bit more stable and secure than a minimalized version of a post-op shoe. In other words, this is a good investment.

4. Vive Walking Boots

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Vive Walking Boots
Use
89
Materials
92
Support
93
Durability
90
Value
91
best offer for today
$17.99
Pros:

Lightweight

Square Toe

Accommodates Bandages & Casts

Non-skid Rocker Sole

Left & Right Foot Compatible

Cons:

Size Runs Big

Vive has offered up a shoe that is both lightweight and durable, giving a great approach to an, otherwise, heavier build. This post-op shoe has a square toe for those having toe injuries and accommodates both bandages and casts. Furthermore, this shoe is left and right foot compatible. It is made with a non-skid rocker sole which provides arch support and helps to relieve pressure away from the forefoot and heel.

Read more

Versatility
This is a multi-use shoe ready for most types of foot injuries. It is stiff; yet, effective in its design; allowing features to be enjoyed by several types of injuries. The extra-strong Velcro straps are adjustable to fit around a minimalist casting if needed. This shoe, also, allows you to alleviate pressure at several different points in the shoe.

Rocker Sole
The Rocker sole of the Vive shoe ensures no soreness around the forefoot and heel areas often associated with foot recovery, as the rocker sole provides arch support and alleviates pressures in both the forefoot and heel area.

Cost and Value
A midrange priced shoe seems to be one of the favorites. Some have voiced that they used the shoe past the allotted time, as it was a good shoe for the money. It brings you stability and comfort which are important attributes when considering life after foot surgery.

5. ProCare Squared Toe

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
ProCare Squared Toe
Use
93
Materials
90
Support
88
Durability
91
Value
92
best offer for today
$10.59
Pros:

Square Toe

Reinforced Heel

Firm Support

Velcro Strap System

Rocker Sole

Cons:

Size Runs Big

ProCare’s post-surgery shoe is not a unique design but has all the qualities one would look for in a post-op shoe. Many of the issues we have post-surgery have to do with comfort, ease of use, and pressure-relieving abilities. This shoe has a square toe design which acts as a bumper to help prevent further injury while in recovery. Furthermore, a rocker sole provides decent mobility and reduces pressure.

Read more

Design
The architecture of this shoe is its best trait. It provides maximum mobilization and adds further protection of the forefoot and toe areas. This helps to ensure progression for post-operative rehabilitation. The rigid rocker sole allows a firm transition from heel to toe.

Support
This shoe has a lot of coverage, ensuring your foot is well supported and protected. The high ankle strapping secures your foot, thus allowing your foot to remain in the correct position during recovery. The reinforced heel area, also, helps to prevent unnecessary movement, thereby providing you with a secure environment.

Cost and Value
This shoe is in the lower tier price wise and seems to provide a lot of features. Buyers have been left with the feeling of a decent bang for their buck and happy with it. Quality is there, as is the technology to back it.

6. Darco Med-Surg

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.4
Darco Med-Surg
Use
89
Materials
91
Support
90
Durability
89
Value
88
best offer for today
$11.95
Pros:

Forefoot Closure

Square Toe

PegAssist Insole

Rigid

Multi-purpose

Cons:

Size Runs Small

The Darco Med-Surg Post-Operative shoe has been designed with your recovering foot in mind. Darco’s research team ensures that most injuries are addressed and they support that research by addressing many of the common needs of a post-op shoe.

Read more

Technology
The square toe design protects the front part of the foot as a bumper to further damage and, also, provides the space you would need if K-wires were part of your foot surgery. They have designed MetaShank™ protection which gives more rigid control under the metatarsals. This is a huge bonus if it was your tender tootsies that were injured.

Fit
Foot surgeries have many different stages of healing. Darco’s entry into this list has a fit that is great for all stages of recovery. While your foot is fully dressed post-surgery, the expandable forefoot closure relieves any pressure; yet, also adjusts to the point that even without bandages you have a comfortable-fitting shoe.

Cost and Value
Price point can be high for something you may only use for a short time, but the quality is there; reflecting each dollar you spend. You may not be in it for long but you will appreciate the money spent, as this shoe performs well in protecting you after a foot surgery.

7. Aircast Short Pneumatic

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.8
Aircast Short Pneumatic
Use
87
Materials
89
Support
92
Durability
91
Value
85
best offer for today
$55.99
Pros:

Rigged Support

Universal Fit

Multi-Adjustable

Low Rocker Sole

Right/Left Leg Compatible

Cons:

Expensive

Much more popular today than most other post-surgical shoes, the Aircast will look familiar to most of us. Specifically designed to provide you with mobility and support for everyday use, there is, also, no hiding this cast for the weeks you may need it. With many adjustable points, anyone will benefit from this walkable cast.

Read more

Aircast
The most evident feature is right in the name, Aircast. Built right in, you will find a hand bulb air pump which allows the Aircast to be filled to the amount you need, in order to provide you with the comfort and support needed.

Multi-point Adjustment
A generous full boot insole provides a tremendous amount of comfort. There is a substantial strap at both the top and forefoot of the boot. It allows for the foot an easy entry; as well as, full support to dissuade movement.

Cost and Value
This is a pricier shoe to buy. I believe technology of the air pump is the reason for the price. All-in-all, this is a good value for the elevated price and it has its return on investment for sure.

8. MARS Wellness Premium

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88.6
MARS Wellness Premium
Use
87
Materials
89
Support
90
Durability
89
Value
88
best offer for today
$14.99
Pros:

Square Toe

Removable Insole

Right/Left Foot Compatible

Padded Heel

Adjustable Ankle Strap

Cons:

Better For Toe Surgery

This square toe post-op shoe is perfect for those having broken toes or after having toe surgery. the structuring allows you to get around without movement in the toe area, thus you can remain comfortable in knowing that the procedure will remain undisturbed. A removable insole helps to provide you with other options, and this is a shoe which is both left and right foot compatible.

Read more

Soft Inner
Soft padding in the inner helps you to remain comfortable should you need to wear this shoe for long periods of time. Furthermore, the padding ensures a nice fit after surgery.

Padded Heel
The padded heel allows for better foot placement. This, in turn, prevents unwanted slipping while moving about; an important feature when considering the pain involved after a surgery.

Cost and Value
This is a budget-friendly purchase. It is well worth the investment for anyone having toe surgery or dealing with a broken toe. Furthermore, this shoe is well built and should last, as well.

9. Darco Softie

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Darco Softie
Use
86
Materials
89
Support
90
Durability
85
Value
84
best offer for today
$10.00
Pros:

Semi-Rigid Metatarsal Shank

Tri-Laminated Upper

Tricot-Foam Upper

Hook-&-Loop Straps

Cons:

Short-Term Use Only

To help ensure healing remains undisturbed, a semi-rigid shank is present within this post-op shoe. This provides control with your forefoot motion; thereby, allowing you to move easier. The tri-laminated, tricot-foam upper conforms to the foot. As such, this shoe is best for after surgeries involving osteotomies.

Read more

Hook-and-Loop Straps
Adjustable straps allow for ease of use; as well as, providing you with a comfortable fit. They are not opposing straps, however, which means the fit might not always be optimal.

Tricot-foam Upper
The upper is made to conform to bone abnormalities. This, in turn, helps to bring you more comfort after surgeries involving osteotomies.

Cost and Value
The cost of this shoe budget-friendly. It should be noted, however, this shoe is for short-term use only. As such, it will not last very long. On the other hand, this is the kind of shoe you want after osteotomies, as the upper is designed to conform to bone abnormalities.

10. Medline Semi-Rigid

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85.8
Medline Semi-Rigid
Use
83
Materials
89
Support
88
Durability
85
Value
84
best offer for today
Pros:

Nylon Upper

Molded Heel Collar

Removable Tongue

Loop Lock Closure

Cons:

Size Runs Small

This is a good shoe for both post-op and pre-op. A removable tongue is present to help aid in better foot placement. In addition, a molded heel collar helps to prevent foot slippage. The nylon upper brings breathability; as well as, provides ample structuring. A loop lock closure helps to bring you a better fit, as well.

Read more

Nylon Upper
The nylon upper allows your foot be within a breathable environment. Furthermore, it adds structure to help stabilize while you get around.

Removable Tongue
Dependent on your needs, there is a removable tongue present to help ensure the best fit possible. As such, this setup is desirable for optimal foot placement.

Cost and Value
This is a shoe which is budget-friendly. Moreover, it can be an ideal choice for both pre-op and post-op; dependent on the recommendation of your doctor. It performs well in what it is designed to do; and as such, it is a good investment.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Use

Foot surgeries can vary from the minor removal of a bunion to the more invasive Achilles tear or plantar fasciitis repair. So, depending on what surgery you had or may be facing, the purpose of the shoe in question is crucial.

You would not get an AirCast boot when you are trying to gently ease your foot into a walking motion; nor, would you get a Slimline Cast boot when mobility is a key to your rehabilitation. The designed purpose of your post-surgery shoe is the foundation of your checklist of must-haves when considering this type of shoe in conjunction with your recovery.

Materials

You may notice that Nine West or Louboutin do not have lines in this facet of the shoe world. Function over fashion is the name of the game in the post-surgery shoe market. The construction material used for each shoe should serve a purpose. If it is a soft, subtle feel you need for your foot, you will find it.

If weather-resistant or easy cleanup is what you have in your sights, it is out there, as well. Oddly enough, you will, also, find post-op shoes that do concentrate on the fashionable side; albeit, ever so slightly.

Support

Support in a post-surgical shoe is an often overlooked feature in this type of shoe, as most concern themselves with the rocker feature; yet, both are keys to recovery, as many of these industry’s customers are sporting this footwear immediately following a casted foot.

Once the cast is off, a well-bandaged foot will need a continued level of support, in order for the muscles to gently get back into form. High-sided, wide Velcro strapped shoes provide the support needed to restore your foot gingerly and gradually to the shape it was well before that first ache or pain.

Durability

The shoe you choose for after surgery needs to have the correct features and offer the best stability and comfort you need during your recovery. Hopefully, the period of time you have to wear a recovery shoe is not too long, but you definitely need your shoes to last.

As we already mentioned, these shoes will primarily be focused on cushioning and comforting your foot post-surgery. A fact that you will have to face, however, is that most shoes for after surgery will wear down as you are using them. You can't expect them to last months and months or years, but we made sure that the choice on our list would last you a typical post-surgery period. That way you don't have to worry about buying multiple pairs.

Choosing higher quality shoes will ensure you get the most bang out of your buck, but so will wearing the correct type of shoes for your type of surgery.

Value

It's important to look at the value for any shoe but it's especially important to look at the value of shoes when you're shopping for shoes for after surgery. You want to make sure they are inexpensive to fit your budget, especially after an expensive surgery, but you want to make sure they are going to help your foot to heel and that they will last long enough to see you through the end of your recovery.

We've taken into consideration the value of all of the boots and shoes on our list to help you better decide what is the right option for your specific injury/type of surgery.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
1
Use
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
2
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
3
Support
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
4
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
5
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Recovering From Surgery

While true recovery times can vary between individuals and surgery types, generally speaking, it takes around 6 weeks to recover from foot surgery. While this timeframe seems unimaginable, it's vital to follow doctor's orders to rest and let your foot heal. If you start walking or putting pressure on the foot before it's ready, you may end up re-injuring the foot, or initiate some other undesirable effect.
Take your time when recovering, and slowly get back into the swing of daily life when you're ready, and when your doctor approves.

Reducing Swelling From Surgery

Depending on what medications you're taking, anti-inflammatories can be quite helpful to reduce swelling after surgery, as well as help alleviate pain. Keeping the foot elevated will help circulation and swelling, wearing supportive socks (if possible) also helps, and eating a lower sodium diet can help prevent water retention.
If swelling is an issue, always check in with your doctor for advice!

Frequently Asked Questions

q: Where do I start?
a:

Best bet for a perfect shoe for you is to speak to your doctor or even perhaps your post-surgical care specialist. They will advise you what the key features you will want for your particular case. You can never ask too many questions!

q: Most of these types of shoes look weird like they have warped in shape. Is this normal?
a:

There is some serious engineering behind the funny look of these shoes. The rocker bottoms you find on these shoes alleviate the foot from having to bend, in order to have a normal walking form. This rocker feature you see is a key to protecting the small muscles underfoot during the healing process; making walking more natural and easy for you.

q: How accurate is the fit on these shoes? Should I go a size bigger or smaller?
a:

Many of these shoes are designed to fit a full cast, heavily bandaged cast, or a socked foot. Depending on your needs and given the Velcro adjustments on most of these models, bigger would be better. You need room, just not too much of it. Again, it is important to ask your doctor what can be expected. Multiple surgeries may cause a lot of swelling, and so forth. Also, keep in mind that each shoe is different. This means some may run smaller than others when considering the same size.

q: Are these shoes ambidextrous?
a:

It would be fair to say that 95% of the shoes offered in this range would be good for either left or right feet. Best to read the description, carefully, or fully investigate their ability to fit either foot.

q: Do post-op shoes come in pairs?
a:

Most of the time, these shoes are sold as a single unit; that is, you would need to make two purchases to receive a pair, per se.

q: What is the difference in the square and round toe post-op shoes?
a:

The square-toe design is specific to handling toe surgery. It provides a bumper, as it were, and further protects the toes from injury and limits movement via a rigid shank. If your surgery occurs in the heel area, however, a round-toe design may suffice. At the end of the day, however, you need to ask your doctor for the accurate expectations you need to find in your post-op shoe.

Sources

  1. Sheehan, K., What Shoes to Wear After Foot Surgery, article; blog, Jul 27, 2017
  2. hortonsoandp.com, How to Find the Best Post-Operative Shoes for Your Feet, article; blog, Jul 07, 2015
  3. Hughes, M. DC., Six Ways to Restore Foot Health After Surgery, article; blog, Jan 01, 1970
  4. webmd.com, What is the treatment for a broken foot?, article; blog, Jul 14, 2009
  5. Mayo Clinic Staff, Broken toe, article; blog, Jan 01, 1970