to top 10 table

Best Softball Cleats Reviewed & Tested for Performance

last updated Nov 08, 2018

Softball is a fantastic past time and for many, a competitive sport that is played by kids and grown-ups all over America. Fast-pitch or slow pitch, there’s a game going on somewhere right now. Some players are wearing runners, football cleats or even soccer cleats to play the game. But you know better – the wrong cleats are like trying to pitch while wearing a catcher’s mitt. You know that all cleats are not the same and that running bases in running shoes can end in an ugly injury. You are off to a great start.

That’s why you’re here, to find a great softball cleat. You want a secure, well-fitting, softball cleat that will not only keep your feet at their best but let you gain the edge in performance over your competitors. You want the best piece of equipment you can find to up your game – even if it is “just a rec league”. You take your feet and your game seriously.

Products Evaluated
15
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Himmatpreet Kaur:

A softball cleat is a player's best asset. With this in mind, we have compiled the best softball cleats in the market. These cleats will help your perform your best and avoid injury. We have updated our list recently to include the top 15 cleats and also updated our Criteria and Frequently Asked Questions sections to help you get all the information you need to choose the best cleats for your needs.

Sorting Options
Use Comfort Features By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.3
Use
98%
Comfort
94%
Features
97%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$31.99
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
Use
95%
Comfort
97%
Features
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$64.95
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Use
95%
Comfort
97%
Features
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$40.00
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Use
92%
Comfort
95%
Features
97%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$24.99
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Use
91%
Comfort
96%
Features
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$85.00
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.7
Use
89%
Comfort
92%
Features
94%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$95.00
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Use
93%
Comfort
90%
Features
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$38.91
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Use
89%
Comfort
97%
Features
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$56.09
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Use
91%
Comfort
94%
Features
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$69.99
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Use
90%
Comfort
94%
Features
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (20.11.18)
$66.33
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Adidas Wheelhouse 2
  • New Balance 4040v1
  • Mizuno ADV Finch 6
  • Mizuno Swift G2
  • Mizuno Swift 5
  • Adidas Freak X Carbon
  • Nike Hyperdiamond 2
  • Adidas Power Alley 2
  • Under Armour Spine Glyde
  • Mizuno ADV Erupt 3
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Other Factors to Consider
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

Top 10 Picks

1. Adidas Wheelhouse 2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
96.3
Adidas Wheelhouse 2
Use
98
Comfort
94
Features
97
best offer for today
$31.99
Pros:

Nubuck, Suede Upper

Durable Rubber Outsole

Double Stitched Overlays

Textile Lining

EVA Midsole

Cons:

Runs Large

This shoe is designed for either fast pitch or slow pitch. It features a cool camo pattern on the outsole and rubberized studs. It is a comfortable shoe that will perform very well on the field no matter what position you play.

Read more

Lightweight cushion
This shoe is designed with a three-quarter length midsole made of EVA to provide cushioning while maintaining a lightweight shoe. It also has an EVA insole for additional comfort.

Durable upper
The upper in the Performance Wheelhouse 2 is made of Nubuck leather that is double-stitched at the toe and heel overlays for extra durability.

Cost and Value
This set of cleats is priced in the lower third of the range. For a reasonable price, you get a comfortable and durable shoe with a unique look, reinforced to last through seasons of softball competition.

2. New Balance 4040v1

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
95
New Balance 4040v1
Use
95
Comfort
97
Features
93
best offer for today
$64.95
Pros:

Toe Protection

Mesh And Synthetic Upper

REVlite Midsole

Lightweight Construction

Cons:

Runs Narrow

These New Balance softball cleats are suitable for either slow pitch or fast pitch. It’s a shoe designed for pitchers but great for any player who wants a lightweight, durable and responsive performance.

Read more

Toe Protection
New Balance has given this cleat Toe-Protect rubber compound that reinforces the toe area and protects the shoe not only from the abrasion of toe drag but the elements as well.

REVlite midsole
These cleats are built with New Balance’s innovative REVlite midsole. The material provides premium durability and responsiveness in a shoe that is ultra-lightweight.

Cost and Value
These cleats are priced in the mid-range of shoes for this list. This represents a good value for the durability and lightness of the gear, as well as the versatility of play and location.

3. Mizuno ADV Finch 6

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Mizuno ADV Finch 6
Use
95
Comfort
97
Features
92
best offer for today
$40.00
Pros:

Synthetic Upper

Rubber Studs

Nine-Spike Design

Full-Length Midsole

Durable Outsole

Cons:

Runs Narrow

This is a fastpitch cleat with rubber studs from Mizuno, who has made athletic gear for more than 100 years. This shoe is endorsed by Jennie Finch as well. It is designed for comfort and durability no matter the field type. You’ll be able to perform at your best through all innings in this shoe.

Read more

Full length midsole
The full-length midsole offers maximum comfort for long hours of play or practice. Your feet take a pounding running all of those bases and these shoes will let you do that comfortably.

Rubber studs
Rubberized studs are durable and softer than metal studs on cleats. They’re also permitted by all leagues and programs, leaving you worry-free.

Cost and Value
These cleats are priced in the lower end of the price range. For such a comfortable cleat with Mizuno quality and engineering, these are a real value.

4. Mizuno Swift G2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.7
Mizuno Swift G2
Use
92
Comfort
95
Features
97
best offer for today
$24.99
Pros:

Trio X3 Design

ProFlex Forefoot

Wave Tech Midsole

Strong Shock Absorption

Cons:

Runs Small

The Swift G2 from Mizuno is dry, flexible, lightweight, durable, cushioning and stable. What more can you ask for from a cleat? Performance and this one delivers that in spades. This is a fastpitch cleat that will take great care of you so that you can deliver your best performance on the field.

Read more

Trios x3
This is a different take on Mizuno’s 9 cleat design. It has 3 trios of cleats, two in the forefoot and one in the back, that enhances your lateral stability and traction. You have a more stable platform for running, throwing and catching.

DryLite
Along with Wave technology and ProFlex, the shoe contains a DryLite fabric liner to wick moisture away from your feet, cooling them down and leaving them in dry comfort.

Cost and Value
This shoe is in the mid-range of prices. A bit of an investment, they are worth the money for the performance they will help deliver. This is also another of Mizuno’s shoes which allows you to customize the cleats to complement your team colors or express your individuality.

5. Mizuno Swift 5

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92
Mizuno Swift 5
Use
91
Comfort
96
Features
89
best offer for today
$85.00
Pros:

Lightweight Construction

Nine-Spike Cleat

Mizuno Wave Cushioning

Padded Tongue And Collar

Cons:

Metal Cleat May Not Be Permitted

Just like their predecessor, the Mizuno Swift 5 are ideal for fastpitch players, though it's best to check the rules to make sure metal cleats are allowed. These are outfitted with Mizuno's unique 9-spike pattern for maximum traction, keeping you rooted on the ground no matter how fast you play.

Read more

Nine-Spike Outsole
When it comes to softball, traction is paramount. It allows you to be properly rooted in the ground, which is important for fastpitch as it allows you to have proper control when playing. These cleats are also designed for superior push-off for better acceleration, meaning you'll be outfield before the batter even starts to run.

Mizuno Wave Technology
As the name implies, the support system in the insole is wave-shaped to better contour to your unique foot shape. This allows for proper guidance and stability of your feet and works in tandem with the metal cleat for maximum push-off. It also provides strong cushioning and energy transfer which reduces the chance of pain and fatigue.

Cost and Value
The Swift 5 is priced similarly to its predecessor and is on the higher end of our list, which is expected for a brand such as Mizuno. With the price, however, you get superior traction and comfort, which will ensure that you're always on the top of your game.

6. Adidas Freak X Carbon

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.7
Adidas Freak X Carbon
Use
89
Comfort
92
Features
94
best offer for today
$95.00
Pros:

SPRINTSKIN Upper

LOCKWEB Support

Studded Carbon Frame

Shaped Heel Cup

Cons:

Limited Long-Term Durability

Initially designed for football, the Adidas Freak X Carbon have found their way into the hearts of softball players, thanks to the breathable and supportive SPRINTSKIN upper, studded carbon frame and shaped heel cup.

Read more

SPRINTSKIN Upper
Unique to Adidas shoes, the SPRINTSKIN upper is a synthetic laminated material that, along with the mesh lining, work together to provide strong support without adding unnecessary weight or hindering breathability. Discomfort and poor temperature regulation can distract you from the game, so it's important to keep these things in check.

Studded Carbon Frame
Owing to their name, the Adidas Freak X Carbon features a carbon fiber plate that extends from the heel to the forefoot to improve multidirectional stability. This along with the molded cleat outsole keep your feet stable and properly rooted on the ground.

Cost and Value:
With prices seeming to vary wildly based on your size and color choice, we would put these shoes just above mid-range in terms of pricing. Adidas products tend to fetch a premium, but with this cost, you are getting the best in support and breathability, as well as the comfort and performance you've come to expect from Adidas.

7. Nike Hyperdiamond 2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Nike Hyperdiamond 2
Use
93
Comfort
90
Features
91
best offer for today
$38.91
Pros:

Low-Top Design

Lightweight Build

Cushioned Midsole

Durable Upper

Cons:

Inconsistent Sizing

This low top pair of cleats is incredibly durable and allows you a great deal of movement. You’ll sail through the diamond in this should which offers enhanced traction as well, or sail through the outfield to catch that ball before it becomes a home run. Either way, you’re a winner.

Read more

12 cleat design
The solid rubber outsole on the Hyperdiamond 2 offers up enhanced traction so you can accelerate faster and move with greater stability. These are a game changer.

Low top
The low top nature of these cleats allows your ankle greater natural movement, making it much easier to turn at the bases or line up to catch the ball. Greater traction means greater performance.

Cost and Value
These shoes are priced in the mid-range of cleats on our list. For the price, you get Nike’s experience in building athletic shoes, better traction and lightweight cushioning in a very durable set of cleats. What’s to lose? Well, for your opponents, the game.

8. Adidas Power Alley 2

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Adidas Power Alley 2
Use
89
Comfort
97
Features
88
best offer for today
$56.09
Pros:

ADITUFF Toe Section

PROTRAX Technology

Nubuck And Synthetic Upper

External Heel Clip

Moisture-Wicking Sockliner

Cons:

Runs Small

This is a shoe built for pitchers. It has metal cleats so it’s for fastpitch games where the regs allow for metal. It has a number of comfort features along with the performance features of this pair of cleats. You really can’t go wrong in these cleats, pitch after pitch, you can concentrate on striking players out rather than on your shoes.

Read more

ADITUFF
The Performance Power Alley 2 comes with Adidas’ ADITUFF for great abrasion resistance at the toe, for pitchers with a lot of toe drag. This shoe will take the beating you give it and come back for more.

Comfortable feet
The Nubuck and synthetic leather upper is very comfortable and if that weren’t enough it also has full-length midsole cushioning, a moisture-wicking sockliner and textile lining to keep your feet comfortable play after play.

Cost and Value
These shoes are very reasonably priced in the lowest third of the price range. For the very reasonable price point, you get a very comfortable, durable shoe for your fastpitch performance.

9. Under Armour Spine Glyde

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.3
Under Armour Spine Glyde
Use
91
Comfort
94
Features
89
best offer for today
$69.99
Pros:

Durable Outsole

Lightweight Upper

Abrasion-Resistant Upper

Spine Chassis

4D Foam Insole

Cons:

Runs Narrow

Our third pitcher specific fast pitch (metal studs) cleat, this shoe can only be described as tough. It will stand up to all the drag you can give it, keep your feet stable and give you maximum torque and control. On or off the mound, you will have a hard time finding a better performance than this shoe.

Read more

Durable upper
The lightweight synthetic upper is already very durable. However, it also features an abrasion resistant toe piece that gives you extra protection to stand up to the drag.

Stable footing
The cleats feature a molded 4D Foam insole that forms to the shape of your foot. This prevents your foot from slipping in the shoe and increases your lateral stability. The outsole is meant to dig in to provide you torque and control.

Cost and Value
These cleats are priced in the lower end of the price range for the shoes in our list. They are a terrific value for the price given the stability, toe piece and comfort features that you will find in the Spine Glyde. Another winner from Under Armour.

10. Mizuno ADV Erupt 3

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91
Mizuno ADV Erupt 3
Use
90
Comfort
94
Features
89
best offer for today
$66.33
Pros:

ProFlex Forefoot

Full-Length Midsole

Aggressive Stud Design

Lightweight Upper

Padded Tongue And Collar

Cons:

Runs Narrow

Build with Mizuno’s relatively new, already famous 9 spike design, this cleat is great for any field surface with its aggressive traction. This is a very comfortable softball cleat that is suitable for fastpitch or slow pitch.

Read more

ProFlex
The outsole on the Erupt 3 features Mizuno’s ProFlex design which allows greater forefoot flexibility for control. Like the name suggests, this allows for more eruptive power and acceleration for your very best performance.

High traction outsole
This outsole features Mizuno’s 9 spike design. The studs are GroundGrip designed for aggressive traction and control no matter the field.

Cost and Value
The Erupt 3 is designed for batters and outfields with its great traction and ability to help you explode into a sudden sprint. It is also a very lightweight and comfortable pair of cleats for a price that is mid-ranged and well worth every penny.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Use

In considering a pair of cleats, you should consider a set that is optimized for the position that you play. Different players have different requirements during play and so their priorities will differ as well:

  • Pitchers- itchers should choose a cleat with a reinforced toe because most pitchers’ have toe drag that would otherwise wear the cleat out faster. Pitchers also should consider a low-top option to maximize their ankle movement. They will also need a shoe that will provide sufficient support and traction to run bases when it’s their turn at bat, those these features take a lower priority over ankle movement and toe reinforcement.
  • Infielders- Metal cleats pick up less grass and dirt than molded cleats so these are good for infielders.
  • Outfielders- Because metal cleats pick up less debris than others, these are also great for outfielders. Metal cleats also make it easier for outfielders to sprint to reach the ball.
  • Catchers- Catchers need the comfort to squat behind home plate and also the support and traction to speed around the bases when their team is at bat.
  • Comfort

    Cleats are not always the most comfortable shoes but they should never be so uncomfortable as to cause damage or injury to your feet and ankles. Players have been known to wear multiple pairs of socks in order to deal with the discomfort that thin soles and cleats can cause.

    Comfort features in a good cleat include:

  • Insole- Many cleats contain an insole, usually made from EVA that will provide some degree of comfort and protection from the pressure of the cleats. If you require a custom insole or orthotic, you should look for a pair of cleats with a removable insole or that has sufficient room to use your insert.
  • Midsole- Most softball cleats have a midsole that is made from EVA or other compressible foam that offers both comforts for the player, protection from the cleats and responsiveness to compression while running. Read the reviews for the cleats you are considering to ensure you find a pair that has a strong midsole that is resistant to collapse.
  • Upper- Padded tongues, padded collars, mesh or other breathable material and a form-fitting (snug not too tight) upper all provide comfort to the foot and help provide support and protection. Preferably your new cleats will have all of these features and still fit well and be lightweight. Never sacrifice safety and comfort for lighter weight though. It’s worth having a slightly heavier cleat to protect your feet.
  • Cut- If you have a prior or recurrent injury in the ankle or foot, you will probably be more comfortable in a high-cut cleat that supports your ankle. Otherwise, a lower cut will provide you greater flexibility and natural movement.
  • Features

    Before you settle on any pair of cleats you should be aware of your league’s rules. Many softball leagues (especially amateur and slow pitch), pitches and schools prohibit the use of metal cleats for safety reasons. Especially for children. Some pitches do not allow metal cleats for safety or full molded cleats because they tear up training pitches. However some high school, college and professional leagues allow for metal cleats.

    The benefits of each cleat type are listed below.

  • Metal Cleats- These are full, permanent metal spikes around the outsole of the shoe. Metal cleats provide the best traction on the field. They are thinner than other cleat types so they penetrate the ground easier. These are often prohibited for safety reasons and in some places, because of the damage they can do to the field.
  • Molded Cleats- These are permanent studs that are shorter than metal cleats and are usually made of rubber or hard plastic studs. The plastic stud variety is lighter than rubberized or metal cleats. There are also usually more studs on the outsole than on cleats with metal spikes. This means they are more comfortable and they make a great shoe for beginners to more advanced players.
  • Training Cleats- These are cleats that are designed for off-field practice. They are smaller than regular cleats and more comfortable. They do have more traction than regular shoes or sneakers and won’t tear into or damage the turf in training fields and facilities. These shoes can also be better for playing on wet or muddy fields because they will pick up much less debris and won’t sink as easily.
  • Interchangable -Some softball cleats have interchangeable spikes which allow you to change the studs/spikes as needed depending on the field, league requirements or location requirements. This can be the best of all worlds.
  • Expert Interviews & Opinions

    Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
    Sort criterias acording to:
    Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
    Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
    1
    Use
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    2
    Comfort
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    3
    Features
    Rate This Criteria as Most Important
    Selecting A Cleat For Your Position

    Whichever position you play during the game, it's important that your cleats help you perform the best possible.
    Pitchers also should consider a low-top option to maximize their ankle movement, while those in the infield or outfield should consider metal cleats, which won't pick up as much debris.

    Cleaning Your Cleats

    Most cleats are either made from a combination of soft leather and synthetic, which make them quite easy to clean with a damp cloth, and soap. Simply wipe of any debris or mud from the field, and let the air dry.

    Other Factors to Consider

    Fit

    Low-tops may allow a player to run faster and are less restrictive. High-tops offer increased ankle support. If you have a prior injury, high-tops are probably a good option to help prevent re-injury.

    Color

    Many shoes are offered in a variety of colors that you can match to your team uniform. Some teams may even require that you purchase a shoe of a specific color. Also, darker colors show less dirt and scuffing than lighter colors, if they have a concern about showing wear.

    Water Resistance

    Playing with wet feet can be uncomfortable and distracting, and in some cases can lead to irritation and unpleasant odor. Water-resistant cleats are best for wet and muddy fields or rainy conditions, and will work to keep your feet dry and happy..

    Brand

    There are several reputable companies making cleats. Avoid being tied to a brand name and look for a comfortable, well-fitting cleat that suits your needs instead. If you usually wear Under Armour but an Easton fits you better and suits your position, go for the Easton.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    q: Why shouldn't you use baseball cleats for softball?
    a:

    There isn’t much of a difference except that some softball cleats are made of rounded rubber points which can be far more comfortable than the type found on baseball cleats. Baseball players generally do not use these types of points. The games are different so you would expect that the development of the rules and equipment would be different as well.

    q: How should my cleats ideally fit?
    a:

    You want your softball cleats to fit a little tighter than regular athletic shoes to avoid having your foot move in the cleats. This helps your efficiency and also helps avoid blisters. Remember to leave room for your socks. Because cleats are usually thinly padded, players have known to wear more than one pair of socks with their cleats so make room for your second or even third pair if that is your preference.

    q: Are cleat sizes the same as regular sneaker sizes?
    a:

    Not necessarily. Different manufacturers actually make different sizes of their shoes and none are really standard. Your best bet is to measure your foot or have it measured by a professional like a podiatrist and then carefully read the sizing charts that manufacturers provide. Remember to leave room for those socks! Also, remember that you want a snugger fit than your sneakers.

    q: Why are so many of these shoes black?
    a:

    Black is generally acceptable to most teams and leagues and hides dirt and scuffs well. It’s also popular among players so more manufacturers make more of them – supply and demand. Many of the manufacturers also make shoes to compliment team colors and Adidas makes a shoe for kids that can change the color of the Adidas stripe on the side of the shoe. You could also dress up a black shoe with color by purchasing a pair of laces in any color or pattern you choose!

    q: What does B(M) mean in terms of size?
    a:

    This does not mean boys or men’s. It indicates the width of the shoes in two different measurement types. A or AA mean narrow, B is average or medium width, and C/D/E/EE are all indications of a wider shoe. N, M, and W mean narrow, medium and wide. What this means for a particular shoe can vary so it’s always best to read the sizing charts.

    Sources

    1. Western University Softball Association, Is there any difference between soccer cleats and softball cleats?, May 25, 2018
    2. Baseball Monkey, Baseball and Softball Cleat Buying Guide,