to top 10 table

Best Wingtip Shoes Reviewed & Rated for Style

last updated Dec 13, 2018

Few shoes are as iconic in America as the classic oxford wingtip is. Wingtips can be dressed up or down as the wearer needs, their design placing them in both the semi-casual and the semi-formal categories. The length of the wings may vary and they may or may not be patterned with the familiar circular punches of the brogue style, but they look dapper with everything from jeans to suits, in the office and at the bar. Many of the shoes on this list are full brogue, lending them the leisurely “day about town” air that many associates with vintage styles.

In a Hurry? The test winner after 15 hrs of research

icon
Bruno Marc Florence
94.6/100 our score
Materials
95
Style
96
Durability
94
Support
92
Value
96
Bruno Marc Florence
Why is it better?

Sturdy Construction

Decent Price

Flexible & Comfortable

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Bruno Marc Florence
Test Winner: Bruno Marc Florence
Researched Sources
19
Researched Sources
Reviews Considered
1376
Reviews Considered
Hours Researching
15
Hours Researching
Products Evaluated
20
Products Evaluated
Last Updated:
Avatar
By Mackenzie Jervis:

The latest update includes the removal of five products (11, 12, 13, 14, and 15) that no longer met our criteria and to reduce the list to ten products. Having ten products instead of fifteen products makes the choosing and purchasing process much easier and less overwhelming for you, the reader. Also, bullet points were added in the evaluation criteria section for better understanding and pros/cons throughout the list were either revised or expanded.

Sorting Options
Materials Style Durability Support Value By Default
Rank
PictureProduct
Name
Rating
Shops
1
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.6
Materials
95%
Style
96%
Durability
94%
Support
92%
Value
96%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$35.00
2
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.6
Materials
95%
Style
93%
Durability
92%
Support
92%
Value
91%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$69.97
3
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
Materials
91%
Style
90%
Durability
92%
Support
90%
Value
93%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$27.99
4
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Materials
92%
Style
89%
Durability
90%
Support
91%
Value
92%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$59.80
5
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Materials
90%
Style
92%
Durability
90%
Support
89%
Value
88%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$76.93
6
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.2
Materials
89%
Style
90%
Durability
91%
Support
87%
Value
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$38.99
7
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88
Materials
85%
Style
90%
Durability
89%
Support
87%
Value
89%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$89.99
8
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Materials
87%
Style
88%
Durability
89%
Support
90%
Value
85%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$194.95
9
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Materials
84%
Style
90%
Durability
85%
Support
89%
Value
86%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$47.57
10
The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85
Materials
84%
Style
85%
Durability
84%
Support
89%
Value
83%
Price Comparison Last Updated (22.01.19)
$39.99
In Depth Review Top 10
  • Bruno Marc Florence
  • Stacy Adams Dayton
  • Ollio Lace Up
  • Dockers Moritz
  • Stacy Adams Tinsley
  • Bruno Marc Prince
  • U-lite Oxfords
  • Bed Stu Lita
  • Nunn Bush Nelson
  • Wanted Babe
Table of contents
  • Criteria Used for Evaluation
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Sources

10 Best Wingtip Shoes

1. Bruno Marc Florence

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
94.6
Bruno Marc Florence
Materials
95
Style
96
Durability
94
Support
92
Value
96
best offer for today
$35.00
Pros:

Sturdy Construction

Decent Price

Flexible & Comfortable

Cons:

Sizing Runs Large

Our first Bruno Marc entrance, listed above at number two, was a good shoe for people new to wearing wingtips. The Florence is the next step up from that, moving up the price point a little and narrowing down the options to a few tried-and-true colors with lacing and contrasting stitching to make the shoes stand out a little bit more.

Read more

Comfortable for Work Wear
Lined in premium leather with a latex cushioned footbed, these Oxfords will serve you all day long. The soles are non-slip and they won’t clack as you walk across the floor

Fashionable Detailing
Featuring full brogue decorative punches around the wings and on the toe as well as a patterned material between the brogue detailing and contrasting stitching around the entirety of the shoe, these wingtips provide an extra boost of detail to any ensemble.

Cost and Value
Though not the least expensive shoe on our list, the Florence still falls towards the bottom of the price curve, making it an affordable option that will last.

2. Stacy Adams Dayton

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
92.6
Stacy Adams Dayton
Materials
95
Style
93
Durability
92
Support
92
Value
91
best offer for today
$69.97
Pros:

Stylish

Classic Design

Reliable Designer

Cons:

Expensive

For those in search of a wingtip that more closely resembled the dance shoes of Hollywood’s Golden Age, there are the Stacy Adams Dayton wingtips. The shoes are offered in either a sleek two-tone black and white combination or a skin-printed black-on-black option. They’re too casual a shoe for the office but would look dapper with jeans or casual dress pants.

Read more

Bold color and contrasting stitches add wow factor
The most common comment about these shoes is that they reel in the compliments. Whether at church, the bar, or at a wedding, it seems these classically styled wingtips are guaranteed eye-catchers.

Leather sole good for dancing scuff-free
The leather sole on these shoes allows them to move scuff-free on most surfaces while allowing a little bit of glide that works well when the shoes are worn out for a night of dancing.

Cost and Value
The shoes come with a fairly high price tag that doesn’t quite match their lack of versatility. Stacy Adams is a great shoe company, and the styling is eye-catching, to say the least, but some may find their price point a little too high.

3. Ollio Lace Up

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
91.2
Ollio Lace Up
Materials
91
Style
90
Durability
92
Support
90
Value
93
best offer for today
$27.99
Pros:

Rubber Sole

Various Colors

Lower Price Tag

Cons:

Run small

Ollio has a slightly more playful and casual take on the wingtip, harking back to its roots as more of a leisure shoe than a dress shoe. The two-tone color schemes pair toe caps and ankle rounds of various colors with a white core. It gives the shoes a slightly saddle-shoe like appearance though are still firmly wingtips with full brogue detailing.

Read more

Range of colors on white background offers many stylish choices
A white core shoe with contrasting brogue styling in a variety of colors that range from the classic to the novel provides ample options for the fashion-forward buyer

Synthetic Materials mean a good option for vegan buyers
Many of the offerings on this list are leather, but the Ollio wingtip is made of synthetic materials with a rubber sole which makes it a good option for vegan buyers seeking a stylish wingtip for the wardrobe.

Cost and Value
The Ollio wingtip is at the lower end of the price range, and that usually means a slight dip in the quality of certain features. The soles are non-slip resistant, and the shoes run a half size small, but those seem to be the only reductions in quality over similarly-made shoes selling at higher price points.

4. Dockers Moritz

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
90.8
Dockers Moritz
Materials
92
Style
89
Durability
90
Support
91
Value
92
best offer for today
$59.80
Pros:

True to Size

Easy to Style

Leather & Rubber

Solid Construction

Compliments Most Outfits

Cons:

Style Too Casual

Dockers is a mainstay in many a wardrobe and their wingtip Oxfords make another great potential addition. Made of leather with a rubber sole, they’re going to be durable and reliable long after less well-crafted shoes would have fallen apart. Offered in standard brown and black, they are well-suited to nicer nights out and casual days at work, if not exactly meant for the boardroom.

Read more

Casual wingtip for daily wear
Dockers is a quality brand, and their wingtips are no exception. The leather might take a few wears to soften, but the shoes are comfortable and light-weight once it does, making them great shoes for daily and office wear.

Leather Upper with Rubber Sole
A leather upper and rubber sole make these great shoes for wet and dry climates alike. They should resist most light water contact to keep your feet dry even in wetter conditions.

Cost and Value
Dockers are often a solid investment for their money. Their wingtip is a good mid-grade shoe at a slightly higher than expected price point but not unreasonably so.

5. Stacy Adams Tinsley

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.8
Stacy Adams Tinsley
Materials
90
Style
92
Durability
90
Support
89
Value
88
best offer for today
$76.93
Pros:

Memory Foam

Made in USA

True to Size

Cushioned Insole

Buffalo Leather Uppers

Cons:

Higher Price Tag

Stacy Adams’ second appearance on this list is for a wingtip that has the class necessary for the office as well as the quality necessary to be a daily-wear shoe. The Tinsley is another full brogue lace-up Oxford, mainly offered in two-tone options, though the specific colors are all fairly subdued. They would look good in a casual meeting at work or paired with a pair of fitted jeans for a night out.

Read more

Exterior made of durable buffalo leather
Buffalo leather has a finer grain than cow leather, giving these wingtips a smoother finish. This finish really shines when treated well and gives center stage to the brogue detailing and rich colors.

Cushioned Insole with Memory Foam
It is hard to imagine a more comfortable insole than a cushioned footrest with the additional support of memory foam. This truly is a pair of shoes that can be worn all day, from the early-morning morning to a late night get together.

Cost and Value
A pair of these shoes can run a little higher than most pairs on this list, but they are worth it. Designed and produced in the United States with buffalo leather uppers and a durable synthetic sole, they will last well after most cheaper pairs have been worn to shreds.

6. Bruno Marc Prince

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
89.2
Bruno Marc Prince
Materials
89
Style
90
Durability
91
Support
87
Value
89
best offer for today
$38.99
Pros:

True to Size

Various Colors

Low Initial Cost

Multiple Designs

Cons:

Half-Sizes Limited

These wingtip Oxfords are from Bruno Marc New York. They come in both lace-up and monk-strap styles as well as a range of colors, allowing the buyer a few more options when making their purchase. They’re in a similar price point as the Nunn Bush wingtips listed at number one, which make them another great option for newcomers to the wingtip scene.

Read more

Flexible and comfortable
Bruno Marc’s Prince Oxford is flexible and comfortable, combining a wooden heel with manmade materials for a sturdy and comfortable shoe that doesn’t require the longer breaking-in period of leather shoes.

Several styling options
Bruno Marc offers their wingtips in monk strap and laced options as well as a variety of colors and color combinations. This give wingtip veterans a chance to play with the style a little bit, an option unique to this listing.

Cost and Value
None of the styles on this list climb very high on the price scale, which makes the purchase low-risk for people trying new styles or colors.

7. U-lite Oxfords

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
88
U-lite Oxfords
Materials
85
Style
90
Durability
89
Support
87
Value
89
best offer for today
$89.99
Pros:

True to Size

Great Quality Price

Unique Color Options

Reliable Construction

Cons:

Long Break-In

U-lite Oxfords are unique among the offerings on this list in that they offer a few color options that other listed wingtips do not. Along with classic black and brown, they offer a brown and blue combination, two variations on pink, as well as the black and white combination most people picture when they imagine wingtips.

Read more

Solid leather construction
Leather if the material of choice for this shoe. The uppers, insole, and lining are all cow leather. The sole is rubber, giving it a little more traction than other materials would.

Stylish color offerings
U-lite offers some unique color options, such as two variations on pink, a brown and blue combination, and the classic black and white. The uppers and toe caps are pinked around the edge and decorated in full brogue style.

Cost and Value
The shoes come at a relatively low price and although the shoes are offered in a price range, even the most expensive offering is at the lower end of the wingtip price range. Given the quality of the shoes and the range of options available, the cost is certainly reasonable.

8. Bed Stu Lita

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
87.8
Bed Stu Lita
Materials
87
Style
88
Durability
89
Support
90
Value
85
best offer for today
$194.95
Pros:

Durable Leather Materials

Stylish Design Options

Good Investment Piece

Cons:

High Initial Cost

Bed Stu’s wingtip Oxfords are unique in that they are produced to look “distressed” fresh from the box. Offered in solid shades as well as two-tone combinations, they lack the shine and polish of a semi-formal wingtip. They are more casual than many of the other shoes listed here despite their higher price point. They’re a good option for someone who wants a durable, well-made daily wingtip.

Read more

Leather upper and sole make for a durable, long-lasting purchase
With a leather sole and leather uppers, these shoes will like last long after shoes made of other materials fall apart. And given the pre-distressed treatment, they will hide minor scuffs and dirt well.

Multiple classic colors on offer
The shoes can be purchased in several classic colors including two different variations on the classic black Oxford and a two-tone brown offering.

Cost and Value
The Lita’s base price point is higher than most of the shoes on this list, but the comfort and durability of the shoes makes it a case of a getting what you pay for. A higher price tag translates into a longer-lasting, stylish, and comfortable shoe.

9. Nunn Bush Nelson

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
86.8
Nunn Bush Nelson
Materials
84
Style
90
Durability
85
Support
89
Value
86
best offer for today
$47.57
Pros:

Leather Upper

Great Cost Value

Non-Marking Outsole

Classic Brogue Style

Versatile Natural Colors

Cons:

Non-Padded Collar

If you’re new to wingtips or not quite sure how to style them with your current wardrobe, then this reasonably priced offering is the wingtip for you! A traditional lace-up full-brogue oxford like this are the basis of a solid daily style that translates well from semi-formal to semi-casual.

Read more

Easy to Style
It comes in several single-tone color options, all of them neutral. That makes them easy to style with any outfit you wear.

Sturdy Materials
They are made of genuine leather and a lightweight non-marking sole with a comfort gel footbed. Whether it’s a full day at the office or a full day on the town, these shoes are up to the challenge.

Cost and Value
Most long-lasting wingtips run towards the high end of my people's price ranges. The Nunn Bush Nelson Wingtip Oxford starts at the lower end in spite of its solid craftsmanship, making it a great value.

10. Wanted Babe

The rating is based on the average rating (1-100) from all the criteria in which we rated this product.
85
Wanted Babe
Materials
84
Style
85
Durability
84
Support
89
Value
83
best offer for today
$39.99
Pros:

Various Colors

Low Starting Cost

Synthetic Vegan Materials

Cons:

Costly Style Option

Wanted’s Babe Oxford wingtips boast the widest the color range of any brand on this list. They are all lace-up full brogues with 4 lacing points and a one-inch stacked heel. The price starts low on the price scale, though size and color options can drive the price up. Reasonably priced options, however, allow for a lot of fun to be had playing with the traditional idea of a wingtip and give lots of chances for people comfortable with the style to play with its presentation.

Read more

Wide Variety of colors and combinations
Wanted offers the largest range of colors and color combinations of every company on this list.

100% Synthetic makes this a good shoe for vegans
The uppers, soles, and instep are all man-made materials, making these an excellent option for anyone opposed to animal products in their clothing.

Cost and Value
Most of the Wanted Babe options are reasonably priced, starting at the low end of the price curve. Some of the options, however, go to the extreme high end of the price range. So long as the pair you want is at the lower end of the spectrum, the shoes seem like a good value for their dollar.

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Materials

The quality of a shoe’s component materials is just as important as the way it fits the wearer’s foot. A shoe made of decent or high-quality is far and away a better investment than a cheaper shoe made from inferior materials. And while it is not always possible to buy the longer-lasting shoe, wingtips are one place that quality quickly shows. Because of the brogue detailing and the multiple layers of upper material, the substance of the shoe must be able to keep its shape through heavy use, remain cohesive, and keep pace with the wear and resiliency of the other layers. The better the quality of the material, the better than shoe will look later in its life.

Comfort is also key, particularly when it comes to shoes that are meant to look good with dress pants and then transition into an outfit for going out in the evening. When ranking the shoes, the material and comfort of the insole was a strong factor so that buyers could have confidence that their “office to evening” shoes will let their feet make it from office to evening.

As is usually the case, however, there is no one perfect answer. While leather is the breakaway favorite of most wingtip manufacturers, some people prefer synthetic materials for reasons either personal or financial. When weighing the value of the construction materials for the shoes listed above, the overall lasting power of the materials was considered over simply whether or not the shoe in question was made of leather.

The materials quality is important in addition to the fit and you’re better off spending your money on higher-end shoes that have greater quality. Wingtip shoes show their quality the quickest due to the intense detailing and layers of upper material. Therefore, the shape must be maintained, cohesiveness stable, and wear plus resiliency must be long-lasting.

As with other shoes, comfort is important. For the wingtip, however, the insole is paramount. Wingtips are made to be worn from day to night so the insole must be able to provide long-lasting comfort.

When it comes to construction in wingtip shoes, both leather and synthetic materials hold up well. Which material is used is based on personal and financial reasons.

Style

Wingtip Oxfords started in the fashion world as a casual shoe. Modern style rules are a little easier going than they used to be and, as a result, a shoe that can serve as both a work shoe and a dress shoe for social events is a key investment piece in many wardrobes. Achieving that kind of versatility requires a color scheme that can work with multiple outfits, materials that mesh well with other common clothing materials, and a fit that looks clean and put-together when paired with dress pants without being too stuffy for a more casual outing.

These shoes are great in style as they can go from work wear to dress wear. They also come in various colors, designs, styles, and fits that can work with all kinds of fashions. You can’t go wrong with wingtips.

Durability

You want and need a shoe that won’t fall apart right away and wing tips are no different. A shoe that wears down too quickly cannot protect your feet from injury and cannot properly absorb shock. Every region of the shoe needs to be durable from the upper to the outsole.

Fortunately, manufacturers have come up with ways to increase the longevity and durability of their shoes by creating high abrasion compounds and interlocking units in the outsole. They have also come up with special foam and other cushioning compounds that last longer than many early foams used in shoes.

Always check the reviews and the technologies used in the shoe you are looking to buy to confirm that the shoe is durable and won’t fall apart in a week or two.

Support

There is no better way to judge a design than by the support it provides. Most shoemakers know that if they don't give your feet something easy to wear on the streets, you're going to go ahead and pass on them entirely. That's just talking about feet which don't have any specific ailments, however. You already know that "normal" feet can handle a wide variety of different climates in the way of footwear. Although it isn't comfortable, you can get away with a pointed-toe d'Orsay flat, and a staggering stiletto is difficult to manage, but not impossible,

So, what about people who have problems with their feet? That's when support comes into play in an even more crucial way. Wingtips may traditionally be a men's style, but there are quite a few women who rock these. After all, fashion has no rules and no gender. You can rock whatever you feel like, and for the ladies out there a good, flat pair of wingtips may be the best thing for foot problems. Men, also, take note of this. It isn't just about high heels versus flat heels- even a raised platform, no matter how small, can add to an already painful problem.

We made sure to include a wide range of platforms with varying boosts of height. We also made sure there were nice, spacious toe boxes so that your feet can spread out comfortably even in styles that fall on the narrow spectrum. A dressy oxford-style design has no place in your closet if it can't support your feet the way they need to be supported. You'll find that every single choice we've laid out today is an excellent show of savvy fashion and health-conscious consumerism.

Value

Ultimately, the value of the shoe depends on many factors. You want and need a shoe that is durable and won’t fall apart right away. You need shoes that will last for a while. No one wants to buy a new pair of shoes every couple of months and some shoes for back pain can be expensive. Even the affordable shoes would rack up a healthy bill for you over time if you have to buy new shoes every couple of months. So look for shoes with features that are more durable.

Consider the outsole material. Rubber or synthetic materials are the most durable without sacrificing flexibility or comfort. Next, consider the upper design: what is the upper made of? If it’s made with a mesh or fabric material, then it’s less durable than a solid leather or synthetic upper.
.
You also need a shoe that won't have an inconvenient and time-consuming maintenance routine. We live busy lives and we often barely have time for everyday activities, let alone have the time to treat and re-treat and clean, polish, and dry shoes every time you wear them somewhere. So, look for shoes that are easier to maintain and clean. Shoes that are easier to maintain and clean are also less expensive over time, as they don’t require a lot of materials to maintain them.

The actual price of a shoe matters too. Most of them can be found for a very reasonable price, so always shop around if it looks like the shoe you have decided on is going to cost you an unreasonable amount.

Expert Interviews & Opinions

Most Important Criteria (According to our experts opinion)
Sort criterias acording to:
Experts Opinion Editors Opinion Users Opinion By Default
Click on a to rate the most important criteria:
1
Materials
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
2
Style
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
3
Durability
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
4
Support
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
5
Value
Rate This Criteria as Most Important
Where To Wear Wingtips

It really depends on your sense of style as to how you wear your new wingtips, but, being a slightly more formal decorative pair of footwear, they are best suited for business or formal wear.
Pair your wingtips with dressier slacks or tuxedo pants for a proper evening out, or if you do choose to dress them down a bit, casual jeans are a great choice as well.

Perforations Of The Wingtip

There are a few different terms to describe the type of wingtip your shoe has.
While the wingtip outline on your shoe is similar, the style of the toecap and perforations have different terms. A shoe with a plain toe and perforations in the wingtip are called a "blind brogue", while toecaps with no perforations are referred to as an "austerity brogue".

Frequently Asked Questions

q: What does “Brogue detailing” or “Brogueing” mean?
a:

Brogue detailing or Brogueing refers to the design of punches that decorate most wingtip shoes. They hark back to ancient Scottish shoes that were punched through with holes so that water could leave the shoes more easily when traveling over marshy, damp ground. The brogue detailing in modern wingtips do not go all the way through the leather but they do provide an opportunity for decoration much as the jagged detail on the edging of the uppers calling “pinked edges.”

q: Why are some shoes marked as appropriate for vegans?
a:

Many wingtips are made, at least in part, with leather. Shoes that are made of good-quality synthetic alternatives are marked as vegan-friendly so that people who are opposed to animal products in their clothing can find the options that will work with their personal beliefs.

q: What color scheme would be best?
a:

The ideal color of a wingtip, as well as whether to buy a single color or a multi-tone shoe, depends on the rest of the wardrobe it is being added to. When buying an investment piece like a wingtip Oxford, it is important to make sure that they do not clash with the base wardrobe. Most professional outfits are based on either black or grey and so black wingtips would be ideal, but in the case of brown or green tones, brown wingtips would be best.

q: Why is leather a good material for wingtips?
a:

Leather is a long-lasting material that, when prepared correctly, can lead to a nearly tailored fit. It also holds up well to long hours of use and has a mild water-proof quality that can help keep feet dry so long as the shoes aren’t submerged.